10-13-2024, 11:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-13-2024, 11:09 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(10-13-2024, 10:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote:(10-13-2024, 03:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol was an absolute disgrace
A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out
Cuzer
Not a disgrace. A stretch maybe. Lots of really close rounds. Beterbiev got given them.
Four factors in boxing scoring:
Clean punching (effect important)
Effective aggression
Ring generalship
Defence
In those close rounds (there were a good number of them), it’s reasonable to give them
betwrbiev.
Thing is, when Bivol let rip, he outboxed Beterbiev. But in lots of the close rounds (and there were many of them), he only did it for say, three 15 second spurts. He circled the ring a lot.
Whereas Beterbiev would have been favoured in effective aggression, and ring control (as Yarde pointed out after in the studio).
Plus, in terms of clean and effective punching…. The stats were super close in terms of how many landed. So then we go to how effective… the judges have a better idea close up…. What clue do we have? Bivol’s face afterwards… so Beterbiev more effective too with his heavy hands.
Hard to separate in defence in the close rounds.
So I can easily see why he was given so many close rounds. Bivol needed to do more in a lot of those rounds. Bivol did the best looking work. But nowhere near enough of it taking all factors into account.
It was very close and both class acts. But 8-4 can easily happen in a close fight, for reasons above.
Hopefully we’ll see a best of 3!
There is no way, on gods green earth, Bivol only won four rounds in that fight
The card is a disgrace
Absolutely a tight fight, I had Bivol by only one round but to give him four rounds out of twelve, shoukd never work again
Cuzer
Way OTT that.
It was close. I had a draw but only a 2 round “swing” from a draw is 8-4.
1 judge had 7-5, and despite plenty seeing Bivol as winner, a number of viewers and pundits also edged towards Beterbiev 7-5, so is a one round swing from that really a “digrace”? nah. There were tons of close rounds and I’ve explained why judges could reasonably give plenty of those to Beterbiev.
Close fights can be 8-4, when the rounds are very very close individually. Rounds are hardly ever given as draws, so overall had to be a draw, 2 point, or 4 point deficit. It may “feel” wrong with the closeness of the fight overall, but the fact is rounds are scored individually, so you can rack up a lead by slightly edging a lot of close rounds. And one judge clearly didn’t like bivols intermittent work, however classy, and put more emphasis on effective aggression and controlling the ring to give him the close rounds.. of which there were plenty.

