04-22-2019, 10:13 AM
(04-22-2019, 09:09 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-22-2019, 08:58 AM)billybassett Wrote:(04-22-2019, 08:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-22-2019, 08:23 AM)billybassett Wrote:(04-21-2019, 05:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I never directly put my reply to you, it was to MT and the clue was me saying “playing Devil’s advocate”. Also the point seems to have been lost that our relative cup successes quarter final, semi final whether we have or haven’t been taken cup ties seriously over the years have been due to recieving Prem money. If we had failed to go up in that time cup success would have been even further away. Now it can be argued that we should have focused more on the cup but the rights and wrongs of that are completely subjective, what isn’t is the need to continue to bring the Prem cash in to enable us in the future to win either cup.
The point about Ajax and Porto is irrelevant. They are the biggest clubs in their leagues, they receive the biggest sponsorship deals, they attract and develop the best players in their respective league. Why are those two clubs relevant to ourselves? Also Leicester did exceptionally well but they broken FFP rules in the Championship and were bankrolled into the Prem.
We've had this discussion before on here so I won't repeat my views but I've seen numerous posters on here agree with playing a second string against whatever opposition in the cups because it rests players for avoiding relegation or trying to get promotion.
All those posters need to take a hard look in the mirror. Given financially and football pyramid wise we've been at out zenith in recent years to have not gone all out for the cup comps is frankly incompetent. If we are unfortunate enough to have to wallow in the chump for a few years with a poorer side and smaller resources I'm sure those posters will be clamouring for a cup run to give them some hope. If they then can't see how completely illogical this is then I guess there's no hope.
I’ll be clamouring to get promotion because our chances of winning the cup will be proportional to our success in the leagues. The two are linked.
Agreed. But not sure why you think clamouring for promotion is mutually exclusive to clamouring for a cup run.
I don’t, I think it all depends on the circumstances.
There are no circumstances in my mind fur entering a competition and then doing your utmost to reduce your chances.
Of course if you're Liverpool you may wish to prioritise the champions League over the fa cup buy we are not in that boat so no excuse not to go for it
