04-29-2021, 08:49 AM
All good points JOK, my issue was with the throw away comment that is being used by 'downplayers' as a reason to reduce lockdown measure quicker as a large proportion get it in hospital. Apologies for grouping you with them - I have a particular dislike of that stat because used in isolation it can make people think that its not as bad as is being described.
Even the data you use only highlights half of the number used and that for a very limited study 1,500 across 11 hospitals (that is 0.3% of the UK hospitalisations and includes an Italian hospital which we don't have total numbers for) and the 23% (not 25% quoted) is an estimate. And each one of those newspaper reports have used the worst case to make the story more tantalising. The figure you quoted (25%) is very much a misrepresentation of any fact.
I've pointed out on here many times that using 'died with', 'died from', or just having covid on the death cert can be used to muddy the waters (and has been) when the facts are that excess deaths tell the story without all the doubt as to the cost of covid.
And the ICU beds stat being at 80% - this ignores two big points. ICU beds have been increased for covid (on previous capacity the % would have been much higher and other wards had to close to accommodate the reallocation to ICU not to comment on the nightingales that counted as ICU and were never used). By saying ICU beds "never rose above 80% and ventilators even less" again it is saying "it wasn't that bad".
And 80% represents the whole country when the virus wasn't consistently attacking the whole country. There were areas that would have been at full capacity and others at 60% (both examples) and it wasn't as if you could just take the patient 100s of miles to where the free beds were.
My issue is anyone who uses, directly or indirectly, comments that imply 'it wasn't that bad' - It was and could be again if we drop our guard.
Even the data you use only highlights half of the number used and that for a very limited study 1,500 across 11 hospitals (that is 0.3% of the UK hospitalisations and includes an Italian hospital which we don't have total numbers for) and the 23% (not 25% quoted) is an estimate. And each one of those newspaper reports have used the worst case to make the story more tantalising. The figure you quoted (25%) is very much a misrepresentation of any fact.
I've pointed out on here many times that using 'died with', 'died from', or just having covid on the death cert can be used to muddy the waters (and has been) when the facts are that excess deaths tell the story without all the doubt as to the cost of covid.
And the ICU beds stat being at 80% - this ignores two big points. ICU beds have been increased for covid (on previous capacity the % would have been much higher and other wards had to close to accommodate the reallocation to ICU not to comment on the nightingales that counted as ICU and were never used). By saying ICU beds "never rose above 80% and ventilators even less" again it is saying "it wasn't that bad".
And 80% represents the whole country when the virus wasn't consistently attacking the whole country. There were areas that would have been at full capacity and others at 60% (both examples) and it wasn't as if you could just take the patient 100s of miles to where the free beds were.
My issue is anyone who uses, directly or indirectly, comments that imply 'it wasn't that bad' - It was and could be again if we drop our guard.

