01-30-2022, 11:23 AM
I deplore the notion of player power. Way back in 1992 they coasted to a seventh place finish to see Gould off (not that it was a bad result). The rebellion against McDonough was probably a professional move by players who cared and the resistance to Mel's tactics was at least backed up by a competent coaching staff and an alternative plan.
These players seemed oblivious to the slow decline under Bilic and were actively opposed to the changes Sam tried to bring in. Relegation seemed to be someone else's fault, not theirs. Now they don't like what Ismael is asking them to do. Is it true that they are an idle bunch, resistant to training hard? Is Ismael an arrogant and impatient coach with "my way or highway" tattooed on his soul? They seem to be trying and failing to play it his way, playing with fear of the consequences. They seem to care about defeat, they don't stroll off smirking after the final whistle.
But what is Ismael trying to achieve? Is there a set of players somewhere who could make it work? Can his style of play win the Championship and thrive in the Premier League? I'm not convinced that it's a winning formula - I accept that we haven't seen it done properly but the players have tried (at times) and you can't just change them all out like a game of Scrabble when you have all the Qs, Xs and Zs. Ismael's Barnsley record of 55 goals in 41 matches (?) including play-offs isn't a scintillating effort. You need to defend well to progress if you're scoring at that rate.
All I know at the moment is that it isn't working and it isn't going to start working any time soon. Regardless of the financial implications, the club can't let this toxic situation go on for much longer. A run of wins might pull us out of the mire. Does anyone think that likely?
These players seemed oblivious to the slow decline under Bilic and were actively opposed to the changes Sam tried to bring in. Relegation seemed to be someone else's fault, not theirs. Now they don't like what Ismael is asking them to do. Is it true that they are an idle bunch, resistant to training hard? Is Ismael an arrogant and impatient coach with "my way or highway" tattooed on his soul? They seem to be trying and failing to play it his way, playing with fear of the consequences. They seem to care about defeat, they don't stroll off smirking after the final whistle.
But what is Ismael trying to achieve? Is there a set of players somewhere who could make it work? Can his style of play win the Championship and thrive in the Premier League? I'm not convinced that it's a winning formula - I accept that we haven't seen it done properly but the players have tried (at times) and you can't just change them all out like a game of Scrabble when you have all the Qs, Xs and Zs. Ismael's Barnsley record of 55 goals in 41 matches (?) including play-offs isn't a scintillating effort. You need to defend well to progress if you're scoring at that rate.
All I know at the moment is that it isn't working and it isn't going to start working any time soon. Regardless of the financial implications, the club can't let this toxic situation go on for much longer. A run of wins might pull us out of the mire. Does anyone think that likely?

