12-27-2021, 01:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-27-2021, 01:57 PM by Pragmatist.)
(12-27-2021, 12:56 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Without making any excuses for the poor planning, muddled thinking and utter dire quality of this whole Ashes effort from England, it is worth pointing out that there was another really fine "umpire's call" lbw which went against England to dismiss Malan. Not the first in this series. Australian umpires don't know the meaning of "unbiased", they just can't help themselves. The identical delivery to an Aussie batsman would be "umpire's call, not out", you can bet on it.
It used to be England's eleven vs eleven Aussie players and two umpires. Now it's eleven Aussie players and five umpires. Having David Boon and Paul Reiffel amongst the officials is a bit like picking Ian Botham and Gus Fraser to be neutral umpires at home.
Back in October, Mo Bobat (ECB Performance Director) challenged the England Lions squad to "break into contention" for the Ashes. I can't see a single reason for not giving the gloves to Foakes for the 4th Test. Stokes, Buttler, Bairstow all owe us a proper score, if not maybe it's time for a change. It's harsh to comment on Root's habit of getting out for 50, because he's getting 50 most of the time. He must feel very lonely out there.
Whilst I totally agree that Foakes should be keeping, he won’t be playing in the 4th Test as he’s currently back in England ! Not sure that Stokes yet “owes us a score”. He’s been out all year with injury and illness and this is only his third Test back.
(12-27-2021, 01:48 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:(12-27-2021, 12:56 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Without making any excuses for the poor planning, muddled thinking and utter dire quality of this whole Ashes effort from England, it is worth pointing out that there was another really fine "umpire's call" lbw which went against England to dismiss Malan. Not the first in this series. Australian umpires don't know the meaning of "unbiased", they just can't help themselves. The identical delivery to an Aussie batsman would be "umpire's call, not out", you can bet on it.Really very selective .. wow! So Reiffel giving Harris out when he edged an lbw shout and Leach getting the benefit of umpires call on Green .. they are examples of aussie umpire bias too?
It used to be England's eleven vs eleven Aussie players and two umpires. Now it's eleven Aussie players and five umpires. Having David Boon and Paul Reiffel amongst the officials is a bit like picking Ian Botham and Gus Fraser to be neutral umpires at home.
Back in October, Mo Bobat (ECB Performance Director) challenged the England Lions squad to "break into contention" for the Ashes. I can't see a single reason for not giving the gloves to Foakes for the 4th Test. Stokes, Buttler, Bairstow all owe us a proper score, if not maybe it's time for a change. It's harsh to comment on Root's habit of getting out for 50, because he's getting 50 most of the time. He must feel very lonely out there.
If you're looking for bias take an introspective look .. comical!
Under the microscope of TV and multiple replays a “biased” umpire would not survive.

