Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
Considering there's a fair few batsmen who look in good nick playing for their counties this year, it's difficult to see what benefit England's loyalty to their players brings. Other sides pick on form and I'd like to see us do the same.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I don't think this team is lacking in talent, FP. I've seen many an England side full of relative stocking fillers go out there and put on a decent performance over the years. This lot under-performs almost every time.
There's been a consistent malaise ever since Strauss finished as captain - when he had to give up the management job due to his wife's illness, his good influence was lost altogether. Cook was a weak captain, relying very heavily on his little cabal of senior players (Anderson, Broad, Prior, Swann) to run the show. It's a matter of record that young players coming into the squad (especially bowlers) were intimidated by this mob and struggled to break into the side. Root is a worse captain than Cook, less tactical acumen, less authority with the squad and still relying on two of the old lags to help him with basic decision making. And here's the elephant in the room - no matter how good Jimmy and Stuart can be when they click, we can't afford to have two players of their age who can't hold up one corner of a three man pace attack, who contribute nothing with the bat and who are increasingly cumbersome in the field. We should have picked a spinner in this series, which means that one or other of the two icons should have been left out.
The batting shows an utter lack of backbone, which I believe reflects Root's fragility. His well-documented reluctance to bat anywhere other than 4 is out of step with truly great players who will bat where the team needs them to. For some time we encouraged swashbuckling batters like Buttler and Bairstow who "did it their way" with considerable success. Silverwood has tried to reintroduce old-fashioned "stickability", a bit of the Boycott or Trott, to the approach. But it seems we don't have the players who can do this, they all instinctively play a shot when under pressure, which is the white ball way but not the Test way. Above all, in making Root captain in the first place we have turned a potentially great batsman into a good batsmen and replaced an average captain with a poor captain.
The missing players would make a difference. But they never pick Woakes and rarely Curran (can't drop Stuart or Jimmy), Archer doesn't do long spells, Stokes often doesn't bowl much, so they might still leave out Leach. The fundamental selection, tactical and morale issues remain. I expect a heavy defeat against India and a wipe-out in Australia. Then it might be time for Silverwood and Root to step aside.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Yesterday was shocking but not surprising
Firstly we’ve about 6-7 players not playing who would be in that team, secondly NZ have developed into a top, top team and play without the arrogance of Kholi’s India and re just as good in all conditions
We’re playing no mugs here
We should go back to Malan and Vince and send Crawley, Bracey, Lawrence, Sibley back to county cricket with the mantra of getting bags full of runs, Pope is swigging in last chance saloon too
I’m a big Stone fan but he’s been poor in this test and leaving out Leach was criminal
Don’t even get me started on Silverwood……..
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
V good side NZ - plenty of depth too. Easily in the top 2 Test teams - with India
It’s Kohli that’s arrogant - not the India team. The green uns in late summer will still make that series a real contest
Posts: 1,149
Threads: 75
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
4
Nasser Hussein presided over several humiliating defeats while captaining a shower of shyte players too.
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Root very much set the tone for this with his reluctance to even have a look at winning the last test and then yesterday he let the spinner bowl him full toss after full toss in his first over and come away with a maiden