05-09-2023, 08:32 AM
I’ve been convinced for some time now that Yunyai will actively look to sell the club. It is totally understandable that they would not sell before knowing whether they would be selling a Premier League club or a Championship club (with no parachute funding left) as that’s the difference between selling a club worth £150m or a club worth £60m. They now know.
They don’t have funds to invest into the club, but they know that extra cash is needed to keep the club ticking over. I don’t believe they took out the £20m MSD loan as a long-term strategy. I believe they took it to buy time and breathing space to sell the club this summer as a going concern. Without that cash flow boost, the club may well have been likely to run out of cash before the end of next season (despite being balance sheet solvent) which would have meant that the threat of administration was much higher and would reduce the value to Yunyai to a lot less than £60m.
They know that without parachute funding, every other club in the Championship is dependent on shareholder loans, which they cannot provide. The risk of relegation within 2-3 years would be a lot higher, further reducing the value of their investment.
There is not a single reason left now for Yunyai to hang on to their investment. The chances of promotion have now diminished massively, while the chances of relegation or mere stagnation have risen proportionately. Now is the time to achieve an orderly sale at the best price possible, at a time when there is no significant external debt (the £20m MSD loan has not yet been spent, so the cash sits on the other side of the balance sheet. Right now, the club is still worth around £60m to £70m, but that price will diminish soon when that MSD cash gets used up.
Yunyai are now likely to be talking to the potential (American) buyers who wanted to buy last year for around £100m, plus others.
There is not a single reason remaining for Yunyai to retain this investment. Their 1,000+ investors will have already lost 70% of their original investment. 30% is the absolute most they will get back, and it could quickly become 15% if they don’t sell in the coming weeks.
“Loss of face” (important in Chinese culture) has already happened. Holding out for promotion via the play-offs was fully justified to try to recover “face”. But the investors aren’t totally stupid. Notwithstanding the “face” factor, every bad investment eventually comes to an end with a commercial decision.
I’m not remotely ITK, although I know a fair bit about Chinese culture. I would be very surprised indeed if the button has not already been pressed in Shanghai to seek to sell the club this summer. Their investment has completely run its course.
They don’t have funds to invest into the club, but they know that extra cash is needed to keep the club ticking over. I don’t believe they took out the £20m MSD loan as a long-term strategy. I believe they took it to buy time and breathing space to sell the club this summer as a going concern. Without that cash flow boost, the club may well have been likely to run out of cash before the end of next season (despite being balance sheet solvent) which would have meant that the threat of administration was much higher and would reduce the value to Yunyai to a lot less than £60m.
They know that without parachute funding, every other club in the Championship is dependent on shareholder loans, which they cannot provide. The risk of relegation within 2-3 years would be a lot higher, further reducing the value of their investment.
There is not a single reason left now for Yunyai to hang on to their investment. The chances of promotion have now diminished massively, while the chances of relegation or mere stagnation have risen proportionately. Now is the time to achieve an orderly sale at the best price possible, at a time when there is no significant external debt (the £20m MSD loan has not yet been spent, so the cash sits on the other side of the balance sheet. Right now, the club is still worth around £60m to £70m, but that price will diminish soon when that MSD cash gets used up.
Yunyai are now likely to be talking to the potential (American) buyers who wanted to buy last year for around £100m, plus others.
There is not a single reason remaining for Yunyai to retain this investment. Their 1,000+ investors will have already lost 70% of their original investment. 30% is the absolute most they will get back, and it could quickly become 15% if they don’t sell in the coming weeks.
“Loss of face” (important in Chinese culture) has already happened. Holding out for promotion via the play-offs was fully justified to try to recover “face”. But the investors aren’t totally stupid. Notwithstanding the “face” factor, every bad investment eventually comes to an end with a commercial decision.
I’m not remotely ITK, although I know a fair bit about Chinese culture. I would be very surprised indeed if the button has not already been pressed in Shanghai to seek to sell the club this summer. Their investment has completely run its course.

