![]() |
|
Style of play hurting our forwards? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Style of play hurting our forwards? (/showthread.php?tid=22799) Pages:
1
2
|
Style of play hurting our forwards? - Lurker#3 - 11-15-2021 Very bored at work and have my dad sending me links to "Read West Brom dot com", who for some unbeknown reason are publishing links saying "West Brom will not be sacking Valerian Ismael", and keep bleating on about style of play holding back Robbo and others in the squad. etc. This has led me to do some quick averages of possession over the season. 1-4: 42.75% 5-8: 59.24% 9-12: 56.25% (LOWEST POSESSION SINCE THE FIRST 4 V STOKE AT 44%) 13-16: 60.5% (INCLUDING HAVING OUR PANTS DOWN AT SWANSEA AT 35%) Now I know possession stats alone dont tell a full and rich story, but there is a clear transition in our style of play after the first 4 games and I think its a fallacy that VI is stubborn tactically, he may well be from a formational perspective, but the stats show we have more of the ball than our opponents, most of the time. This, aligned with us still making one of the highest percentages of "final 3rd" passes in the division shows we are not short on the ball in key areas. So why would he drastically change his formation? So that leaves 2 things; the players being too tired to hurt teams once they get in the box/final 3rd because of the intensity VI demands, or our players are not showing the kind of clinical ability the likes of Fulham and Bournemouth are. If I don't get any crisis calls this afternoon I may update this thread with more stat analysis in the same blocks of 4 if I can see any trends. What do I think is causing our shitness in the final third? A mixture of the aforementioned. Which was incidentally a hallmark of the early Bielsa teams at Leeds. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - MassDebater - 11-15-2021 This is also aligned to the opposition realising that if they don't have it we can't press them. Sadly we don't seem to really know what to do with the ball when we have it. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Sliced - 11-15-2021 Yup, basically the opposition lets us have the ball and we need to try and find another way of dealing with this. I would argue so far that we've struggled RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Lurker#3 - 11-15-2021 Interestingly we are 5th highest in terms of possession but 23rd in our pass completion percentage. This suggest we are trying to play much riskier passes. Perhaps in desperation when we are struggling. We are 2nd/3rd respectively for Shots/game and Shots on target. But low midtable on dribbles and fouls against. 18th in the league for the number of total passes, and a similar position for both long and short pass accuracy. But 2nd for the number of key passes made, We are between 16/20th in the league in terms of our "assist type" in terms of Cross, through ball, corner and free kick. But in the top few for "Other" and throw ins. consequentally Fulham and Bournemouth top the "other" category, which i imagine covers knock downs, square passes etc. We contest the second highest amount of aerial duels but win our fair share. We score the majority of our goals either in the six yard box or form outside the area. We are a poor 14th for goals scored inside the penalty area. This again to me shows a lack of composure in wide attacking areas and a real lack of quality. I am not sure what Val can do about inaccurate crosses and poor finishing apart from get batter players. The one other interesting stat is we are midtable for "Unsuccessful Touches" where Fulham and Bournmouth and near the top. This may show they are showing more bravery in attacking situations as they both have very high numbers of dribbles also. This is why we should definitely persevere with Grady as he is our most creative outlet and best dribbler. We also need to get another player of that type in the team. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Bob Fossil - 11-15-2021 (11-15-2021, 01:50 PM)Sliced Wrote: Yup, basically the opposition lets us have the ball and we need to try and find another way of dealing with this. I would argue so far that we've struggledThis was a common anti-Pulis tactic, where teams would let them have the ball and they didn't know what to do with it. Whilst it also works with Valball, it is far more dangerous as we do have better attacking options and are not scared to venture forward. It can still be very effective though, especially with our lack of a creative midfielder. This is Val's latest conundrum for me and he has to find a way of turning possession into genuine creativity, which maximises the strengths of our forwards. It cannot be a coincidence that all of Robinson, Hugill, Phillips, Grady and even Grant are not playing well on a regular basis as, whilst none are world beaters, they are all accomplished in this league and should be doing better. When we start well in games, we tend to kick on, it's when the game drags on and teams bed in that we struggle so the subs have to better and more thought out. Instead of just the monotonous, often futile, like for like, we need to try something different like switching to a back 4 and going 433 / 442 or maybe just 352. It's almost like he's scared to try it, at present, because he really believes in the 343 and is desperate to persevere. Word of warning though, many a manager has fallen foul of this trap and stuck to a rigid formation, as they often underestimate the intelligence of the fans and our ability to see opportunity for change and faith soon turns to belligerence. