09-20-2020, 04:50 PM
(09-20-2020, 04:11 PM)steviedm Wrote:(09-20-2020, 02:12 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:(09-20-2020, 11:57 AM)Ampadu's Left Boot Wrote:(09-20-2020, 10:57 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:(09-20-2020, 10:02 AM)Ampadu's Left Boot Wrote: The Premier League may attract a global audience of billions but it is the U.K. public who fill the BBC's coffers. It's easy to provide different edits of the same show so the 'worldwide audience' excuse doesn't wash. I think a couple of minutes to talk about Albion and the two superb goals they scored that afternoon wouldn't have been too much to ask.
I believe they do it live, so unless they change that, they wouldnt be able to do different edits, and then you'd have to worry about them completely all the filming in time if they moved away from doing it live.
Certainly possible, and a great idea to be fair, I just don't think that's currently possible the way they do things.
How many people worldwide watch live MOTD? Or even watch it all? Give me strength. The BBC's duty is to the U.K. public, they can edit the live broadcast while it's on and China, South America et al can get the 'live' broadcast' with a slight delay, like people in those countries would have an idea of any 'delay' anyway. There's no excuse for not giving fair time on the show to teams like Albion. The truth is that they just don't give a shit.
Missed my point entirely. The consensus seems to be that the analysis after is the real shit part that could be edited/changed based on where you're watching... well how and when would they do that editing/changing what the pundits say if the original broadcast is live, specifically the punditry? How would a short delay to foreign countries change that?
It's been a few years but I used to work on Match of the Day (when it came out of BBC TV Centre) and it's certainly a live programme. It was still pretty much all on tape when I worked there and there'd often be an assistant producer working his or her balls off to finish an edit seconds before it was due to be played in. It was seat of the pants stuff at times. I imagine it's a bit quicker now with digital files - in those days, the game would be recorded on 90 minute digital tapes (one half per tape) and this would be the mixed feed coming from the outside broadcast van at the ground (i.e. the match director's version with cuts to different cameras/replays played in etc). At the end of each half, the isolated angles from each of the match cameras would be played in and recorded. The match director may not, for example, have played in one of the better replays of a goal or incident and this would be useful for the programme edit. Of course, this meant spooling the tape from the time of the incident to the isos at the end to check them and then back again. A lot of time was wasted fast forwarding and rewinding tapes. Happy days. It's all done in Salford now and is probably a totally different experience.
There used to be a lovely chap called Graham who often ran VT when I was there - he was a Wolves fan, but not the editor. The programme editor when I was there was Paul Armstrong - a proper Boro fan and one of the loveliest blokes you would want to meet - absolutely a proper football fan. More recently, it's been edited by someone I was mates with who's an Everton fan but one of those north Welsh ones so actually is much more of a rugby fan than football.
Like others on here, I haven't watched the programme for years - no need when you've got Sky etc. I do think the obsession with a few clubs has got worse over the years and the BBC is patronising at best. I didn't see it yesterday but not to mention the Pereira free kick is criminal and I can guarantee Paul Armstrong would have found time for it to be shown again. Probably both goals to be honest. If they failed to mention us at all, not even a line, after the game then this is definitely a departure from when I was there - then, the editor in the gallery would be talking to the panel while they're on air and saying things like "a word on West Brom now, please."
Really interesting insight. Thanks.

