Style of play hurting our forwards?
#11
(11-15-2021, 02:20 PM)Hopalong Wrote: I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about.   Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? 

I do see us start every game on the front foot playing with 3 strikers/wingers.

I do see teams completely changing their shape parking with bus with often 6 defenders. (Like we did last season at Man City and Liverpool). 

I do see our players in most games missing gilt-edged chances and conversely making similar mistakes at the other end which have cost us every defeat and other points (plus playing 12 men at Fulham). 

I see injuries to key players which has meant a loss of some continuity (O'Shea, Mowatt, Clarke). 

I see Diangana who ripped this league to shreds two seasons ago looking like a little boy lost and no longer seemingly capable of playing football. 

And yet we are third in the league with automatic promotion still in our own hands (Bournemouth/Fulham have to play each other twice and we have to play both of them at home).  

Far too early to be writing Val and the Albion off.

I like this a lot ^^^^
Reply
#12
In my opinion Val needs to be more adventurous and make big calls when they are needed. He's very quick to take off the likes of Grady & Robinson if they're having a bad game, but Grant is locked in on the left pushing the others to play out of position. Grant is the best finisher no doubt, but his general play is really poor.

I'd like to see him sacrifice a defender every now and then to overload the midfield against sides who aren't attacking at all. Yes the defenders play forward and in their half, but would it not be beneficial to have a Molumby/Snodgrass on the ball rather than Ajayi/Kipre?

It looked like we had stumbled across a decent midfield duo against Bristol City with those two, only for it to be shelved as soon as Livermore was available again. Why is Livermore undropable? He's a very limited player with the ball at his feet and he contributes to us struggling to break sides down. He's great for Val's pressing style, but we know now that teams won't let us do it, so why continue picking Jake in those games.

We can't blame everything on how the opposition set up, do teams not try to do the same at Fulham and Bournemouth?
Reply
#13
The last couple of home games, we haven't looked dangerous in front of goal, despite playing 3 forwards. I don't think it's necessarily down to the style of play, more the personnel. Against Boro, the three forward players are all arguably more effective playing down the left, so probably shouldn't be a surprise that they didn't gel and compliment one another. If we had played three left backs at the back, the same positional confusion would take place.

I think we need Val to have the right blend of players for his three forwards before judging. The problem we have is Grady, Grant & Robbo were all signed last season, and are on long contracts. To get the balance right we probably need to off-load one of them. Hugill is only useful for cameos off the bench, and we know Matty Philips will have a run of good & bad games, and lacks consistency over a period of games.

We desperately need a good all-round target man, and perhaps one of the younger players like Tulloch or Morton could do a job as the third attacker in this system, with Grady, Grant or Robbo the other forward.
Reply
#14
(11-15-2021, 03:16 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: The last couple of home games, we haven't looked dangerous in front of goal, despite playing 3 forwards. I don't think it's necessarily down to the style of play, more the personnel. Against Boro, the three forward players are all arguably more effective playing down the left, so probably shouldn't be a surprise that they didn't gel and compliment one another. If we had played three left backs at the back, the same positional confusion would take place.

I think we need Val to have the right blend of players for his three forwards before judging. The problem we have is Grady, Grant & Robbo were all signed last season, and are on long contracts. To get the balance right we probably need to off-load one of them. Hugill is only useful for cameos off the bench, and we know Matty Philips will have a run of good & bad games, and lacks consistency over a period of games.

We desperately need a good all-round target man, and perhaps one of the younger players like Tulloch or Morton could do a job as the third attacker in this system, with Grady, Grant or Robbo the other forward.

You might be right about this especially with our limited funds. Who would you get rid of out of the 3 though? Knowing us we'll probably get about 500k for Grady
Reply
#15
(11-15-2021, 03:23 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 03:16 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: The last couple of home games, we haven't looked dangerous in front of goal, despite playing 3 forwards. I don't think it's necessarily down to the style of play, more the personnel. Against Boro, the three forward players are all arguably more effective playing down the left, so probably shouldn't be a surprise that they didn't gel and compliment one another. If we had played three left backs at the back, the same positional confusion would take place.

I think we need Val to have the right blend of players for his three forwards before judging. The problem we have is Grady, Grant & Robbo were all signed last season, and are on long contracts. To get the balance right we probably need to off-load one of them. Hugill is only useful for cameos off the bench, and we know Matty Philips will have a run of good & bad games, and lacks consistency over a period of games.

We desperately need a good all-round target man, and perhaps one of the younger players like Tulloch or Morton could do a job as the third attacker in this system, with Grady, Grant or Robbo the other forward.

You might be right about this especially with our limited funds. Who would you get rid of out of the 3 though? Knowing us we'll probably get about 500k for Grady

Right now, I'd probably say Grady, but we might regret it, particularly if we let him go on the cheap. I'd see how the next 6 or 7 weeks go, and then make a call. Perhaps an option would be to loan out Grady, to fund a loan in.
Reply
#16
Hopalong Wrote:I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about.   Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? 

