Players who should have retired instead of signing for the Baggies
#11
(05-26-2021, 02:01 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: Hartson,

Always remember a 4 1 away defeat at Stoke, Phelan clattered a Stoke player and all the Baggies fans chanted off off off.

I remember Phelan virtually catching the ball in our penalty area as to him it was preferable to concede a penalty rather than have to turn and run after it.
Reply
#12
(05-26-2021, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Branislav Ivanovic contributed nothing this season, as predicted by many. But we've been here before. Opinions vary about some of the players below, but here's my onions:

Graham Roberts - this fellow gets kudos from some because he kicked Steve Bull's ass, but his record of P39, W9, L18, D12 is pretty poor. Scored 6 goals, but 4 were pens. Desperate signing by Talbot, just in time to partake in our spectacular fall from grace.

Andy Townsend - he managed to play 18 times, but has admitted freely that his knees had already gone before he signed the contract.

Mike Phelan - who could have imagined that a player of some quality who had spent half of his 5 seasons at Man Utd on the bench would struggle with the rigours of life in a lower league? Just 21 appearances.

Geoff Hurst - weird one this. Two goals in 10 appearances at the start of the season, then disappeared. I can't even remember why he left.

Joleon Lescott - now we're getting into contentious territory. He didn't add the authority our back line needed, as evidenced by Pulis' eventual decision to play him at full back, with GMac and Jonas restored to the centre. On the plus side, we stole money off the Villa for him and he relegated them.

Gareth Barry - another one who gets some plaudits on this 'ere bored. In my opinion a clear sign that Pulis had given up. Lazy signing. He would always struggle to match the influence of Darren Fletcher, but overall his impact was far less than expected, somewhere between negligible and negative.

I'm sure there are other examples, as well as signings like Fletcher who worked out well. But I'll never get excited when I hear news stories starting with "2 times Premier League Champion and FA Cup winner xxxxxx has signed a 2 year contract with West Bromwich Albion".
Interesting you mention Fletcher, I would have added him to the list. Could not make a decent pass.
Reply
#13
(05-26-2021, 02:03 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(05-26-2021, 02:01 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: Hartson,

Always remember a 4 1 away defeat at Stoke, Phelan clattered a Stoke player and all the Baggies fans chanted off off off.

I remember Phelan virtually catching the ball in our penalty area as to him it was preferable to concede a penalty rather than have to turn and run after it.

He really was another level of garbage and well worth a place in our worst ever team, made Andy Townsend look good.
Reply
#14
(05-26-2021, 02:01 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote: Hartson,

Always remember a 4 1 away defeat at Stoke, Phelan clattered a Stoke player and all the Baggies fans chanted off off off.

I thought of Hartson, but what no one realised at the time was that he was possibly developing an cancerous tumour on the brain,He did not site this as a reason when he left, but to this day I believe this was a primary reason why he did not perform well for us. I was really glad when he overcame this life threatening illness and is a decent pundit nowadays.
Reply
#15
Yeah I’m willing to cut Hartson a fair degree of slack considering he was clearly unwell for a lot of his time with us. Scored against the Wolves and always speaks fondly about us, no ill will towards the guy.

I still remember my sharp intake of breath when I walked into the ground before his debut against Hull and saw him warming up. Don’t think I’d ever seen a footballer that size!
Reply
#16
Gray, Mcnaught, Morley.

All shit and past it, wonder who flogged us them?
Reply
#17
(05-26-2021, 01:59 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-26-2021, 01:31 PM)wba13 Wrote: Scott Carson couldn’t catch a cold.
Giles Barnes couldn’t pass wind.
Rosenberg couldn’t shoot straight.

Think you're missing the thread- it has to be players at the end of their careers. Think one last pay day- eg Anelka!
Carson was 25 when he left us and has enjoyed a solid if unspectacular career since. Rosenberg was juts a misfit, but has done well wherever he went at decent European clubs.

Wow, Spandau, how could I forget Anelka! Good call.
Reply
#18
(05-26-2021, 02:11 PM)coxy134 Wrote:
(05-26-2021, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Branislav Ivanovic contributed nothing this season, as predicted by many. But we've been here before. Opinions vary about some of the players below, but here's my onions:

Graham Roberts - this fellow gets kudos from some because he kicked Steve Bull's ass, but his record of P39, W9, L18, D12 is pretty poor. Scored 6 goals, but 4 were pens. Desperate signing by Talbot, just in time to partake in our spectacular fall from grace.

Andy Townsend - he managed to play 18 times, but has admitted freely that his knees had already gone before he signed the contract.

Mike Phelan - who could have imagined that a player of some quality who had spent half of his 5 seasons at Man Utd on the bench would struggle with the rigours of life in a lower league? Just 21 appearances.

Geoff Hurst - weird one this. Two goals in 10 appearances at the start of the season, then disappeared. I can't even remember why he left.

Joleon Lescott - now we're getting into contentious territory. He didn't add the authority our back line needed, as evidenced by Pulis' eventual decision to play him at full back, with GMac and Jonas restored to the centre. On the plus side, we stole money off the Villa for him and he relegated them.

Gareth Barry - another one who gets some plaudits on this 'ere bored. In my opinion a clear sign that Pulis had given up. Lazy signing. He would always struggle to match the influence of Darren Fletcher, but overall his impact was far less than expected, somewhere between negligible and negative.

I'm sure there are other examples, as well as signings like Fletcher who worked out well. But I'll never get excited when I hear news stories starting with "2 times Premier League Champion and FA Cup winner xxxxxx has signed a 2 year contract with West Bromwich Albion".
Interesting you mention Fletcher, I would have added him to the list. Could not make a decent pass.

Fletcher was fantastic for us, have to be blind to think otherwise. Never replaced his leadership or determination.
Reply
#19
Fletcher was a proper captain.
Reply
#20
Luther













Blissett.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: