Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-13-2021, 11:39 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.
I'd extend it to bad fouls too.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
07-13-2021, 11:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-13-2021, 11:53 AM by SW4Baggie.)
(07-13-2021, 11:40 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:39 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.
I'd extend it to bad fouls too.
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that
(07-13-2021, 11:13 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
Hmmm VAR/ref was criticised for the Sterling Penalty, and yet I felt we should at least have had a couple of reviews in the final and there were none (not the BBC made clear were happening anyway).
The Sterling pen was a “some given, some not” category - it wasn’t a clear and obvious error… then the “reds” in the final, I guess they were the same category too. I don’t think either us nor Denmark feel particularly aggrieved about those decisions overall which suggests they were right not to be reviewed.
VAR should be there to ensure the massive howlers are removed, not erode every subjective call. Football is a very blurred sport, lots of “maybes” and “orange cards” that standardising only risks ruining the game as we saw with the PL’s ludicrous interpretation last season.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(07-13-2021, 11:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:40 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:39 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.
I'd extend it to bad fouls too.
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
Thats fine. If they've just conceded they'll only be wasting their own time! VAR would only check for any obvious error anyway, i.e. was the scorer offside, handball etc. If theres nowt obvious the check would be done in 30sec anyway.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-13-2021, 11:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:40 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:39 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.
I'd extend it to bad fouls too.
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
(07-13-2021, 11:13 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
Hmmm VAR/ref was criticised for the Sterling Penalty, and yet I felt we should at least have had a couple of reviews in the final and there were none (not the BBC made clear were happening anyway).
The Sterling pen was a “some given, some not” category - it wasn’t a clear and obvious error… then the “reds” in the final, I guess they were the same category too. I don’t think either us nor Denmark feel particularly aggrieved about those decisions overall which suggests they were right not to be reviewed.
VAR should be there to ensure the massive howlers are removed, not erode every subjective call. Football is a very blurred sport, lots of “maybes” and “orange cards” that standardising only risks ruining the game as we saw with the PL’s ludicrous interpretation last season.
Correct. Football is at a crossroads. VAR PL-style causes lots of controversy and generates tons of discussions and those sadly all-important social media interaction, but it is killing the game, particularly the disallowing of goals.
I really hope there can be a big push for this to happen.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(07-13-2021, 11:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:40 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:39 AM)MrFizz Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.
I'd extend it to bad fouls too.
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
(07-13-2021, 11:13 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.
Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.
In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.
This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.
Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix
Hmmm VAR/ref was criticised for the Sterling Penalty, and yet I felt we should at least have had a couple of reviews in the final and there were none (not the BBC made clear were happening anyway).
The Sterling pen was a “some given, some not” category - it wasn’t a clear and obvious error… then the “reds” in the final, I guess they were the same category too. I don’t think either us nor Denmark feel particularly aggrieved about those decisions overall which suggests they were right not to be reviewed.
VAR should be there to ensure the massive howlers are removed, not erode every subjective call. Football is a very blurred sport, lots of “maybes” and “orange cards” that standardising only risks ruining the game as we saw with the PL’s ludicrous interpretation last season.
I agree, the Sterling pen and the Kane non-pen there was some degree of doubt in these so they went with the refs decision which is what should happen IMO. Ok they could analyse every incident for minutes on end and in slow-mo like they do now here but it ruins the game and a lot of the time the decision they end up with is just as doubtful as (or worse than) the original one. Leave VAR for the howlers e.g. ref gives a pen for handball and replays show it didn't hit the players hand.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Interesting how Walton seemed to agree with every VAR intervention, pretty much the same as he does over here, when clearly both approaches can't be right.
They nailed it for me and it showed how VAR can be a fair system if used properly. Of course it's not perfect but it doesn't need to be, it just needs to be consistent. The worry over here would be, the more subjective it becomes, as in "clear and obvious" it would just give more weight to those at the top of the food chain and make an already corrupt league, even more so.
Was it "clear and obvious"?
"It's only Burnley" play on, sort of mentality, whereas if it's Liverpool "better check that, don't want Klopp having a post match rant"
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-13-2021, 12:17 PM)MrFizz Wrote: And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
Thats fine. If they've just conceded they'll only be wasting their own time! VAR would only check for any obvious error anyway, i.e. was the scorer offside, handball etc. If theres nowt obvious the check would be done in 30sec anyway.
[/quote]
Simple the captain has to state what he wants reviewing(bad foul, possible / given penalty, that Is/Is not a goal), if there's nothing to review and they call for a spurious one, then as said, they just lose the time it takes and that screws them.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
07-13-2021, 02:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-13-2021, 02:38 PM by SW4Baggie.)
(07-13-2021, 01:16 PM)MassDebater Wrote: [quote="MrFizz" pid="363353" dateline="1626178678"]
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
Thats fine. If they've just conceded they'll only be wasting their own time! VAR would only check for any obvious error anyway, i.e. was the scorer offside, handball etc. If theres nowt obvious the check would be done in 30sec anyway.
Simple the captain has to state what he wants reviewing(bad foul, possible / given penalty, that Is/Is not a goal), if there's nothing to review and they call for a spurious one, then as said, they just lose the time it takes and that screws them.
So you're saying there should be a 3rd party who decides which decisions are reviewed and which arent?
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-13-2021, 02:37 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (07-13-2021, 01:16 PM)MassDebater Wrote: [quote="MrFizz" pid="363353" dateline="1626178678"]
And this is the issue… imagine it’s the 90th minute and you’ve just conceded… the players on the side that have conceded have 3 reviews left, they’ll use them all on anything they can… then its how to you police that? Give them a red for spurious use of reviews… chances are they’ll review that 
Thats fine. If they've just conceded they'll only be wasting their own time! VAR would only check for any obvious error anyway, i.e. was the scorer offside, handball etc. If theres nowt obvious the check would be done in 30sec anyway.
Simple the captain has to state what he wants reviewing(bad foul, possible / given penalty, that Is/Is not a goal), if there's nothing to review and they call for a spurious one, then as said, they just lose the time it takes and that screws them.
So you're saying there should be a 3rd party who decides which decisions are reviewed and which arent?
No, just the three categories and if there isn't something that the captain can point at as needing reviewing then they lose the review and nothing is done. I'm not saying they can go ohh that's our throw - review, ohhh that's a corner - review... Just three hard and fast types. Goals would only be if there was some infringement that the ref never saw, or if a goal was disallowed for offside or handball or something, again the captain has to stipulate what they want reviewing. maybe the ball went out on the cross for example? Fouls, if the ref has taken no action on it then the captain can ask for a review, or if the captain thinks it's bad enough a tackle and the ref only gave a yellow then they can... Penalties would fall under fouls.
In all cases the captain has to state exactly what they want reviewing, and only one review per event, to prevent reviews of reviews... it's puts it back in the player's hands and I'd probably cut it back to one review per half (plus one for extra time), not rolled over. If they call review and can't say what was wrong then they lose it.
If the review is right then they keep it for the rest of that half. No need to VAR except to provide the replays for the ref on the pitchside to review, which also puts it back into the ref on the pitches hands, rather than faceless people in some van or something.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-13-2021, 01:12 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Interesting how Walton seemed to agree with every VAR intervention, pretty much the same as he does over here, when clearly both approaches can't be right.
They nailed it for me and it showed how VAR can be a fair system if used properly. Of course it's not perfect but it doesn't need to be, it just needs to be consistent. The worry over here would be, the more subjective it becomes, as in "clear and obvious" it would just give more weight to those at the top of the food chain and make an already corrupt league, even more so.
Was it "clear and obvious"?
"It's only Burnley" play on, sort of mentality, whereas if it's Liverpool "better check that, don't want Klopp having a post match rant"
You just have to see the nonsense which was our home match against Liverpool for VAR nonsense to please a wider audience.
|