Can we agree that Keef is simply shit at politics?
#11
(06-27-2025, 04:48 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Despite his denial that he is bad at politics.

There is a pretty compelling argument for saying that he was a very effective leader of the opposition.

In a 2-party system (which it was, but may no longer be) the primary objective of the principal party of opposition is to win next time. The dilemma is that - should all go to plan - there's an overnight transition from LOTO to PM, and whatever's left of the shit sandwich is now yours to eat, so you'd better be ready because the evasive tactics at which you've become so accomplished are now of absolutely no use.

He wasn't (ready, that is): Blair was about as ready as it's possible to be in '97, and he was probably the last about whom that could be said. Anything radical needs to be - to quote some halfwit best forgotten - sufficiently "oven ready" to be implemented from day one; so anything radical is inevitably off the table when the priority in opposition has been more about stealth and timidity than it ever was about ambition. 

That's me done...
Reply
#12
(06-27-2025, 09:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-27-2025, 09:04 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This Labour Govt doesn't have any principle that it wouldn't be prepared to ditch in a heartbeat, if it thought doing so would reverse an unfavourable poll or quiet a hostile focus group

And the PLP lacks the stomach to do anything necessary.

Necessary? That's very subjective. You could argue that applies to the leadership just as much. As we hurtle headlong to a situation where AI (one example amongst many) will have an increasingly important affect on how we work, without the bare bones of a strategy or even a realisation we need one.

The guiding 'principle " behind the Govts welfare proposals appear to be how to save money. Perhaps they need to focus on why there is an increasing number of claimants.
Reply
#13
Once again I am here to remind you that the last time there was a Labour party even remotely aligned with it's founding principles and with a decent, proper Labour leader, the country rejected them I record numbers. You get the leaders you deserve I'm afraid. Those complaining the most now, did the least in 2015, 2017 and 2019 to see the true alternative elected. Take your medicine I'm afraid gents.
Reply
#14
Ted’s spot on, there was an option for change available with Corbyn and the country chose Johnson of all people. Labour had to pivot to get the criminals out and ended up with their best bet. There is a collective memory loss on here about the criminality of the last lot and where they left us all.
Reply
#15
Whoever is in charge of this government's comms strategy needs firing in the sun. "#DyingforWork", seriously?
Reply
#16
(06-28-2025, 08:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Ted’s spot on, there was an option for change available with Corbyn and the country chose Johnson of all people. Labour had to pivot to get the criminals out and ended up with their best bet. There is a collective memory loss on here about the criminality of the last lot and where they left us all.

"The criminals"? 

Good grief. That's revisionism of the highest order.

And Corbyn wasn't an option for change, he was an option for the collapse of the rule of law, property rights, the broader economy and thereafter the state.

(06-28-2025, 07:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Once again I am here to remind you that the last time there was a Labour party even remotely aligned with it's founding principles and with a decent, proper Labour leader, the country rejected them I record numbers. You get the leaders you deserve I'm afraid. Those complaining the most now, did the least in 2015, 2017 and 2019 to see the true alternative elected. Take your medicine I'm afraid gents.

There's plenty within Labour that would argue Corbyn and his Campaign Group cronies have nothing to do with the founding principles of the Labour Party.
Reply
#17
Regardless of political colours. Doesnt it say an awful lot about modern day politicians and their advisors?

Most with no experience of life in the real world?
Reply
#18
(06-30-2025, 12:26 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Regardless of political colours. Doesnt it say an awful lot about modern day politicians and their advisors?

Most with no experience of life in the real world?

What's also lacking in the context of this particular Labour government is any evidence of a political philosophy.

You knew where you stood with Barbara Castle, Tony Benn, Peter Shore, Neil Kinnock & Gordon Brown - even Corbyn FFS. Tony Blair simply craved power at any cost. Starmer has power, but does anyone know what he actually believes? what his values actually are? how about those of anyone else in the cabinet?

This isn't new btw. The last prominent ideologue in the Tory Party died a long time ago.
Reply
#19
(06-30-2025, 12:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-30-2025, 12:26 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Regardless of political colours. Doesnt it say an awful lot about modern day politicians and their advisors?

Most with no experience of life in the real world?

What's also lacking in the context of this particular Labour government is any evidence of a political philosophy.

You knew where you stood with Barbara Castle, Tony Benn, Peter Shore, Neil Kinnock & Gordon Brown - even Corbyn FFS. Tony Blair simply craved power at any cost. Starmer has power, but does anyone know what he actually believes? what his values actually are? how about those of anyone else in the cabinet?

This isn't new btw. The last prominent ideologue in the Tory Party died a long time ago.

I'm not sure that's fair on Blair. 

And I get the impression that Starmer has political beliefs, he is just very happy to put them to one side in his relentless pursuit of the furtherment of his career.
Reply
#20
Starmer and the GE result were simply a result of people reaching for the beige after the polarisation expirement of Johnson v Corbyn produced exactly what it was always destined to.

We don’t live in a world of set ideological paradigms, whether that’s uncomfortable for those that would like them or not.

I think we needed a centrist just a much stronger and more decisive one than Starmer. Ideally.

Blair was comfortably the best domestic PM in my lifetime and he effected many positive social changes before he crashed into the sand that the credit boom was built on
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: