Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games
#11
(10-26-2025, 08:26 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(10-26-2025, 08:05 AM)MrBater Wrote: Sorry we'd have 3 wins - 9 points + 6 draws for 15 PTS under Giles in the first 12 games.

I think he also had a massive rebuild to do...

We've lost more under Mason than we did under Giles, but have 2 more points. As I said above Giles didn't lose many on the bounce, which shows he knew what he was doing. Mason has won just 2 in 8 games...

Mason has lost 2 in a row twice already and has an unbeaten streak of 4 games, Giles despite the hammering losses, had a 6 game unbeaten streak by the 12th match. And then added another 5 unbeaten to it.

It would've been obvious to fans back then that Giles had a clue, I'd ask my dad but he's dead... I think he went to almost every game that 75 season, and he always talked about it fondly...

We won 1 game in that opening 12 in 75/76. 
On a similar note, Fergie took 3 years before he won the first trophy at United. 
If no new manager is ever given any chance when there’s a bad run then we’re heading to be a basket case club.

A lot of people are questioning though why we are so toothless as offensive unit though and whether this is likely to change. Iling Junior doesn't seem that arsed from what I've seen so that leaves Johnstone who is often doubled or trebled up on because teams know he's the only attacker who will actually go at players and if they leave two on two against Mowatt and Diakite they won't be the ones breaking the lines in the middle of the park. 

Mistakes will happen as they do with any team and you have to take them on the chin but if you see there is a plan and you don't get the rub of the green you accept it but our very ponderous displays with few goal attempts mean we are creating our own ball and chain.
Reply
#12
Ferguson at United was a different kettle of fish, he was an established manager with trophy success at Aberdeen. But both Giles as a player manager and now Mason are both rookies, now Giles was given time and I believe Mason will be given time.
We don’t need and I hope we don’t start the Watford way of hire and fire, Mason needs time and more players at his disposal.
Two good things came out of yesterdays match one was Dike really looked up for it in his Twenty minute Cameo,Two yes I know he ballsed up the goal but Griffiths shot stopping was excellent. Let’s hope he learns from it, remember both Foster and Palmer making worse mistakes than that.
Reply
#13
With reasonable owners Mason should be nowhere near the sack. It's mad we are even talking about it. And there is nothing to suggest that the current owners are anything other than reasonable  

This is a very much a changed squad, with a complete overhaul of the defence. It will need time to knit together.

We have also had injuries, and these have tended to cluster in certain areas of the squad. Not having Mulumby and Collier available this week was a massive miss.

We've also played more games away than at home. At this early stage of the season that can have an impact on where you are in the league. Especially given our away record in recent seasons.

There are some concerns. Scoring goals, quality of players we have brought to the club, style of play (we are really a bad watch). Mason's future will depend on how he solves these, but that he needs longer to find solutions is not in doubt.
Reply
#14
One of the mistakes I think we have made with Mason is not insisting he had an Assistant Manager with good managerial experience. Megson when he started had Frank Burrows to help him, Atkinson had Addison and Giles (if I remember rightly) had Nobby Stiles. Mason has Gibbs but he has never managed a club.
Reply
#15
(10-26-2025, 09:32 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: With reasonable owners Mason should be nowhere near the sack. It's mad we are even talking about it. And there is nothing to suggest that the current owners are anything other than reasonable  

This is a very much a changed squad, with a complete overhaul of the defence. It will need time to knit together.

We have also had injuries, and these have tended to cluster in certain areas of the squad. Not having Mulumby and Collier available this week was a massive miss.

We've also played more games away than at home. At this early stage of the season that can have an impact on where you are in the league. Especially given our away record in recent seasons.

There are some concerns. Scoring goals, quality of players we have brought to the club, style of play (we are really a bad watch). Mason's future will depend on how he solves these, but that he needs longer to find solutions is not in doubt.
Amazing how hardly anyone seems to have noticed the absence of Molumby and Collyer,  the latter was starting to show he can move the ball faster. 
And correction to whoever said Giles had a bigger rebuild to do in 1975. No, he bought in a few older pros but there was no huge rebuild. 
I have doubts about the way we set up, the use of subs, maybe the cautious approach to playing staff back from injury, but I really would be nowhere near issuing P45s. 
And for all our genuine concerns towards our toothless approach,  we have literally lost our last 2 away games due to individual errors. I would mark it as Must do better, not Get out.
My choices for manager aren't pulling up any trees right now although we may have missed a trick with Rohl, so for me, what is done is done. And as this is football,  I'll add the words - for now.
Reply
#16
I went to most matches in 75-76 and although the start was rocky there was a belief that the manager knew what he was doing and things were improving, especially after the first to away matches ( 3-0 and 4-0 losses).

I desperately want Mason to succeed but would like to see some passion from him especially on the touch line, this hands in the pockets and shaking your head style don't inspire confidence. I'd also like him to start changing things around a bit and be more dynamic with his subs. He also needs to stop whining about the fixture list as it will even itself out over the season.

As poor as we are at the moment we should be capable of winning the next 2 and things should look better ( I've gone and done it now ).
Reply
#17
I saw every home game and many of the away games under Giles.

It was obvious from day 1 that he knew what he was doing.

I also worked in Great Barr at that time so was able to sneak out to watch many of the training sessions being conducted at what was Aston University's recreation centre. 

Most of the training was done playing five a sides between attack and defence to sharpen up ball control and shape.  He'd take players aside and talk to them one to one on their game, a bit like Corberan. 

I wish Mason success.  But the season started with us showing signs of having a method and style of playing, with individual players thriving in that set up.  The players were obviously enjoying it and played with a smile on their faces.

We now look tired and jaded with little in the way of method and shape. As someone said earlier, a bit Bruce-like.  There's no joy in our game unless we score and then we withdraw into our own half waiting for the inevitable equaliser.  

Remember Wrexham?  They are now 3 points behind us.  I don't like Phil Parkinson, but he has found a way of winning. He has sorted out their defence and got them organised.

I don't totally buy into the "poor recruitment"  argument. You can go a long way with a group of average players if you instil a bit of belief in them and they know exactly what their role is.   

Fucking about at the back cost us again yesterday.  We expend massive amounts of energy keeping possession in our own half to the extent that we are clueless as to what to do when we get into the opposition half.  As well as being a ridiculous pass, it was a result of having a midfielder facing the wrong way and not having a clue what was behind him.  That ball should have gone out to the wings. 

I know fukcall about football, but if I was Mason, I'd play Grant and MJ on the wings with instructions to push their fullbacks back and get as many crosses in as possible to Maja or Dike.  Price and Mowatt can push forward and the back four push up to condense the action area and Molumby breaking things up in the middle.  The ball needs to come out of defence fast to the wide men. 

It isn't sophisticated but we are not going to win anything if we don't start scoring goals and you can't do that playing in your own half.  

Feel free to tell me I am talking bollocks. I'll try not to cry.
Reply
#18
(10-26-2025, 08:26 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(10-26-2025, 08:05 AM)MrBater Wrote: Sorry we'd have 3 wins - 9 points + 6 draws for 15 PTS under Giles in the first 12 games.

I think he also had a massive rebuild to do...

We've lost more under Mason than we did under Giles, but have 2 more points. As I said above Giles didn't lose many on the bounce, which shows he knew what he was doing. Mason has won just 2 in 8 games...

Mason has lost 2 in a row twice already and has an unbeaten streak of 4 games, Giles despite the hammering losses, had a 6 game unbeaten streak by the 12th match. And then added another 5 unbeaten to it.

It would've been obvious to fans back then that Giles had a clue, I'd ask my dad but he's dead... I think he went to almost every game that 75 season, and he always talked about it fondly...

We won 1 game in that opening 12 in 75/76. 
On a similar note, Fergie took 3 years before he won the first trophy at United. 
If no new manager is ever given any chance when there’s a bad run then we’re heading to be a basket case club.

Utd also didn't wn the league until Fergies 7th season.

The lack of time managers are given now are ridiculous, but it's the modern game.

Southampton's manager will be the next shown the door.
Reply
#19
I watched most of the home games under Giles during the 75 76 season and the big difference was he was a player manager. For youngsters it was not uncommon then for a player to also manage a club, the other memorable one was Trevor Francis at Sheffield W’. I remember watching us in the old second tier and Giles every single week was the best player on the pitch by a country mile. That bought him a lot of credit along with a view that he had a style of play, based on what he’d learnt from Revie’s dirty Leeds, and enjoyed tremendous respect having enjoyed a long and successful career as a player. Tbh the comparisons with Mason are a bit ridiculous as the circumstances, the times, the finances, our club etc etc are just completely different.
Reply
#20
Agree with a lot of what OF says.

For me, it’s become apparent over the last few games that the tin tack for Mason is a when not an if. And in those circumstances, I’d rather we get on with it.
Raw Sausage
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: