![]() |
|
V.A.R - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: V.A.R (/showthread.php?tid=6030) |
V.A.R - Huggybear - 08-11-2019 Having experienced first hand of VAR at Anfield a few seasons back and again watching today ,I am losing the will to live.If you are going to the actual game and celebrating a goal and then a few minutes later having it chalked off ,then the whole concept of me going to watch it live is not worth it.Human error and talking about it after is all part and yay parcel of football.I have no issues at looking at penaltys but these offsides where they are a natts cock offside is a nonsense.VAR is for armchair viewers . RE: V.A.R - Stratfordbaggie - 08-11-2019 Better to get decisions correct in view of the money involved, cannot afford to rely on poor decisions costing millions. Also VAR creates even more talking points RE: V.A.R - Mancbaggies - 08-11-2019 (08-11-2019, 07:57 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Having experienced first hand of VAR at Anfield a few seasons back and again watching today ,I am losing the will to live.If you are going to the actual game and celebrating a goal and then a few minutes later having it chalked off ,then the whole concept of me going to watch it live is not worth it.Human error and talking about it after is all part and yay parcel of football.I have no issues at looking at penaltys but these offsides where they are a natts cock offside is a nonsense.VAR is for armchair viewers . Bang on. Said exactly that at Anfield that night. You can’t actually properly celebrate a goal. Ridiculous RE: V.A.R - Huggybear - 08-11-2019 So you would be happy to accept that goal that Wolves scored today and also the Man City so called offside goal yesterday ,if that happened to us in the FA Cup Final ? RE: V.A.R - ColliersWoodBaggie - 08-11-2019 Football is organic. It has to have human error involved. Penalty decisions may be helped along by VAR. But offsides within millimetres are a touch over the top. And sticking the stuff up on a big screen. FFS. Not a fan of the Americanisation of our football. RE: V.A.R - Juan Quidonqui - 08-11-2019 (08-11-2019, 08:30 PM)Huggybear Wrote: So you would be happy to accept that goal that Wolves scored today and also the Man City so called offside goal yesterday ,if that happened to us in the FA Cup Final ? If we were in an FA Cup final I think I’d need VAR to confirm I hadn’t just dreamt it all. RE: V.A.R - albion_pigeon - 08-11-2019 I agree with the fact these decisions are worth millions and can't afford to be got wrong, especially for clubs like us who don't have the "United", factor. It needs to be a different format though. There should be a panel in the ref's ear for important decisions who are watching from multiple angles who can tell them instantly whether the decision is right or not. It's not difficult. RE: V.A.R - Glosboys - 08-11-2019 If it's a very,very close offside like Sterlings just do what they do in cricket and go with the linesman call. RE: V.A.R - SW4Baggie - 08-11-2019 (08-11-2019, 08:37 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:(08-11-2019, 08:30 PM)Huggybear Wrote: So you would be happy to accept that goal that Wolves scored today and also the Man City so called offside goal yesterday ,if that happened to us in the FA Cup Final ? If there’d been VAR at Wembley against Pompey you may well have seen us in one... At the WC in Russia there were 64 games, yielding 164 goals... VAR reviewed 6 goals and overturned 5... That’s 3%... There were 1072 goals scored in the PL last year, meaning 28 would be reviewed... that’s less than 3 goals ruled out every 2 seasons per team... when you’re watching highlights of all games on TV, it seems more frequent, but at a game it’s not going to ruin anything. (08-11-2019, 08:48 PM)Glosboys Wrote: If it's a very,very close offside like Sterlings just do what they do in cricket and go with the linesman call. How do you define what’s a very, very close call? Do you say within a couple millimetres? Or do you add subjectivity into the VAR decision, so we then moan about consistency again? If you say within a couple millimetres why not just go with the actual law. RE: V.A.R - Shabby Russian - 08-11-2019 So far the biggest impact VAR seems to be having is disallowing goals for very marginal offisides ones that would probably not have been called. The Sterling goal is a perfect example of this, no one would have complained if that had been given before the introduction of VAR because no one before would have gone back to see if any of his anatomy could have been possibly offside. I think if they are going to preserver with VAR, which they will, they have to reconsider the way in which they are determining offside decisions and apply the clear and obvious rule, so that if most of the attackers body is level with the last defender then it is not offside . |