09-27-2019, 10:58 AM
There are things which need addressing when it comes to the charitable status of private schools; things which should have been addressed long ago by successive governments and The Charity Commission. Here's an example of why...
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.
Some years ago I worked for a very successful privately-owned company. Some of the owners (not all) sent their kids to pretty expensive private schools, paid the fees through the business, rounded up the amount and called it a donation. The charitable status of the schools allowed them to receive donated income free of tax; the business offset the expenditure against its corporation tax liability; the owners (also directors) did not declare the payments as a benefit in kind; tax was either avoided or exempted by all three of the parties; the auditors - much though they didn't want to - knew all about it. And I know they did because I told them. In the scheme of things, this anecdote is just one tiny flake in a whole blizzard of under-the-counter patronage and avoidance.
These are the kind of issues that do need addressing, but preferably rationally, not emotively, and by someone with a bit more credibility than Diane Abbott. Personally I have no issues at all with people sending their children to private schools; I do have a problem with certain schools being an automatic conduit to power and influence, but that's a different argument. Unfortunately we don't have the climate for forensic, rational scrutiny and debate; not in politics, not in the media.

