01-27-2025, 02:01 PM
(01-27-2025, 12:42 PM)Squid Wrote:(01-27-2025, 12:25 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:(01-27-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: I've seen this phrase pop up a few times on here and I find it very irksome.
The position you are at in the table is the position you are at in the table. You can say a team is doing better/worse than expected, but ultimately, the table doesn't lie and no team was saved from relegation because there was a little meeting after the final day and people decided a team was in a false position.
FWIW, we really were that bad under Bruce and definitely had to start to stink of relegation, especially after that horrendous performance against Blues at home. There was nothing false about our position in the table then.
Isn't that the epitome of a "false position" though. Bruce had us doing far worse than we should have been, given the squad we had and the quality of those around us. Carlos then came in and proved it right.
I do agree that the table doesn't lie, but the false position line is never meant in a literal sense, it will always be a hypothetical, based on other factors and will therefore be subjective.
But up until that point, our position in the table wasn't false. If we hadn't improved (very dramatically) under the next manager, we would have stayed there.
Like I said, it's impossible to be in a, literal, false position. It can only be judged against hypothetical expectations. If you look at it in relation to the latter then the fact that Carlos got us out of the shit, with the same group of players, suggests either, hypothetically, we were in a false position under Bruce, because the squad should have been doing better, or, we were in a false position under Carlos because we were now above the expectations of said squad????
The question therefore should surely be, is there, ever, a position that is not "false"


