(11-01-2024, 01:58 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:Capitalism is brutal, I appreciate that and the churn of markets impacts significantly on people. That is why we shouldn't have got ourselves in a mess like we have over the last decade ( I include Brexit in that). In an ideal world, Reeves should not have boxed herself in with the promises on income tax, VAT, and employee NICS. Hunt set that trap with two disgraceful NICs cuts knowing full well it would either have to be reversed or spending would have to fall significantly. He knew exactly what he was doing and did it for the benefit of the Conservative Party.(11-01-2024, 01:52 PM)Logic1 Wrote:(11-01-2024, 01:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-01-2024, 01:29 PM)Logic1 Wrote:(11-01-2024, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I don't disagree with much of this. I'm just not seeing any evidence though of the next incompetent lot (following the previous incompetent lot) to deliver.What if the increase in taxes on employment, leads to firms substituting away from labour to capital? Perhaps stimulating investment instead of relying on cheap labour? This has not been mentioned by anyone. Small business is exempted from much of the changes. Is it not right that private bigger business contributes to health and education and the country's defence? If we have a private health system, would that not have to be financed from employers like in the US? Is a healthier population and kids being educated in schools not falling down in the private sectors interest?
Too many assumptions on income and tax growth, when the reality is the Employers NI is going to drive a "blip" in inflation, and as a consequence Interest rates. I can see there being a gap in income when tax revenue is behind forecast. Not even the OBR are on-board with it fully.
This is a grown up chat. I think you should stay out of it.
Under the previous government the tax take went from 37% of GDP to 38%. This government plans to increase it to 39%. There are many countries that have a higher tax take than us and have much better living standards. If you have an ageing population, perhaps it is optimal to have higher taxes.
What do you call a small business? The Employment Allowance on NI means broadly less than 5 people.
Why should businesses of 5-100 carry the burden? Here in the real world (I advise on finance) I can tell you that those businesses are working on such fine margins that they can't afford these rises. They cannot afford to borrow to invest - the banks won't lend them the money because their margins are too thin, and they can't service the borrowing with the present interest rates - which are being prolonged by this budget.
That's the real world that my clients live in - not a Labour cabinet where not a single person has ever run a business in their lives, and live in a hypothetical world.
This is a nonsense argument. I dislike it when people use the term "real world". Is there such a thing as an unreal world? What defines what a real world is? As far as I know, there is only one world. At the margin, you might well be right, uncompetitive firms may be pushed out of the market. Their resources will be subsumed by more productive firms. Taxation creates dead weight efficiency loss but strong public services have to be financed from somewhere. In return for higher taxes, businesses get healthier and better educated workers and better transport etc. That will improve their ability to generate profits.
Come and do a day with me and my clients, and experience their real pressures. Not able to pay suppliers, not able to pay their mortgages.
That's the real world, not "uncompetitive firms may be pushed out of the market. Their resources will be subsumed by more productive firms". Try saying that to people who lose their jobs a week before Christmas because their employers can afford the increase in Employers NI. They have families and bills Real lives.
Load it on everyone, not just the ones targeted by Labour.
I guess that is the real story of the last government, looking after the Conservative Party and not the country. Easy to blame Reeves, but the media is set up against the Labour Party so no surprises she made the choice to roll back the NICs cuts by sticking it on business (some of it will also be absorbed by owners and not just workers btw). One thing that proves this is the generally widespread accepted narrative, across all media, that paying tax is bad and that there is no return to taxation with better public services. It's like they just assume all the money will be wasted. I guess we'll see. Last time the Labour Party spent big on the NHS, things improved. It will be harder this time though as the population is older.
PS: perhaps your clients could pay less money to their financial advisors?

