(03-09-2020, 03:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It's all good and well saying that Civil Servants are the problem, and there are a couple of good anecdotes there Hudds - cheers, but what is the alternative. Or is there no real desire or need for an alternative, just someone to blame?
I’m not really sure of a definitive solution. Bear in mind, Proth is a very different shade politically but I am in general agreement with him. It would help if the civil service intake was broader and deeper, perhaps with cross-secondments more with industry and a limited permitted service. On the hoof, it might help if there were some strategic use of political “Commissars”, not to dictate but to robustly critique back-sliding on policy matters and to listen carefully to other views (eg from industry) to balance the civil servants’ (invariably biased) briefings to ministers.
All I can say is that, coming into the Civil Service at 30 in 1988, I was astonished by the self-serving attitudes – it was never about “the public interest” at all but playing the internal system. There were some talented people but they had become institutionalised. I was deemed a freak because I wasn’t a typical civil servant and I took a real interest in the work, so got a lot of the tougher gigs and I also managed to change a lot of the old crap quite quickly, but I chose to leave (after 10 years) to force changes that I couldn’t achieve from within.
One change I always wanted took three years and advanced litigation before HMT caved in and then agreed that I had a good case and changed the law! They just didn’t want to countenance reasonable (and necessary) change in the first place to remove unnecessary financial burdens on business and which was of no revenue risk (the change I pressed for became the Excise Payment Security System (EPSS) if you can be arsed to google it). So, revenons a nos moutons, HMT had to go back and tell their minister that all was well after all the fuss and effort to try to defend the status quo, so I can believe a minister can lose patience with civil servants and call them “useless”.

