Posts: 655
Threads: 185
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
06-12-2021, 04:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2021, 04:56 PM by ferencpuskas.)
and I can go back to the days of Len Hutton , Freddie Trueman, Godfrey Evans, and that era ! Our middle order wouldn't have got a game for Stourbridge in them days ! FFS Joe resign, it must be murder for you trying to captain and lead this crew, with the exception of the 3 main bowlers, they're a kin joke. Resign mate, goo and play in the IPL, earn some big bucks with the rest of the big whackers, while you can, cos this lot will kill ya,!
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Nahhh - it’s those biased home umpires/ that pitch the Kiwis have doctored
Posts: 152
Threads: 8
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
The fast bowlers are fine, and we have some strength in depth there. We'll miss Jimmy and Broad when they retire but who wouldn't?
We don't seem to trust our spinners. Or, rather, we don't trust our batters enough to play a specialist spinner, so rely on Root as an option.
It's the worst batting line up I can remember. Even in the grim days of the 80s and 90s you had the likes of Atherton, Stewart, Hussain, Robin Smith. Not the most fluent batsmen (Smith apart) but bloody hell you'd have to earn their wicket, they wouldn't give it up cheaply. Of the top seven, Root is OK (although the days of being mentioned in the same breath as Kohli, Williamson and Smith are over). Burns has had a couple of good knocks, but his stance and technique looks awful. The other five, just not good enough, at the moment at least. Go back to County cricket and sort your games out.
Our fielding is piss poor. Actually, that's not true, our out fielding is fine, it's our catching that's piss poor. We have to create 25-30 chances to get 20 wickets. It seems to be getting worse.
And oh my word, Bracey is the worst batsman/keeper I think I've ever seen at test level. Given how crap his batting has been, I thought he was a specialist keeper a la Chris Read. Apparently, he's surprised that he's being picked as a keeper. Surely this isn't the best option? I'd sooner have Jonny Bairstow, even with the glaring holes in technique.
I wouldn't fancy buying a ticket for day 4 in the Ashes in the Winter.
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(06-12-2021, 07:17 PM)Mish Wrote: The fast bowlers are fine, and we have some strength in depth there. We'll miss Jimmy and Broad when they retire but who wouldn't?
We don't seem to trust our spinners. Or, rather, we don't trust our batters enough to play a specialist spinner, so rely on Root as an option.
It's the worst batting line up I can remember. Even in the grim days of the 80s and 90s you had the likes of Atherton, Stewart, Hussain, Robin Smith. Not the most fluent batsmen (Smith apart) but bloody hell you'd have to earn their wicket, they wouldn't give it up cheaply. Of the top seven, Root is OK (although the days of being mentioned in the same breath as Kohli, Williamson and Smith are over). Burns has had a couple of good knocks, but his stance and technique looks awful. The other five, just not good enough, at the moment at least. Go back to County cricket and sort your games out.
Our fielding is piss poor. Actually, that's not true, our out fielding is fine, it's our catching that's piss poor. We have to create 25-30 chances to get 20 wickets. It seems to be getting worse.
And oh my word, Bracey is the worst batsman/keeper I think I've ever seen at test level. Given how crap his batting has been, I thought he was a specialist keeper a la Chris Read. Apparently, he's surprised that he's being picked as a keeper. Surely this isn't the best option? I'd sooner have Jonny Bairstow, even with the glaring holes in technique.
I wouldn't fancy buying a ticket for day 4 in the Ashes in the Winter.
On his day Robin Smith was unplayable ,probably on of the best exponents of the square cut I've seen, anything remotely loose on the offside enevitabley ended up going to the boundary. People used to mock the likes of Boycott ,Brearley and,Greg for their slow scoring but they'd hang around frustrate fugg out of bowlers.
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(06-12-2021, 07:28 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (06-12-2021, 07:17 PM)Mish Wrote: The fast bowlers are fine, and we have some strength in depth there. We'll miss Jimmy and Broad when they retire but who wouldn't?
We don't seem to trust our spinners. Or, rather, we don't trust our batters enough to play a specialist spinner, so rely on Root as an option.
It's the worst batting line up I can remember. Even in the grim days of the 80s and 90s you had the likes of Atherton, Stewart, Hussain, Robin Smith. Not the most fluent batsmen (Smith apart) but bloody hell you'd have to earn their wicket, they wouldn't give it up cheaply. Of the top seven, Root is OK (although the days of being mentioned in the same breath as Kohli, Williamson and Smith are over). Burns has had a couple of good knocks, but his stance and technique looks awful. The other five, just not good enough, at the moment at least. Go back to County cricket and sort your games out.
Our fielding is piss poor. Actually, that's not true, our out fielding is fine, it's our catching that's piss poor. We have to create 25-30 chances to get 20 wickets. It seems to be getting worse.
And oh my word, Bracey is the worst batsman/keeper I think I've ever seen at test level. Given how crap his batting has been, I thought he was a specialist keeper a la Chris Read. Apparently, he's surprised that he's being picked as a keeper. Surely this isn't the best option? I'd sooner have Jonny Bairstow, even with the glaring holes in technique.
I wouldn't fancy buying a ticket for day 4 in the Ashes in the Winter.
On his day Robin Smith was unplayable ,probably on of the best exponents of the square cut I've seen, anything remotely loose on the offside enevitabley ended up going to the boundary. People used to mock the likes of Boycott ,Brearley and,Greg for their slow scoring but they'd hang around frustrate fugg out of bowlers.
Top player. Dropped too early - perceived as terrible against spin
Posts: 2,009
Threads: 113
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
4
06-12-2021, 07:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2021, 07:40 PM by aj21.)
Nonsense about this being the worst team. Half the players that should be playing aren't. The selection policy of resting the players at the IPL, despite them not playing cricket for a month is a farce.
Stokes, Archer, Woakes, Butler, Curran, Ali, Bairstow all unavailable. Chris Woakes hasn't played a test match in 2021
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
We are desperately short of opening batsmen. Half our underperforming middle order might just step up if someone knocked the shine off the ball.
Posts: 44
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
I dont have a massive issue with resting players, mainly to see if some of the back up players are any good. Turns out our back up seamers look decent, but our batsmen much, much less so.
Lawrence might be decent, looks like he could be an aggressive middle order batsman, but the rest that have come in look not good enough. I had hopes for Crawley, but maybe he is the new Rob Key.
I think the “Root is ok” is a tad harsh. Ok he is a little behind Kohli, Smith and Williamson, but so are 99.9% of people who have played test cricket. A double hundred away in SL, followed by nearly doing it in the next match is a little better than ok. He is also one of the most underrated ODI batsmen in the world. Sits perfectly in the middle order in our tactical approach to ODIs, which has worked so well.
Issue is in tests is if he only goes ok or has a bad day, we dont have anyone coming through that looks like they can even average 40. Just cant see how we will outbat the Aussies this winter.
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(06-12-2021, 05:37 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Nahhh - it’s those biased home umpires/ that pitch the Kiwis have doctored
Posts: 559
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(06-12-2021, 07:38 PM)aj21 Wrote: Nonsense about this being the worst team. Half the players that should be playing aren't. The selection policy of resting the players at the IPL, despite them not playing cricket for a month is a farce.
Stokes, Archer, Woakes, Butler, Curran, Ali, Bairstow all unavailable. Chris Woakes hasn't played a test match in 2021
The problem is none of those players mentioned can bat in the top 3. Including Bairstow.
So if you’re consistently 50 odd for 2 then it doesn’t really matter who’s coming next.
We don’t build innings and just seem totally clueless.
I saw a stat that since 2018 our average score for the loss of 2 wickets is 58. Only Zimbabwe, Bangladesh and Ireland (ffs) are worse in that period.
Nassers comments last night were alarming in how we seem to be ignoring everything about the way test cricket is played.
We then decide to make silverwood the only selector when I’m not sure he’s even the best coach for the job.
India and Australia will batter this team.
|