05-01-2020, 08:43 AM
(04-30-2020, 05:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(04-30-2020, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm asking for a debate, not a one-sided lowest common denominator protect-everything-at-all-costs scarefest with no end in sight. From some of the responses it's clear that a few folk would've been happy living in East Berlin before the wall came down.
Proth you only ever see one side of a debate, your entire belief system is based on the accumulation of wealth above most other things, it’s how you validate someone’s opinion is the correct one or not. So what you’re really hoping for is the economy is put before people’s lives at the earliest opportunity but only some people’s lives, the ones that cost money rather than make. Unless you are advocating they are protected properly and logically that would include them and their families, finances were secured until such time as the risk was minimal. Forgive me if that seems harsh but your postings for years have rarely if ever as far as I can recall ever deviated from the most purest and ideological form of capitalism.
A way out would be for testing to be available across the UK so you can identify, trace and lock down areas where the virus shows an outbreak. Proactive measures not reactive which we have seen all through this crisis from the government. That way people would be able to go back to work at a relatively low risk over a managed time and the vulnerable wouldn’t be prisoners in their own homes. The only balancing act for this would be how low the risk would need to be, until hopefully at some point a vaccine is found or better medicines are found to aid recovery.
The fact is we can’t currently do that is because austerity left the country completely unprepared for such a way of operating. We are now trying to play catch-up and how much more has this cost in lives and economically in the long term than curbing the worst instincts of austerity to cut and cut again until we are scrabbling around for wafer thin plastic sheeting to protect frontline staff as an example?
What would your solution be? Just lift the lockdown and see what happens?
Hilarious coming from the the most one-eyed of the cyclops herd on here.
I'm asking for an adult debate about the opportunity cost of a Lockdown of this scale. For the record, my mother has had Stage 4 cancer for 8 years and is in isolation with my brother who moved in with her 8 weeks ago. I have two kids missing out on vital time at school. I have as much skin in the game as anyone on here.
Those seeking to protect every single life are at odds with reality. We can't live in stasis until there's a vaccine, "testing" is a panacea too.
Contrary to your point about austerity, it appears that the NHS is coping just fine with plenty of capacity.
As such the answer to your final question is - continued indefinite isolation for the most vulnerable and lift the the lockdown progressively for everyone else.

