Can we agree that Keef is simply shit at politics?
#1
Despite his denial that he is bad at politics.
3 u turns in a week - WFA, grooming, disability benefits. McSweeny and McFadden are not the messiahs and need to go ASAP.
Starmer is being badly advised by eejits and has neither the wit nor spine to ignore them. He should lead and influence public opinion, not blindly follow it, weather-vane like, after the event.
Not a leadership bone in the bloke's body.
Reply
#2
(06-27-2025, 04:48 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Despite his denial that he is bad at politics.
3 u turns in a week - WFA, grooming, disability benefits. McSweeny and McFadden are not the messiahs and need to go ASAP.
Starmer is being badly advised by eejits and has neither the wit nor spine to ignore them. He should lead and influence public opinion, not blindly follow it, weather-vane like, after the event.
Not a leadership bone in the bloke's body.

Principle free PM. What does he stand for?
Reply
#3
Duh duh duh fucking useless
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/202...dApp_Other
Reply
#4
I'd hoped that with a large majority Labour might be brave and reforming. It is turning out to be neither, and we will all pay for it. Within a year Labour has reverted utterly to type, almost behaving like an opposition - where, if we're honest, they've always been more happy bar 1997-2005.

From The Times. And wildly accurate:

James Callaghan’s cabinet spent much of 1976 arguing over spending cuts. And while Denis Healey was arguing with Anthony Crosland over the terms of Britain’s bailout from the International Monetary Fund, Deptford’s Lorraine Chase appeared in a series of television advertisements for Campari.

Only one speech from this tumultuous period’s historical record is truly useful in understanding the welfare rebellion that has shaken Sir Keir Starmer’s government this week. Don’t bother with the diaries of Tony Benn or Barbara Castle. If you want to put yourself in Downing Street’s shoes, find those old Campari clips on YouTube instead.

In the most famous, Chase lounges in the grounds of some opulent villa beside a chinless posho entranced by her poise, class and otherworldly beauty. Campari and lemonade served, he is overcome by passion. “Were you truly wafted here from paradise?” he asks. Sounding like Chas and Dave on helium, she clarifies: “No! Luton Airport!” Not so rarefied after all. As they learn that a new crop of Labour MPs aren’t quite as special as they thought, powerbrokers in No 10 are living that excruciating moment again and again. Has Starmer’s new intake wafted in from paradise? No! The Labour Party.

Before last year’s general election, we were told that Labour’s new intake of MPs would be everything the prime minister could dream of: loyalists and ready-made ministers. In 2022, Starmer’s once and future chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney, set out his plan for tightly controlled candidate selections to Labour’s national executive committee. “I don’t want to be sitting here in a few years’ time with a Labour PM in trouble, knowing we have let him down,” he said. “A Labour rosette must be a mark of quality and an expression of what we stand for.”

He spoke specifically of protecting Labour from the deviants forced to resign as Tory MPs that year — porn addicts and sex offenders. In practice, however, the rules were used to exclude almost anyone who might sympathise with Corbynism. This, the leader’s office and Labour left both suggested, was a recipe for compliance. Only true believers in what we might call the Starmer-McSweeney Project — a politics that put the needs of a conventionally defined national interest and electoral success ahead of the wants of left-wing activists — were supposed to succeed. McSweeney wanted “incredible candidates … who truly represent the nation we want to represent”.

We learnt instead this week that, despite Starmer’s claims to be leading a Changed Labour Party, the instincts of the people who make up his majority are, like the girl from Luton Airport, disarmingly ordinary. A fatal number of them cannot stomach the responsibility for removing benefits from disabled people. Nobody reprogrammed their brains. They are utterly conventional 21st-century Labour politicians, which is to say they are the sort of garden-variety liberal lefty some people around the prime minister dismiss as insufficiently serious for high office. They were local councillors who didn’t like George Osborne’s cuts. One told me as the scale of the rebellion on welfare became clear: “We just haven’t come here to do that sort of thing all over again.”

Starmer’s political team thought they had won a mandate for insurgent, iconoclastic government: ruling as Starmer campaigned, with little heed for the values, hopes and dreams of their lobby fodder or party members. But the Labour MPs rebelling on welfare believe they have a mandate to govern as a nice, normal Labour government that spends money on the poor and needy, isn’t forced into shaming compromise by arbitrary fiscal rules, and ends up on the right side of the kind of history you can find on the big table in Waterstones.