I do see us start every game on the front foot playing with 3 strikers/wingers.

I do see teams completely changing their shape parking with bus with often 6 defenders. (Like we did last season at Man City and Liverpool). 

I do see our players in most games missing gilt-edged chances and conversely making similar mistakes at the other end which have cost us every defeat and other points (plus playing 12 men at Fulham). 

I see injuries to key players which has meant a loss of some continuity (O'Shea, Mowatt, Clarke). 

I see Diangana who ripped this league to shreds two seasons ago looking like a little boy lost and no longer seemingly capable of playing football. 

And yet we are third in the league with automatic promotion still in our own hands (Bournemouth/Fulham have to play each other twice and we have to play both of them at home).  

Far too early to be writing Val and the Albion off.
Top post, Hop.
IMO, a proper no.9 would transform this team. We currently are playing 3 wingers as strikers. None of them are capable of holding the ball up.
(Or it might simply be all Vals fault, telling the forwards to give the ball to the opposition and to try not to score...)
Reply
#17
(11-15-2021, 07:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Hopalong Wrote:I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about.   Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? 

I do see us start every game on the front foot playing with 3 strikers/wingers.

I do see teams completely changing their shape parking with bus with often 6 defenders. (Like we did last season at Man City and Liverpool). 

I do see our players in most games missing gilt-edged chances and conversely making similar mistakes at the other end which have cost us every defeat and other points (plus playing 12 men at Fulham). 

I see injuries to key players which has meant a loss of some continuity (O'Shea, Mowatt, Clarke). 

I see Diangana who ripped this league to shreds two seasons ago looking like a little boy lost and no longer seemingly capable of playing football. 

And yet we are third in the league with automatic promotion still in our own hands (Bournemouth/Fulham have to play each other twice and we have to play both of them at home).  

Far too early to be writing Val and the Albion off.
Top post, Hop.
IMO, a proper no.9 would transform this team. We currently are playing 3 wingers as strikers. None of them are capable of holding the ball up.
(Or it might simply be all Vals fault, telling the forwards to give the ball to the opposition and to try not to score...)

Yup, too easy to defend against as nobody is trying to disrupt the defensive shape, all you need to do is sit deep and the strikers can't do anything as there's no space for them to run in behind. Hugill and Zohore the closest to being what we need but the former isn't good enough technically and the latter seemingly can't be arsed.
Reply
#18
(11-15-2021, 06:20 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 03:23 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(11-15-2021, 03:16 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: The last couple of home games, we haven't looked dangerous in front of goal, despite playing 3 forwards. I don't think it's necessarily down to the style of play, more the personnel. Against Boro, the three forward players are all arguably more effective playing down the left, so probably shouldn't be a surprise that they didn't gel and compliment one another. If we had played three left backs at the back, the same positional confusion would take place.

I think we need Val to have the right blend of players for his three forwards before judging. The problem we have is Grady, Grant & Robbo were all signed last season, and are on long contracts. To get the balance right we probably need to off-load one of them. Hugill is only useful for cameos off the bench, and we know Matty Philips will have a run of good & bad games, and lacks consistency over a period of games.

We desperately need a good all-round target man, and perhaps one of the younger players like Tulloch or Morton could do a job as the third attacker in this system, with Grady, Grant or Robbo the other forward.

You might be right about this especially with our limited funds. Who would you get rid of out of the 3 though? Knowing us we'll probably get about 500k for Grady

Right now, I'd probably say Grady, but we might regret it, particularly if we let him go on the cheap. I'd see how the next 6 or 7 weeks go, and then make a call. Perhaps an option would be to loan out Grady, to fund a loan in.

Could be worth doing if he doesn't show any form in before January, a loan move might get his confidence back - as long as we do get someone in
Reply
#19
(11-15-2021, 07:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Hopalong Wrote:I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about.   Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? 

I do see us start every game on the front foot playing with 3 strikers/wingers.

I do see teams completely changing their shape parking with bus with often 6 defenders. (Like we did last season at Man City and Liverpool). 

I do see our players in most games missing gilt-edged chances and conversely making similar mistakes at the other end which have cost us every defeat and other points (plus playing 12 men at Fulham). 

I see injuries to key players which has meant a loss of some continuity (O'Shea, Mowatt, Clarke). 

I see Diangana who ripped this league to shreds two seasons ago looking like a little boy lost and no longer seemingly capable of playing football. 

And yet we are third in the league with automatic promotion still in our own hands (Bournemouth/Fulham have to play each other twice and we have to play both of them at home).  

Far too early to be writing Val and the Albion off.
Top post, Hop.
IMO, a proper no.9 would transform this team. We currently are playing 3 wingers as strikers. None of them are capable of holding the ball up.
(Or it might simply be all Vals fault, telling the forwards to give the ball to the opposition and to try not to score...)

Keifer Moore may be an option given Cardiff's situation?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: