WBAUnofficial
English Refereeing - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: English Refereeing (/showthread.php?tid=19575)

Pages: 1 2 3


English Refereeing - Squid - 07-13-2021

After the pitiful UK medal tally in the 1996 Olympics, there was a massive overhaul of sport funding and training, to the massive benefit of UK sport.

Well, this European championships needs to target something similar in refereeing in the English game. 

Aside from the ignominy of no PL referees being deemed good enough to participate, we actually got to see what VAR could look like as opposed to the nonsensical horror show served up every week in the PL. 

Changes need to be made.


RE: English Refereeing - Duffers - 07-13-2021

What struck me about refereeing, and especially the use of VAR, at the Euros was that they had a much more clear view and what constitutes “clear and obvious error”. IMO referees hide behind VAR now, terrified to make a decision and happy to VAR sort it out.

A “clear and obvious error” doesn’t take ten replays in super slow motion to determine whether there was contact or not. It doesn’t necessitate lines being draw from armpits to determine if someone was offside by millimetres. Refs need to braver and the cameras need to hold off unless they genuinely need to get involved.


RE: English Refereeing - Birdman1811 - 07-13-2021

Interestingly Taylor was regarded as one of the best refs of the tournament. A British ref.

Is it the personnel or is it their instructions?


RE: English Refereeing - hooch0959 - 07-13-2021

I think there's a lot to learn from the Way they handled VAR.  As far the Refs are concerned it was a collection of the best Refs in Europe same as a collection of the best Footballers in Europe.  Here we have the best 20 Refs we can find following Mike Riley's mandate  How Mike Riley is still in job is what I find astounding, man seems to be unaccountable


RE: English Refereeing - Remi_Moses - 07-13-2021

Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.


RE: English Refereeing - MassDebater - 07-13-2021

(07-13-2021, 10:37 AM)hooch0959 Wrote: I think there's a lot to learn from the Way they handled VAR.  As far the Refs are concerned it was a collection of the best Refs in Europe same as a collection of the best Footballers in Europe.  Here we have the best 20 Refs we can find following Mike Riley's mandate  How Mike Riley is still in job is what I find astounding, man seems to be unaccountable

Hey don't forget the foreign exchange South American ref!

Totally agree Remi, if the challenge is upheld then you keep the challenge otherwise it's lost.


RE: English Refereeing - Johnnykayeengland - 07-13-2021

I'm not one who believes that English refs are any poorer than others. Oliver and Taylor were fine in this tournament.
It's the backup/ support from the FA as opposed to UEFA which is the difference.
As well as a sensible use of VAR.
Give our refs the support they need and the game improves.
Remember how aggressive players like arsenal and Man U were to refs in the 90s? The FA decided to stop it. We don't get that sort of intimidation now.
Up to the fa to sort it out. I hope they've been watching!


RE: English Refereeing - SW4Baggie - 07-13-2021

(07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.

Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.

In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.

This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.

Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix


RE: English Refereeing - MassDebater - 07-13-2021

(07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.

Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.

In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.

This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.

Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix

Hmmm VAR/ref was criticised for the Sterling Penalty, and yet I felt we should at least have had a couple of reviews in the final and there were none (not the BBC made clear were happening anyway).


RE: English Refereeing - MrFizz - 07-13-2021

(07-13-2021, 11:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-13-2021, 10:40 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Calling for VAR needs to be by the team captain NOT THE BLOODY REFEREE. 3 shouts per game - Sorted.

Never understood the call for handing review responsibilities to the teams. Football isn’t like Tennis and Cricket where there are numerous stoppages and a relatively low importance of each shot/score in the overall result.

In football one goal often decides the game, and there are very few noteworthy incidents requiring review. Handing the opportunity to disrupt the game to teams will only end up with tactical uses of reviews and remove the agency from the ref.

This tournament showed exactly how VAR can work. The ref is left to get on with the game and his decisions are reviewed in private. If a clear and obvious error - ie one that looks obvious from watching the game at normal speed - is spotted then the panel upstairs recommend a decision. This is all played out without the fans / players being alerted until the check has suggested there’s a review required.

Over the course of those tournament there seemed to be a VAR check maybe once a game max, and interference maybe once every 2-3 games. Exactly how it should be done. The technology works perfectly well provided humans aren’t allowed to bring yet more opportunity for error into the mix

I like the idea of a 'referral' by captains, but only for goals and penalty claims, nothing else. VAR can only intervene without prompting for violent conduct not seen by on field officials.