Concentrating on the league
#11
I'm in my mid forties. I my life time the "small" clubs to win the Cup have been Everton(!) twice, Coventry, Wimbledon, Portsmouth, Wigan, Leicester. So maybe once every 5 years someone else gets a crack. There's a lot of other teams saying the same thing as us.
Reply
#12
(01-11-2025, 04:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I have very little interest in the cup. Simply we can only hope to win this competition if we get back to being a Prem club who are not struggling against relegation.
2015 when we got fucked over in the quarter finals against Villa has been the best opportunity for us in the last 15 years or so.

Blues and Swansea say hello. Wigan too.
You never know if you put a good enough side out.
I have always loved the cups
Reply
#13
Our first team would have given them a game... for an hour until 5 of the 7 changes we made had to start entering the pitch. We're miles off them, as someone else said we needed to be right on it and weren't and they needed to have a massive off day and didn't.
Reply
#14
(01-11-2025, 08:49 PM)KRO Wrote:
(01-11-2025, 04:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I have very little interest in the cup. Simply we can only hope to win this competition if we get back to being a Prem club who are not struggling against relegation.
2015 when we got fucked over in the quarter finals against Villa has been the best opportunity for us in the last 15 years or so.

Blues and Swansea say hello. Wigan too.
You never know if you put a good enough side out.
I have always loved the cups

Yes. Blues, Wigan and Swansea who were all Premier League teams when they won the cups, and all of them now over a decade ago.

Cardiff, 17 years ago, is the last time a team outside the Prem got to an FA cup final. Coventry were unlucky last year, granted.

It's with adding only Leicester during COVID have broken the domination of the usual glamorous suspects in lifting the FA Cup in the last 12 years. In the previous 17 years only Wigan, who you mentioned and Portsmouth, the year they beat us in the semi, have broken the domination again of the usual suspects who have now won 26 of the last 29 cup finals. That's 5 clubs that have utterly monopolised the FA Cup dating back to the mid 90s.

If these stats don't demonstrate the futility of the competition, which has miniscule prize money, then nothing does.
Reply
#15
Prize money has eff all to do with it.
Managers picking weakened teams do. It’s nuts. You don’t get cash for winning random league games. But the strongest teams are usually picked. Fans have been radicalised to accept getting knocked out of the cups and it being a plus.
It’s ridiculous. You at Ipswich I think under Di Matteo a great example
Reply
#16
(01-11-2025, 09:28 PM)KRO Wrote: Prize money has eff all to do with it.
Managers picking weakened teams do. It’s nuts. You don’t get cash for winning random league games. But the strongest teams are usually picked. Fans have been radicalised to accept getting knocked out of the cups and it being a plus.
It’s ridiculous. You at Ipswich I think under Di Matteo a great example

Unfortunately it's a consequence of the disparity between the money for winning or getting promoted or attaining certain league positions and the one for winning the cup. I agree that its ridiculous to pick weakened teams but unfortunately a lot of managers prioritise the league for the reason that that's probably going to keep you in a job longer. I think its a shame. 

I can understand making some changes if you're playing against weaker opposition but I wish we'd not basically accepted that we were going to lose today before kickoff by putting out a team with a defence that had no time to play together beforehand.
Reply
#17
It’s become normalised.
I hate it mate
Reply
#18
(01-11-2025, 09:40 PM)KRO Wrote: It’s become normalised.
I hate it mate

Completely agree.

They keep adding new comps too. Eventually something's going to have to go, and the League cup will be first in line IMO
Reply
#19
(01-11-2025, 09:28 PM)KRO Wrote: Prize money has eff all to do with it.
Managers picking weakened teams do. It’s nuts. You don’t get cash for winning random league games. But the strongest teams are usually picked. Fans have been radicalised to accept getting knocked out of the cups and it being a plus.
It’s ridiculous. You at Ipswich I think under Di Matteo a great example

Prize money means nothing to the fans but we don't get a say.
It's because if you finish 1 point ahead of the team that are 3rd you will be in a league where you'll probably, unless they win the play-offs, be £150m richer than them.
It means poxy, but well-run, clubs like Bournemouth, who aren't really any bigger than Walsall, can have the whip hand over clubs like you and us that can bring 50,000 fans to Wembley.
Fans haven't been radicalised. We don't pick the teams. Football clubs outside the top flight believe they haven't the resources to win this competition so don't really have a go.
All the examples you cite KRO like your beloved Blues, Wigan, Swansea and even us with our lame quarter final exit v Ipswich are all very old examples too. 
The chasm between the Prem and the rest is wider than ever. It's fact that can be shown up with many statistics.
Dreaming of it being like the 1970s or 80s again where we watch the players at the team hotel and see who has the fittest wife is now the realms of ancient history.
It's a sickener, but the modern game at the top level is bordering on a closed shop making it a very frustrating existence for many famous clubs.
I hate it as much as you, but I'm being pragmatic about it. I hope it changes.


By the way, unless I'm mistaken, it's now 45 years since a team outside the top league won the FA Cup.
Reply
#20
I think it's so sad what's happened to the FA Cup imo. The greatest domestic football cup competition in the history of the game. 3rd round day was one of the biggest on the calendar when I was growing up. (I'm 49)

To see it how it is now with every side fielding reserves and no replays etc. A huge part of the heritage of the game has gone forever. Call me sentimental or whatever but I think it's sad.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: