01-11-2025, 10:18 PM
(01-11-2025, 10:08 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(01-11-2025, 10:02 PM)Peachy Wrote: I think it's so sad what's happened to the FA Cup imo. The greatest domestic football cup competition in the history of the game. 3rd round day was one of the biggest on the calendar when I was growing up. (I'm 49)
To see it how it is now with every side fielding reserves and no replays etc. A huge part of the heritage of the game has gone forever. Call me sentimental or whatever but I think it's sad.
Bang on Peachy.
Everyone old enough to recall how football was once much fairer feels the same.
It mattered so much to players too. I recall Malcolm McDonald utterly inconsolable after Arsenal lost the 78 final, having experienced the same 4 years earlier with Newcastle.
I suppose you're old enough to recall thousands unable to get in the Hawthorns when we played Everton in 89.
I can recall being in crowds of over 35,000 when we played the likes of Cov and Southampton a decade or so earlier. I didn't get to the great Man U tie in 78, which again was rammed to the rafters.
If we'd played Bournemouth at home today I doubt we would have got more than 12,000.
Remember the Everton game well. That Everton cup home game is actually where my username came from. Peachofacross. "That's a peach of a cross from Goodman, and that's a lovely goal".
So many happy and sad fa cup memories. One of my favourite Albion games of all time was the home tie in the torrential rain against Charlton which we won 1-0. That game had absolutely everything. Naylor played a blinder.

