WBAUnofficial
Prof Neil Ferguson - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Prof Neil Ferguson (/showthread.php?tid=10206)

Pages: 1 2 3


Prof Neil Ferguson - Protheroe - 05-06-2020

His private life is his business. But he has a track record on predictions. He said Sweden would have 40,000 deaths by now. They have 2,800. He said that 150,000 people would die from BSE. 200 people died. He said avian flu would kill 200m people. It killed 440.

Only 400 people under the age of 60 have died from Covid 19 in the UK. Genuine question - why are we not returning to work?


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - baggy1 - 05-06-2020

Possibly because it isn't about the under 60s. If everyone returns to normal then the spread increases exponentially, which as you point out isn't a problem for the fit and healthy (so it seems), but it means that those over 60 either have to lock themselves away from the world completely, or die.

This isn't about you and your need to see people getting the economy going, it's about all of us protecting some of us.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - Protheroe - 05-06-2020

(05-06-2020, 08:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote: This isn't about you and your need to see people getting the economy going, it's about all of us protecting some of us.

Indeed, but Sweden appears to be coping admirably without shutting down in excess of 40% of its economy.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - baggy1 - 05-06-2020

So you are comparing a country that is twice the size of the UK with a 6th of the population and think that is a reasonable comparison?


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - Ossian - 05-06-2020

(05-06-2020, 07:54 AM)Protheroe Wrote: His private life is his business. But he has a track record on predictions. He said Sweden would have 40,000 deaths by now. They have 2,800. He said that 150,000 people would die from BSE. 200 people died. He said avian flu would kill 200m people. It killed 440.

Only 400 people under the age of 60 have died from Covid 19 in the UK. Genuine question - why are we not returning to work?

Probably because that evidence in itself suggests that a large demographic - i.e. those primarily of working age - are being protected by the lockdown measures, and not that their underlying resistance is necessarily at a level where risk is minimal. Not to mention their capacity to pass infections on to households and wider contacts. 

We were under-prepared and slow to respond; the ongoing lockdown is the consequence.

(05-06-2020, 08:21 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So you are comparing a country that is twice the size of the UK with a 6th of the population and think that is a reasonable comparison?

Sweden is also almost twice the size of the UK in terms of area and its largest city has a population of below 1 million. Our own (UK) stats suggest that population density is a significant factor in rates of infection and mortality.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - baggy1 - 05-06-2020

Sorry if I come across pissy on all of this Proth but I'm getting a bit tired of people who this won't impact getting impatient and wanting to get to Zara, or order their new F-Type but the reality is that we simply don't know how to deal with this effectively yet.

I'm interested in your stat about only 400 people under 60 having died of Covid-19 so far. One of my things is stats and I've looked at the comparative numbers but for the under 65s (because of the way the data is grouped) for the 4 weeks until 24th April. Year on year deaths for the under 65s shows 10,181 this year compared to 6,157 last year.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - Protheroe - 05-06-2020

(05-06-2020, 08:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry if I come across pissy on all of this Proth

And I'm sorry if I come across as all pissy too (genuinely). But this guy was the architect of Lockdown and has a long and illustrious history of being WRONG on virtually everything.

I've spent the last 4 years hearing from 'experts' who clamied the world was going to end because of Brexit, which'll now be a cakewalk compared with this.

As I've said previously, I have skin in the game on this. My mum is terminally ill. I haven't seen her for weeks. I fail to understand why we're being infantilised into a forced lockdown when we could be trusted to adopt sensible precautions - which we were doing before lockdown.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - Arti - 05-06-2020

Come on, Proth. Scientists build models to predict what could happen in certain situations if particular paths are chosen. They range from the best to worst case scenarios. You know this.

Ferguson's private life IS his business, though whilst this is in the public interest, the 'graph held on to this story for just such a day as yesterday when our death toll exceeded the worst in Europe, evidencing that the government has failed in its primary objective of protecting its people.

I'm not playing the left v right hand here, though you may not believe that, mate. Got two funerals later this month that I can't go to, both under 60s, so I'm beyond that right now. We seriously dropped the ball.

Edit: Really sorry to hear about your mom, mate.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - JOK - 05-06-2020

The problem with using mathematical modelling to predict the outcomes of disease outbreaks is that bacteria can’t read spreadsheets or graphs.

B1 is correct, we can’t just assume such and such a demographic should be allowed to operate as normal. They will simply pass on the virus to those at risk. Also, we have had seemingly healthy people die along with the ill or elderly. 

Just as an aside. I’m just back to perusing this board after a few days ‘self isolation’ to allow my irritation levels to subside  Angel   It was confirmed a week last Sunday that my 98 years and 8months old mother, who is very frail, had tested positive with Covid. Along with another 8 in her home. Up till yesterday afternoon all were showing no signs. The one who started the scare with a temperature and cough is now “back to normal “ so appears to have fully recovered. 
My point is, this virus is so random in it’s victims outcomes.


RE: Prof Neil Ferguson - Protheroe - 05-06-2020

(05-06-2020, 08:47 AM)Arti Wrote: I'm not playing the left v right hand here, though you may not believe that, mate.  Got two funerals later this month that I can't go to, both under 60s, so I'm beyond that right now.  We seriously dropped the ball.

I'm not disputing that, seriously. We have dropped the ball on BOTH the management of the virus AND the damage to the economy. Personally I'm also one of those that finds himself completely unsupported by Rishi Sunak either, so I'm not making a party political point.

And let me blunt about it, after all this is done the reality about death rates across the free world will become a lot clearer. I don't really believe much I read at the moment.