Maguire
#11
(09-13-2023, 09:22 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:13 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Well it is and it isn't. 

So many excellent players are at a handful of clubs, it's perfectly possible that a player might not be playing regularly fir their club, but still be by a long way the best player for their country.

Zinchenko is an example of this, was by no means a first choice pick for City, Ukraine would always pick him if available. 

Should Maguire be starting for England now...certainly there is more viable competition now for his position, and I doubt he would be starting if Stones was fit.

But it is still the case, England have had a consistent run of good results and performances with Maguire in central defence, 3 good tournaments (in my opinion  other opinions are no doubt available) . Not sure what all the hulaboo is about.

I can see the argument for sticking with consistency, as you say Maguire has largely been solid in England shirt for years now. Plus injuries to Stones and Mings mean we aren't well stocked at CB right now, there's certainly no argument against including him in the squad.

Furthermore it's worth remembering that Dunk/Guehi started the match and had Guehi not picked up a knock they probably would have played well into the second half.

Purely from a footballing perspective though I'm not sure what benefits there are to bringing on Maguire at HT when you're 2-0 up in a friendly. Why not give Tomori a go?

its this blinkered approach that will blight the legacy of Southgate, if he doesn't win something.

Feels like a safety blanket approach. He'd have been stung by the criticism after Ukraine and known that he needed to get a result in Scotland to avoid any further. His starting CB gets a knock so he reaches for his familiar, trusted defender instead of taking a risk with Tomori.

Pretty sure that had we beaten Ukraine Tomori would have come on.
Reply
#12
I thought Maguire took his goal superbly last night.
Reply
#13
Not sure what level of abuse he is getting as I don't do social media, but, if it's personal, it's unnecessary, if it's questioning his footballing ability, it's probably justified. Not his fault he's picked though.

Southgate's insistence on playing him is now borderline belligerent, almost as if he's doing it just to defy the critics which is just mad and could bite him in the arse.

Tomori, should be the most aggrieved CH this morning.
Reply
#14
The wider issue here is the polarisation of football discourse. Said before that everyone always has to react instantly and to extremes. Players and managers are either GOATs or clowns after one or two good or bad performances and nuance regularly gets lost. It's how things like the Maguire situation develop.
Reply
#15
He's a fine defender, worth £75 million not really.
Always gives 100%.
All defenders make errors he's no different.
Southgate has always retained his loyalty to his players and to his credit it normally works out well.
Reply
#16
(09-13-2023, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 08:43 AM)Squid Wrote: All true, but why did Southgate select him when he's not even playing regularly?

A fair and valid question.

Re selections, this Paddy Power tweet made me chuckle.   Big Grin
[/url]

Paddy Power
[url=https://twitter.com/paddypower]
@paddypower
15h

“Kalvin Phillips was in great form for Leeds 2 years ago so he’s earned a place in the starting lineup.”
Reply
#17
TBF Phillips played well last night.
Reply
#18
(09-13-2023, 09:39 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Not sure what level of abuse he is getting as I don't do social media, but, if it's personal, it's unnecessary, if it's questioning his footballing ability, it's probably justified. Not his fault he's picked though.

Southgate's insistence on playing him is now borderline belligerent, almost as if he's doing it just to defy the critics which is just mad and could bite him in the arse.

Tomori, should be the most aggrieved CH this morning.

And good on you Bob.

Social media is generally a shit tip where many miserable nobodies can take a pop at anyone without recourse.
Reply
#19
(09-13-2023, 10:08 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:39 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Not sure what level of abuse he is getting as I don't do social media, but, if it's personal, it's unnecessary, if it's questioning his footballing ability, it's probably justified. Not his fault he's picked though.

Southgate's insistence on playing him is now borderline belligerent, almost as if he's doing it just to defy the critics which is just mad and could bite him in the arse.

Tomori, should be the most aggrieved CH this morning.

And good on you Bob.

Social media is generally a shit tip where many miserable nobodies can take a pop at anyone without recourse.
Not on me high horse or anything it just doesn't appeal to me. I've tried it but don't get it.
Reply
#20
(09-13-2023, 10:08 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-13-2023, 09:39 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Not sure what level of abuse he is getting as I don't do social media, but, if it's personal, it's unnecessary, if it's questioning his footballing ability, it's probably justified. Not his fault he's picked though.

Southgate's insistence on playing him is now borderline belligerent, almost as if he's doing it just to defy the critics which is just mad and could bite him in the arse.

Tomori, should be the most aggrieved CH this morning.

And good on you Bob.

Social media is generally a shit tip where many miserable nobodies can take a pop at anyone without recourse.

Sounds familiar.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: