11-13-2019, 02:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2019, 02:21 PM by Pragmatist.)
(11-13-2019, 01:31 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It'll be nigh on impossible to do owt about the 'tapping up' that goes on. Players only have to turn down contracts now and clubs are fucked.
Correct - we can’t stop the tapping up, but the compensation arrangements need to be a lot fairer.
(11-13-2019, 02:05 PM)Hopalong Wrote:(11-13-2019, 01:32 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Don't we get £4m for Barrie(?) if he's a success?
If that's the case (and I accept it might not be), it seems pretty reasonable. I can't imagine the academy staff on big money, so surely that covers a whole year and then some? We then have the rest of the crop to make something out of - for free.
I had a look at some of the other academy poachee's who we got upset about. I couldn't find one that's been a runaway success. Probably Chris Wood - and that's stretching the definitions of 'academy graduate' and 'poached'! For all the panic of harper leaving on a free, how much is he actually worth to the club? Obviously not much to the playing squad...
What we really should be concentrating on is a route to our first team. If we get them to play there, not only will less leave, they will also be worth more with first team appearances under their belts.
...isn't that really the point of the academy, anyway?
Regardless, I don't think the issue is of youngsters leaving, it's more that none have actually been successful - with us or anyone else. That what we should be getting pissed off about.
'Don't we get £4m for Barrie(?) if he's a success?'
No. £235,000 and that's because he wasn't under contract.
You may be thinking of Rogers who was contractually tied. We've reportedly had 4m for him and will reportedly get another 4m if he meets whatever conditions were agreed as part of the deal, appearances etc...
That’s correct. Barry was under contract and went to a non-English club who only have to pay nominal compensation. The Rogers deal with City was fine, but only possible as he moved to an English club. If the player is not under contract because he’s too young to sign a professional contract, ie not yet 17, then we are screwed. The system is woefully deficient and must be addressed.

