12-01-2019, 07:27 PM
I think the principle of VAR is brilliant, and I thought at the WC it worked really well, bar a couple of lengthy decisions. I was optimistic that as refs got more used to the system a lot of the slow decisions and controversial inconsistencies would even themselves out, but it’s fast spiralling out of control.
The principle of “clear and obvious” has been completely lost in a quest for absolute accuracy and application of rules to letter of the law which football is far too fast a paced game to allow.
I was a big fan of VAR and have defended it a lot, but seeing how the PL are applying it is farcical. There needs to be a set amount of time to decide decisions - 15s is plenty of time to see if something is clear and obvious, and a couple of camera angles from the ref’s view and assistant’s. If this can’t be sorted the whole thing needs scrapping as this quest for an impossible perfection is far worse than the odd bad decision .
Giving teams set numbers of Reviews is far from the answer as this won’t change frustrations with decision times or goal checks as there will no doubt be tactical use of reviews or optimistic uses that will find something 4-5 passes ago that overrules goals.
The principle of “clear and obvious” has been completely lost in a quest for absolute accuracy and application of rules to letter of the law which football is far too fast a paced game to allow.
I was a big fan of VAR and have defended it a lot, but seeing how the PL are applying it is farcical. There needs to be a set amount of time to decide decisions - 15s is plenty of time to see if something is clear and obvious, and a couple of camera angles from the ref’s view and assistant’s. If this can’t be sorted the whole thing needs scrapping as this quest for an impossible perfection is far worse than the odd bad decision .
Giving teams set numbers of Reviews is far from the answer as this won’t change frustrations with decision times or goal checks as there will no doubt be tactical use of reviews or optimistic uses that will find something 4-5 passes ago that overrules goals.

