Max O'Leary
(01-25-2026, 04:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 12:43 PM)MrBater Wrote: He dropped a bollock and as ever this season we were punished for it. I honestly can't remember a more punishing season for costly mistakes.

Jury is out on him until he has some work to do.

We all know what JG is about. We all know he's a very good GK who can, and has, won us points. 

We know nothing about O'Leary, other than the fact he's already cost us two points (we all make mistakes, I am aware). 

I just don't understand the gamble the club/Madge is taking here. It's a massive end to the season, and now is not the time to faffing about with the GK, especially with one that has already made a costly mistake, and hasn't exactly left his club with rave reviews. It's all to similar to the Wildsmith debacle at the end of last year. 

It just doesn't make any sense to me.

There could be more to it. If Josh is struggling personally then it may be to protect him. It all seemed very sudden, maybe the Norwich result just hit him hard. 
Not ITK just think there’s something more to it, it’s not just performance based.
Reply
(01-25-2026, 04:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 12:43 PM)MrBater Wrote: He dropped a bollock and as ever this season we were punished for it. I honestly can't remember a more punishing season for costly mistakes.

Jury is out on him until he has some work to do.

We all know what JG is about. We all know he's a very good GK who can, and has, won us points. 

We know nothing about O'Leary, other than the fact he's already cost us two points (we all make mistakes, I am aware). 

I just don't understand the gamble the club/Madge is taking here. It's a massive end to the season, and now is not the time to faffing about with the GK, especially with one that has already made a costly mistake, and hasn't exactly left his club with rave reviews. It's all to similar to the Wildsmith debacle at the end of last year. 

It just doesn't make any sense to me.

Totally agree Josh. I had no issue with bringing in another keeper to add competition but after 2 days with the side I would have stuck with Griffiths.

Imvho Griffiths at 6'6 would have taken that free kick without issue.
Reply
(01-25-2026, 05:08 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:
(01-25-2026, 04:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 12:43 PM)MrBater Wrote: He dropped a bollock and as ever this season we were punished for it. I honestly can't remember a more punishing season for costly mistakes.

Jury is out on him until he has some work to do.

We all know what JG is about. We all know he's a very good GK who can, and has, won us points. 

We know nothing about O'Leary, other than the fact he's already cost us two points (we all make mistakes, I am aware). 

I just don't understand the gamble the club/Madge is taking here. It's a massive end to the season, and now is not the time to faffing about with the GK, especially with one that has already made a costly mistake, and hasn't exactly left his club with rave reviews. It's all to similar to the Wildsmith debacle at the end of last year. 

It just doesn't make any sense to me.

Totally agree Josh. I had no issue with bringing in another keeper to add competition but after 2 days with the side I would have stuck with Griffiths.

Imvho Griffiths at 6'6 would have taken that free kick without issue.

He would have had to leave the goal line to do that
Reply
(01-25-2026, 05:08 PM)Peachofacross Wrote:
(01-25-2026, 04:57 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(01-24-2026, 12:43 PM)MrBater Wrote: He dropped a bollock and as ever this season we were punished for it. I honestly can't remember a more punishing season for costly mistakes.

Jury is out on him until he has some work to do.

We all know what JG is about. We all know he's a very good GK who can, and has, won us points. 

We know nothing about O'Leary, other than the fact he's already cost us two points (we all make mistakes, I am aware). 

I just don't understand the gamble the club/Madge is taking here. It's a massive end to the season, and now is not the time to faffing about with the GK, especially with one that has already made a costly mistake, and hasn't exactly left his club with rave reviews. It's all to similar to the Wildsmith debacle at the end of last year. 

It just doesn't make any sense to me.

Totally agree Josh. I had no issue with bringing in another keeper to add competition but after 2 days with the side I would have stuck with Griffiths.

Imvho Griffiths at 6'6 would have taken that free kick without issue.
O’Leary, depending where you look is either 6ft 1 or 6ft 2 and a half. 
At the lower end 6 1 is getting slightly short keeper wise by modern standards but 189cm is very much par for the course.
Very tall keepers seem to get cut far more slack by fans, regardless of their actual ability.
Josh Griffiths is certainly very tall keeper wise, 6 6 and a half. It certainly helps create a more imposing presence.
However, as the likes of Pickford, Raya, Given, Casillas have proven being around the 6ft range is still plenty tall enough if you’ve other aspects to your game.
For those of us old enough to recall up until 25-30 years ago 6ft was fine. Someone like Joe Corrigan at 6 4 was seen as a true giant. 
Posts haven’t changed in size so I think too much can be read into smaller keepers by today’s standards.
No one ever considered Clemence or Shilton small, which they would be now.
Reply
Not sure the relevance of size is. O'Leary got to the ball, and it should have been an easy catch. Height had little to do with the error!
Reply
(01-25-2026, 05:53 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not sure the relevance of size is. O'Leary got to the ball, and it should have been an easy catch. Height had little to do with the error!

This
Reply
MOL is arguably the better of 3 very poor GK”s at this level

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
(01-25-2026, 06:18 PM)Cuzer Wrote: MOL is arguably the better of 3 very poor GK”s at this level

Cuzer

I'll reserve judgement until I've seen him week in, week out.   Griffiths has saved us more points than he has cost us and he'll only get better.
Reply
(01-25-2026, 05:53 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not sure the relevance of size is. O'Leary got to the ball, and it should have been an easy catch. Height had little to do with the error!

Both feet were off the ground. That's the difference. He jumped for it whereas Griffiths would have had feet planted.
Reply
(01-25-2026, 05:53 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Not sure the relevance of size is. O'Leary got to the ball, and it should have been an easy catch. Height had little to do with the error!

Taller people get high balls easier. It’s a great deal of relevance and that’s why keepers generally aren’t the size of Callum Styles. 
Harder for a 6ft 3-4 centre half to intimidate a keeper taller than him. 
Also the taller a person their reach is generally longer too so Griffiths, I’m convinced, would have had no problem with that cross at all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: