WBAUnofficial
Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games (/showthread.php?tid=39140)

Pages: 1 2 3


Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Spandaubaggie - 10-25-2025

Not now, but 50 years ago. A bloke called Johnny Giles.
12 games in less points than now, less goals.
Difference then there wasn’t all the noise. 
People had more patience then and everyone no matter how unqualified didn’t have an opinion we had to read.
That young manager turned out pretty good in 1976. 
Perhaps there’s a lesson from history we can learn. Let’s hope so.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Josh1873 - 10-26-2025

It's ridiculous to judge a manager after 12 games, really.

I agree there are some worrying signs, criticism is valid, and improvement is needed. But calling for Mason to go us ridiculous.

Give the bloke a chance FFS.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - MrBater - 10-26-2025

Wasn't it 2 points for a win back then, so having fewer points is more likely...

So 75 first 12 games -
3 wins (current 5)
3 loss (all quite heavy to skew the comparison) (current 5)
6 draws (current 2)

So J Giles lost less, any by October was putting a solid run together... By the 12th match we were unbeaten for 6 ( 2 wins 4 draws) games.

The three losses accounted for 9 of the goals we'd conceded... As in the first 12 we let in 14... 7 of the 12 managed to score against us... We scored against 7 too..

Mason has scored against 9 and had 9 score against him.

Giles went unbeaten for the next 5 matches, winning 3 and drawing 2. So if Mason can pull that off we'd all be happy!

Giles team won a lot of games 1-0, maybe he was the original Arsenal / Megson?? End of the season we'd scored 55 in 42 games and let in 33... Won 20, lost 9, drew 13... We were pretty hard to beat after a rocky start it seems...

Then again I'm not sure 73 points would get us POs this year!

Yes I'm bored Big Grin

Also, Giles only lost 2 at home... I always think plays a big part in how a manager is seen. The first to Saints in DECEMBER(19)!! That's quite a long time for most of your fans not seeing you lose... The second, March 17 to Bristol City.

Most of our fans probably didn't see him lose a game!

After the Saints loss we went unbeaten for 6 games w4 D2
After the Bristol loss we went unbeaten for 4 games w3 d1
Our worst losing streak was 2 in a row Luton away followed by Saints at home.

If Mason's losses were more spread out and interspersed with being unbeaten runs, I think people would be less unhappy.

Results found here, I can't vouch for the accuracy as I was only 5 at the time...
West Bromwich Albion Results Fixtures 1975/1976 https://share.google/XK7cOlS0ghOT5B8Az


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - PatelsPlatoon - 10-26-2025

I just looked up that season. Worked on the same 3points for a win total as now then we were still doing worse.
Can only agree with what Josh said. Calling for Mason’s sacking is bonkers and incredibly short sighted.
Criticising the team is valid but seeing a sacking as a solution now is reckless.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - MrBater - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 07:44 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I just looked up that season. Worked on the same 3points for a win total as now then we were still doing worse.
Can only agree with what Josh said. Calling for Mason’s sacking is bonkers and incredibly short sighted.
Criticising the team is valid but seeing a sacking as a solution now is reckless.

As I've said above, Giles team was much harder to beat overall, and only once lost 2 in a row. They were far more Corberan, won a lot 1-0 or drew instead... They had an obvious plan and approach, which is what I think a lot are concerned about with Mason, in that he seems clueless


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - PatelsPlatoon - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 07:46 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(10-26-2025, 07:44 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I just looked up that season. Worked on the same 3points  for a win total as now then we were still doing worse.
Can only agree with what Josh said. Calling for Mason’s sacking is bonkers and incredibly short sighted.
Criticising the team is valid but seeing a sacking as a solution now is reckless.

As I've said above, Giles team was much harder to beat overall, and only once lost 2 in a row. They were far more Corberan, won a lot 1-0 or drew instead... They had an obvious plan and approach, which is what I think a lot are concerned about with Mason, in that he seems clueless
I don’t know how much people can recall of 50 years ago in a different time, but we’d lost 3-0 and 4-0 by this stage and would only have 10 points using the 3 points for a win tally.
There’s a lot to be concerned with but Mason needs time. 
Look at Cov now. This didn’t happen overnight and it’s taken some years of rebuilding.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - MrBater - 10-26-2025

Sorry we'd have 3 wins - 9 points + 6 draws for 15 PTS under Giles in the first 12 games.

I think he also had a massive rebuild to do...

We've lost more under Mason than we did under Giles, but have 2 more points. As I said above Giles didn't lose many on the bounce, which shows he knew what he was doing. Mason has won just 2 in 8 games...

Mason has lost 2 in a row twice already and has an unbeaten streak of 4 games, Giles despite the hammering losses, had a 6 game unbeaten streak by the 12th match. And then added another 5 unbeaten to it.

It would've been obvious to fans back then that Giles had a clue, I'd ask my dad but he's dead... I think he went to almost every game that 75 season, and he always talked about it fondly...


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Spandaubaggie - 10-26-2025

I honestly thought the way we started this season is we’d lose very few away.
Mason won’t be getting sacked unless we go on a horror run threatening relegation, much the way Norwich are doing.
No one can be impressed at poorer form and poorer performances but I’m happy enough to see what happens this season unless he does a Wayne Rooney on us.
I doubt Patel and Nestor are remotely concerned about the form of the past few days. Ultimately it’s their opinions that matter.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - Borin' Baggie - 10-26-2025

I'm not calling for Mason to be sacked but it's very much concerning that we've gone backwards from the beginning of the season, it's frustrating that we've set-up the same away from home for the third game and got nothing in those three games and his game management - which I called out in his first few games - isn't improving.


RE: Another untried manager doing even shitter after 12 games - PatelsPlatoon - 10-26-2025

(10-26-2025, 08:05 AM)MrBater Wrote: Sorry we'd have 3 wins - 9 points + 6 draws for 15 PTS under Giles in the first 12 games.

I think he also had a massive rebuild to do...

We've lost more under Mason than we did under Giles, but have 2 more points. As I said above Giles didn't lose many on the bounce, which shows he knew what he was doing. Mason has won just 2 in 8 games...

Mason has lost 2 in a row twice already and has an unbeaten streak of 4 games, Giles despite the hammering losses, had a 6 game unbeaten streak by the 12th match. And then added another 5 unbeaten to it.

It would've been obvious to fans back then that Giles had a clue, I'd ask my dad but he's dead... I think he went to almost every game that 75 season, and he always talked about it fondly...

We won 1 game in that opening 12 in 75/76. 
On a similar note, Fergie took 3 years before he won the first trophy at United. 
If no new manager is ever given any chance when there’s a bad run then we’re heading to be a basket case club.