It’s a perfectly legitimate point of view. Perhaps voters on the progressive left will thank them for expressing it. What else would we expect people who joined the Labour Party as teenagers to think? But let’s be clear: it’s not the view of the prime minister, his chief of staff or the chancellor. The rebels are voting to reject their authority entirely, even if they don’t quite realise that’s what they are doing.

No 10’s hands are now outstretched across the barricades and a costly deal has been done to limit the reforms to new claimants, but the contempt I’ve heard from the top of government for Labour MPs this week is off the charts. Some wish the rebels had already been suspended, something Sir Alan Campbell, the chief whip, told the prime minister was politically impossible on Monday night.

Instead Downing Street and its remaining supporters must satisfy themselves with rhetorical punishment. A choice line from one cabinet source: “I cannot express the disdain I have for these stupid pricks who knocked a few doors and think they’re JFK because Keir ran the best election campaign in 30 years.” Another, from inside Downing Street: “It’s deeply unserious stuff from deeply unserious people. They are sounding the death knell of the Labour Party and they don’t even realise it.”

The death knell of the Labour Party? Not quite. This Labour Party, though? The Labour Party of Sir Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves and Morgan McSweeney? That No 10 source is right: this is an existential moment for the politics that has held sway over the British centre-left since May 2021, when McSweeney and Starmer concluded the time had come to abandon their strategy of unity with Corbynism and instead confront its politicians, delegitimise its ideas and meet the voters on their own terms.

They called it country first, party second: as it happens, the country hasn’t liked what they’ve been served so far and the party even less so. The argument to Labour MPs is that if they do not let Starmer save the centre-left from its own weakness and self-indulgence now, by taking unpopular decisions in the interests of long-term stability — on welfare, immigration, spending restraint and much else — Nigel Farage will come along and blow the whole thing up. Instead, Labour MPs are blowing the government’s credibility to pieces themselves.

Twice now Labour MPs have said instead that they would rather save themselves from Starmer, who is even accused by some in No 10 of failing to take ownership of the decisions that have destroyed so much of his authority: on the cuts to the winter fuel allowance (worth £1.5 billion) and these doomed welfare reforms (£5 billion).

If obstruction and calls for “regime change” are the parliamentary Labour Party’s reaction to what one Downing Street adviser calls “tinkering round the edges” of the crisis-stricken state, what hope do the prime minister, his chief of staff or chancellor have of convincing them to swallow their pride and confront bigger challenges ahead? On this evidence, they are not going to vote for a tough immigration bill or for reforms to special educational needs provision later this year.

Cabinet ministers know it and No 10 does too. Does Starmer? Now that he is finally bothering to speak to his MPs himself, perhaps he’ll grasp it too.
Reply
#5
Labour won the last election because the Tories were the worst government in living memory. There was no real enthusiasm for their ‘things can only get a bit better’ policies. What was it? The Minging Vase strategy?!

All their ‘grown up, tough decisions’ always have an uncanny knack of falling upon the poorest and most vulnerable in society. Funnily enough after years of cuts to public services, watching millionaire and billionaires get ever richer and towns and cities have a stench of decay about them, people don’t have the appetite for yet more of the same Sunak inspired government.

No amount of cosplaying as a soldier, wearing a hard hat or kissing various world leaders bottoms is impressing anyone.

The truth is Starmerism is meaningless, what is it? For everything he says now you can find a quote where he is saying the opposite in previous years. We may as well have a pudgy mannequin, in freebie suit as PM

[Image: GuSwvxvXkAA6A1C?format=jpg&name=medium]
Reply
#6
I did tell you this before the election.
Reply
#7
(06-27-2025, 08:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I did tell you this before the election.

I have been criticising Starmer and his advisers long before the election. No one wants Blue Labour, it appeals to a tiny % of comfortably well off middle class, centrists.
Reply
#8
(06-27-2025, 08:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-27-2025, 08:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I did tell you this before the election.

I have been criticising Starmer and his advisers long before the election. No one wants Blue Labour, it appeals to a tiny % of comfortably well off middle class, centrists.

Well, the polls on here suggest otherwise. Centrist is the new Leftism.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#9
This Labour Govt doesn't have any principle that it wouldn't be prepared to ditch in a heartbeat, if it thought doing so would reverse an unfavourable poll or quiet a hostile focus group
Reply
#10
(06-27-2025, 09:04 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This Labour Govt doesn't have any principle that it wouldn't be prepared to ditch in a heartbeat, if it thought doing so would reverse an unfavourable poll or quiet a hostile focus group

And the PLP lacks the stomach to do anything necessary.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)