Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-14-2023, 01:44 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Three crap centre backs are worse than two crap centre backs. A badly-coached defence, or a defence that is out of its depth with the way it's expected to play will be crap whether it has one or ten players in it.
I've never liked the back three, which for us is always a back five anyway. Does it work? It was Townsend not Pieters losing those far post headers as Swansea piled those left wing corners in late on. My concern is that Carlos isn't very good at defence. Last season we had O'Shea and Pieters, class players at the opposite ends of their respective careers. Ajayi and Bartley will not change or improve much at their ages. Can CC and his coaching team develop and improve younger players like Kipre and Taylor? I'm not sure.
"Not very good at defence"
We conceded four goals in his first ten games in charge. He took a Bruce team with one of the worst defensive setups in the division and turned it into one of the best, in a fortnight.
Would be interesting to see the make up of the defence during those 10 games.
CC's Huddersfield side in his first season were woeful defensively and conceded the most goals in the division, only surviving due to being able to score more than the ones in the bottom 3. He then added Tom Lees in the summer and this massively improved, so I think it's a fair question to ask if he can coach a defensive structure, particularly given the various challenges each defensive combination here will have.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-14-2023, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:44 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Three crap centre backs are worse than two crap centre backs. A badly-coached defence, or a defence that is out of its depth with the way it's expected to play will be crap whether it has one or ten players in it.
I've never liked the back three, which for us is always a back five anyway. Does it work? It was Townsend not Pieters losing those far post headers as Swansea piled those left wing corners in late on. My concern is that Carlos isn't very good at defence. Last season we had O'Shea and Pieters, class players at the opposite ends of their respective careers. Ajayi and Bartley will not change or improve much at their ages. Can CC and his coaching team develop and improve younger players like Kipre and Taylor? I'm not sure.
"Not very good at defence"
We conceded four goals in his first ten games in charge. He took a Bruce team with one of the worst defensive setups in the division and turned it into one of the best, in a fortnight.
Would be interesting to see the make up of the defence during those 10 games.
CC's Huddersfield side in his first season were woeful defensively and conceded the most goals in the division, only surviving due to being able to score more than the ones in the bottom 3. He then added Tom Lees in the summer and this massively improved, so I think it's a fair question to ask if he can coach a defensive structure, particularly given the various challenges each defensive combination here will have.
Furlong, Bartley, O'Shea, Townsend for the most part I would expect. The injury to Bartley brought Pieters into the side and he did reasonably well. He completely ripped up what the same group of defenders had been doing and for a couple of months made us nigh on impossible to score against.
Finding similar success with Ajayi, Kipre, Bartley and Taylor would be mighty impressive but to question his ability to do it given what has gone before seems harsh and way OTT.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(08-14-2023, 01:57 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:44 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-14-2023, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Three crap centre backs are worse than two crap centre backs. A badly-coached defence, or a defence that is out of its depth with the way it's expected to play will be crap whether it has one or ten players in it.
I've never liked the back three, which for us is always a back five anyway. Does it work? It was Townsend not Pieters losing those far post headers as Swansea piled those left wing corners in late on. My concern is that Carlos isn't very good at defence. Last season we had O'Shea and Pieters, class players at the opposite ends of their respective careers. Ajayi and Bartley will not change or improve much at their ages. Can CC and his coaching team develop and improve younger players like Kipre and Taylor? I'm not sure.
"Not very good at defence"
We conceded four goals in his first ten games in charge. He took a Bruce team with one of the worst defensive setups in the division and turned it into one of the best, in a fortnight.
Would be interesting to see the make up of the defence during those 10 games.
CC's Huddersfield side in his first season were woeful defensively and conceded the most goals in the division, only surviving due to being able to score more than the ones in the bottom 3. He then added Tom Lees in the summer and this massively improved, so I think it's a fair question to ask if he can coach a defensive structure, particularly given the various challenges each defensive combination here will have.
Furlong, Bartley, O'Shea, Townsend for the most part I would expect. The injury to Bartley brought Pieters into the side and he did reasonably well. He completely ripped up what the same group of defenders had been doing and for a couple of months made us nigh on impossible to score against.
Finding similar success with Ajayi, Kipre, Bartley and Taylor would be mighty impressive but to question his ability to do it given what has gone before seems harsh and way OTT.
Looking at the defenders CC had available at Hudds in his first season, they were aging but solid old pros... Keogh, Stearman, Elphwick, Naby Sarr, Schindler, so they shouldn't have had the defensive record they had that season. It seems he chopped and changed them a lot as several of those players had 15-20 appearances, though he may well have been unlucky with injuries.
I get the impression CC is better when he has a leader at the back... Tom Lees is an excellent defender who had a few injury prone years, who had he stayed fit, would have been a PL player. and then he managed to add Colwill from Chelsea who will play for England in time. It was the perfect blend of pace and gutsy old pro defending.
We have 2 and a half seasons to judge CC's defensive coaching on, one where he did very well but had 2 excellent players at the heart of the defence, one where he did awfully, but seems there were issues with injuries and ageing players, and then half a season with us which saw mixed results. Some excellent defensive play at home, and other than his first couple games, has generally been very poor away.
Think it's a bit early to be saying either way, but it needs to improve here!
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
I'm not sure he would have gone with a 3 if BTA was fit Saturday
It's nice to have the option and we do have five "capable" centre halves at this level so mad not to utilise and work on the option
I still think 4-2-31 suits us best when everybody is fit and up to speed, also need the square pegs in square holes, not Chalboh, Molumby and Okay in midfield for example
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 1,100
Threads: 123
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
3
I don’t care as long as we are not zonal marking for set pieces
|