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - MassDebater - 11-15-2021 (11-15-2021, 01:55 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Interestingly we are 5th highest in terms of possession but 23rd in our pass completion percentage. This suggest we are trying to play much riskier passes. Perhaps in desperation when we are struggling. That's because we rarely can pass the damn thing to our own players, nowt to do with risky passes, we've all seen many of our players fail to complete a simple 10 yard pass. I'd like to see a stat on dangerous shots, as I suspect we'll be mid-table on that. Having loads of shots that don't trouble the keeper is as pointless as passing it around squarely at the back. Not surprised on the crosses assist type as we keep lumping it in to nobody. I honestly cannot remember the last cross (not corner) that led to a goal for us... RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Hopalong - 11-15-2021 I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about. Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? I do see us start every game on the front foot playing with 3 strikers/wingers. I do see teams completely changing their shape parking the bus with often 6 defenders. (Like we did last season at Man City and Liverpool). I do see our players in most games missing gilt-edged chances and conversely making similar mistakes at the other end which have cost us every defeat and other points (plus playing 12 men at Fulham). I see injuries to key players which has meant a loss of some continuity (O'Shea, Mowatt, Clarke). I see Diangana who ripped this league to shreds two seasons ago looking like a little boy lost and no longer seemingly capable of playing football. And yet we are third in the league with automatic promotion still in our own hands (Bournemouth/Fulham have to play each other twice and we have to play both of them at home). Far too early to be writing Val and the Albion off. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Lurker#3 - 11-15-2021 (11-15-2021, 02:09 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(11-15-2021, 01:55 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Interestingly we are 5th highest in terms of possession but 23rd in our pass completion percentage. This suggest we are trying to play much riskier passes. Perhaps in desperation when we are struggling. This thread is more to see whether or not we can really pin our profligacy on VI. Your first point is right, and its not something you can pin on a manager as we've had this issue for a number of years now. Your third point key, we cross more than most teams in the league but are not converting, but are scoring from range. This could be as a result of poor clearances under pressure where we recycle possession. As I say I said above we need to increase the number of dribbles we attempt and take more risky touches in the final third to break deep defences down. (11-15-2021, 02:20 PM)Hopalong Wrote: I honestly don't see a lot of the shit-ness that people keep going on about. Did the style of play hurt our forwards in the eight games we have won and the draws that we should in the main have converted to wins? I see it largely liek this, and the term shit-ness, from me, was somewhat tongue-in-cheek. I also still massively support Val and think he will make us a very good team in time, with the right signings. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - Sliced - 11-15-2021 (11-15-2021, 02:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:agree, good post(11-15-2021, 01:50 PM)Sliced Wrote: Yup, basically the opposition lets us have the ball and we need to try and find another way of dealing with this. I would argue so far that we've struggledThis was a common anti-Pulis tactic, where teams would let them have the ball and they didn't know what to do with it. Whilst it also works with Valball, it is far more dangerous as we do have better attacking options and are not scared to venture forward. It can still be very effective though, especially with our lack of a creative midfielder. RE: Style of play hurting our forwards? - MassDebater - 11-15-2021 I think our 'final 3rd shitness' is mostly because we seem scared of shooting when in good positions, which I know is at odds with the loads of shot stats. instead we now seem to want to overplay it out wide in order to get in a pointless and easily defended cross. That sort of thing either comes from managerial instruction or because players have no confidence... to be 3rd and have players low on confidence is a strange thing to suggest, so you'd assume they're being told to do it? Then again the way some of them are passing it harks back to the low confidence. It's the strangest overall situation I can ever remember. Before we've been shit or we've been great or we've been average, at the moment we can be all three within 30 minutes in any given game... It just makes zero sense. |