05-09-2023, 03:50 PM
(05-09-2023, 02:32 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(05-09-2023, 12:53 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote:(05-09-2023, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: Great post Prag. I've been thinking for a while that the MSD loan was sought out to buy us time to find a buyer. This may also explain why Carlos is still engaged as much as he is.
In many ways the MSD loan forces sale: the debt for shares obligation means any default further increases losses and the terms prohibit any further cash leaving the business.
Therefore, they need to sell now to minimise any further losses.
I'm not aware of any debt for equity swap option being announced? Surely the only way that could happen would be if the loan was in default? S4A have completely missed the point and the structure of these types of loans, as evidenced by some of the questions they asked in the letter recently published.
The club has insufficient cashflow to meet it's day to day obligations, so this loan will most likely be structured with a bullet repayment, possibly with interest rolling up. Asking about what the repayment term is (we know it is 4 years) and the split between capital and interest misses the point.
So if the loan is payable in 4 years time, then pressure from MSD won't be the catalyst for something to happen. It will be when we can't afford to pay the wages, or our committed transfer fees (like the remaining instalments on Grant's loan) that will likely force MSD into action. As Prag suggested in the opening post, Lai will want the club gone before then, otherwise the investors will lose everything.
The only thing we don't know is when will happen? I said early I thought Lai might have one more season, but I'm starting to agree with Prag. I say this because our Turnover in the year ended June 2022 with TV/Parachute monies stripped out was £13.7M. A typical Chump club would receive £5M, so let's round it up to £20M for us in the EFL. Our wage bill in 2022 was £42.7M. And we owe a further £10.7M to other league clubs in transfers(reduced by £2M in the last 12 months). Even with the MSD £20M, I think something has to give. Our monthly outgoings have to be c£4M a month, possibly more.
There’s no debt for equity swap option.
The S4A questions are very good ones - trying to force details out into the open. Some questions are possible more relevant than others, but there are lots of stones to look underneath.
MSD are no fools - they don’t enter into these loans not expecting to get paid. They’ve got enough security to satisfy them but they won’t want to call it in. This is basically bridging finance to buy time for a sale. I believe Yunyai probably made a decision to sell this time last year, but wanted this season to see if they could sell with Premier League status to try to get £100m more of their money back. They needed a Plan B though, and that is where we are now.
I don’t think Lai can afford another season, without selling all players worth selling and somehow trying to replace them very cheaply, which hardly enhances the prospects of promotion. If our chances of promotion in 2022/3 were 30%, then in 2023/4 without a new owner injecting some cash it’s probably less than 5%, and with a much reduced share value with mounting debt. Not worth the effort compared to taking a sensible price now, and certainly not worth the added risk of administration and losing everything in a year’s time. But of course there’s no guarantee that a sale of the club will get agreed this summer, so using the £20m loan and making sales of players has to be the alternative.
Timing-wise it makes no sense to start selling players immediately if a sale is going to happen. This is why I expect a sale to potentially already lined up now that we know where we are. The sooner the better so that everyone can move forward ready for the new season.
The next few weeks could be very interesting - one way or another!

