Prof Neil Ferguson
#11
As painful as it is I don't see what the alternative is / was, if we hadn't had the lockdown we would have been even worse. Let's compare like with like as best we can, forget about the countries as a whole and compare New York with London so far - 19k in NY and 5k in London, even taking into account NY being approx twice the size of London does this give you a better insight into why we are doing it this way. And that is taking into account NY has had a partial lockdown for some of that time.

Nobody's saying it is perfect and they have made a lot of mistakes, but simply put a lockdown of this nature is working better than no lockdown.
Reply
#12
This is a convenient and welcome distraction on a day when the headlines should be about how many people have now sadly passed away and the questions it leaves us with regards to the governments handling of the situation.

Italy was an example to us all what was about to hit us and as late as mid March we were allowing the Cheltenham Festival to go ahead, talking about herd immunity and by late March we had all but given up on contact tracing by testing because we hadn’t got the capacity. We didn’t plan (well we ignored the Cygnus) we reacted slowly and in contradictory manner. The idea the lockdown has been too long or too strict is absolute nonsense given how many people have sadly passed away. The main people peddling this line are the likes of Farage, Toby Young etc.
Reply
#13
(05-06-2020, 07:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote: His private life is his business. But he has a track record on predictions. He said Sweden would have 40,000 deaths by now. They have 2,800. He said that 150,000 people would die from BSE. 200 people died. He said avian flu would kill 200m people. It killed 440.

Only 400 people under the age of 60 have died from Covid 19 in the UK. Genuine question - why are we not returning to work?

#ShagsWhenHeWants

His previous track record is awful.

However the decision to shut things down in this case was correct. It was just mismanaged appallingly....by a govt you helped to elect
Reply
#14
(05-06-2020, 09:28 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: It was just mismanaged appallingly....by a govt you helped to elect

I have no regrets whatsover about electing the #LeastWorst government. I don't even want to countenance how Milne & McDonnell would've used this situation to extend the tenctacles of the state into every single aspect of our lives.

(05-06-2020, 09:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: we were allowing the Cheltenham Festival to go ahead

I was at Cheltenham on Gold Cup day. I'm still waiting for any evidence whatsoever that Cheltenham was reponsible for anymore than the usual drunkeness and illicit outdoor sex.

(05-06-2020, 09:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea the lockdown has been too long or too strict is absolute nonsense given how many people have sadly passed away.

Are you an epidemiologist?
Reply
#15
(05-06-2020, 08:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-06-2020, 08:47 AM)Arti Wrote: I'm not playing the left v right hand here, though you may not believe that, mate.  Got two funerals later this month that I can't go to, both under 60s, so I'm beyond that right now.  We seriously dropped the ball.

I'm not disputing that, seriously. We have dropped the ball on BOTH the management of the virus AND the damage to the economy. Personally I'm also one of those that finds himself completely unsupported by Rishi Sunak either, so I'm not making a party political point.

And let me blunt about it, after all this is done the reality about death rates across the free world will become a lot clearer. I don't really believe much I read at the moment.

But that didn't stop you talking about Sweden's mortality rates, which as I mentioned on here the other day is far higher than other Scandinavian countries who all introduced some form of lockdown.

And I find it hard to believe that only 400 people under the age of 60 have died from this virus - it might be true but from what I have heard anecdotally that seems hard to believe.

Ferguson was a fool to do what he did, but I suspect if he was not seen as the man who was responsible for the lockdown the Daily Telegraph would not have pursued this story.
Reply
#16
(05-06-2020, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-06-2020, 09:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea the lockdown has been too long or too strict is absolute nonsense given how many people have sadly passed away.

Are you an epidemiologist?

This is where you lose credibility I'm afraid Proth, you don't need to be an epidermiologist to understand that virus' are transferred from person to person and that by reducing the person to person contact then you reduce the spread.

We are already at a reported number of 30,000 people dead directly attributable to this virus, if we hadn't have had the lockdown that number would have been much higher.

And one other point that is pure conjecture - the young healthy few that have died because of this appear to have been exposed to this virus to a greater extent than others. If we had let this virus just run through society then the more 'healthy' people would have been exposed more and potentially creating higher mortality amongst that group. That is just an observation that is as valid as you saying you went to Cheltenham and had no effects other than being exposed to fat birds taking it up the arse round by the portaloos - no suggestion there that you were doing more than passing btw  Big Grin
Reply
#17
(05-06-2020, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-06-2020, 09:28 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: It was just mismanaged appallingly....by a govt you helped to elect

I have no regrets whatsover about electing the #LeastWorst government. I don't even want to countenance how Milne & McDonnell would've used this situation to extend the tenctacles of the state into every single aspect of our lives.

(05-06-2020, 09:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: we were allowing the Cheltenham Festival to go ahead

I was at Cheltenham on Gold Cup day. I'm still waiting for any evidence whatsoever that Cheltenham was reponsible for anymore than the usual drunkeness and illicit outdoor sex.

(05-06-2020, 09:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea the lockdown has been too long or too strict is absolute nonsense given how many people have sadly passed away.

Are you an epidemiologist?
You presumably dont get the train there and back like 10s of thousands of others? If you do, and its anything like the trains i get there and back, you really don't need a graph.

You can also look at the death rates in the surrounding hospitals if you are desperate for numbers.
Reply
#18
Do you understand that the scenarios that you are citing as absolute are based on models that we stopped from happening with various mitigation procedures to avoid those scenarios from happening?

The statistician in my head is screaming.

(05-06-2020, 01:42 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: You can also look at the death rates in the surrounding hospitals if you are desperate for numbers.

Highest concentration of cases in the country near the racecourse and higher than Cheltenham itself and nearby Gloucester.
Reply
#19
(05-06-2020, 02:06 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Do you understand that the scenarios that you are citing as absolute are based on models that we stopped from happening with various mitigation procedures to avoid those scenarios from happening?

The statistician in my head is screaming.

(05-06-2020, 01:42 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: You can also look at the death rates in the surrounding hospitals if you are desperate for numbers.

Highest concentration of cases in the country near the racecourse and higher than Cheltenham itself and nearby Gloucester.

Wasnt Proths most glorious example ever given it has to be said
Reply
#20
(05-06-2020, 01:42 PM)HeathAyIt Wrote: You presumably dont get the train there and back like 10s of thousands of others? If you do, and its anything like the trains i get there and back, you really don't need a graph.

You can also look at the death rates in the surrounding hospitals if you are desperate for numbers.

I was on packed trains and tubes 4 days a week before lockdown Heath, including through Cheltenham during festival week.

Gloucestershire's Director of Public Health seems pretty sanguine about it too.

(05-06-2020, 02:06 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: Highest concentration of cases in the country near the racecourse and higher than Cheltenham itself and nearby Gloucester.

The Death Count for Prestbury and Racecourse is 3. Amongst the lowest in Gloucestershire.

Cheltenham has a death rate comparable to any other provincial town.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: