WBAUnofficial
3 or 4? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 3 or 4? (/showthread.php?tid=30900)

Pages: 1 2


3 or 4? - Lurker#3 - 08-14-2023

Would you stick with the back 3 or go back to a 4?

I am always a fan of a back 3 as it stops you getting sucked into a back 6 when defending and allows you to commit more players forward in central areas. 

I think it also allows Semi to be more reckless which is where his strength lies. I still can't see the point of Kipre mind.


RE: 3 or 4? - Atomic - 08-14-2023

(08-14-2023, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Would you stick with the back 3 or go back to a 4?

I am always a fan of a back 3 as it stops you getting sucked into a back 6 when defending and allows you to commit more players forward in central areas. 

I think it also allows Semi to be more reckless which is where his strength lies. I still can't see the point of Kipre mind.

It depends on the squad you have unless you have the finances and freedom and influence (as a head coach) to assemble the squad you desire.


RE: 3 or 4? - Ted Maul - 08-14-2023

Pros:
- Frees up our central midfield a bit more.
- Plays to the strengths of our current defenders.
- Will give us the best possible chance to bed Taylor into the side as he's used to playing in a three.

Cons:
- Relies very heavily on good wing backs to be effective and I am not confident we have that.


RE: 3 or 4? - SuperBob2002 - 08-14-2023

It'd provide Townsend and Furlong more cover in terms of having the ability for the left/right centre half to cover them when they're doubled due to Phillips and Wallace not tracking back and leaving them exposed (obviously not Phillips ATM given he'll be getting a run up top). The Wallace and Phillips winger combination is a massive weakness of ours and regular leaves Townsend and Furlong being doubled by opposition forwards.

My issue is we don't have 3 quality centre halves at the club. This combined with the aforementioned lack of cover from our wingers makes our full backs seem worse than they actually are. Both Townsend and Furlong are more than capable players at this level. They aren't the issue.


RE: 3 or 4? - CaptainFantastico - 08-14-2023

With the current options at centre half a back 3/5 is essential


RE: 3 or 4? - MrFizz - 08-14-2023

Always preferred a 3 with wing-backs, and with our rather unreliable centre-halves it means theres another 2 there if one has a brain fart!


RE: 3 or 4? - Shabby Russian - 08-14-2023

I don't like a back 3.

In some instances it is the best formation for a team, but even then there are inherent weaknesses.

Chelsea, currently are the club most suited to a back 3, but even then I think it leaves them short in central midfield, or short of goalscorers.

I don't think we have wing backs that can make the system work for us on a long term basis. Not against using it for specific games, or changing during a game if necessary.


RE: 3 or 4? - SW4Baggie - 08-14-2023

(08-14-2023, 12:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Would you stick with the back 3 or go back to a 4?

I am always a fan of a back 3 as it stops you getting sucked into a back 6 when defending and allows you to commit more players forward in central areas. 

I think it also allows Semi to be more reckless which is where his strength lies. I still can't see the point of Kipre mind.

Kipré is by far the strongest passer out from the back, he rarely gives the ball away and made several very positive passes upfield. Given what CC wants the back line to do this season, I expect we will see plenty of him. 

As it stands I think I’d go with Kipre and Ajayi either side of Bartley, but the fact the latter has been a sub in the last 2 doesn’t bode well for his fitness. Hoping Taylor can take that role as the season goes on, but it would be a huge ask for such a young and inexperienced CB to come in and take a very vocal role in coordinating a back 3.


RE: 3 or 4? - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-14-2023

Three crap centre backs are worse than two crap centre backs. A badly-coached defence, or a defence that is out of its depth with the way it's expected to play will be crap whether it has one or ten players in it.

I've never liked the back three, which for us is always a back five anyway. Does it work? It was Townsend not Pieters losing those far post headers as Swansea piled those left wing corners in late on. My concern is that Carlos isn't very good at defence. Last season we had O'Shea and Pieters, class players at the opposite ends of their respective careers. Ajayi and Bartley will not change or improve much at their ages. Can CC and his coaching team develop and improve younger players like Kipre and Taylor? I'm not sure.


RE: 3 or 4? - Ted Maul - 08-14-2023

(08-14-2023, 01:42 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Three crap centre backs are worse than two crap centre backs. A badly-coached defence, or a defence that is out of its depth with the way it's expected to play will be crap whether it has one or ten players in it.

I've never liked the back three, which for us is always a back five anyway. Does it work? It was Townsend not Pieters losing those far post headers as Swansea piled those left wing corners in late on. My concern is that Carlos isn't very good at defence. Last season we had O'Shea and Pieters, class players at the opposite ends of their respective careers. Ajayi and Bartley will not change or improve much at their ages. Can CC and his coaching team develop and improve younger players like Kipre and Taylor? I'm not sure.

"Not very good at defence"

We conceded four goals in his first ten games in charge. He took a Bruce team with one of the worst defensive setups in the division and turned it into one of the best, in a fortnight.