The Short Blanket
#31
(02-03-2025, 08:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 07:22 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2025, 03:41 PM)richbaggie Wrote: “The ‘short blanket’… if you cover your head, you have your feet cold, but if you cover your feet, you have your head cold.”

Rafa Benitez pointing out that the more risks you take in committing players forward, the more open it will leave you at the back. Whilst if you are too defensive, it leaves you more open to failing to score enough goals.


It always felt like Carlos had the same conundrum and Mogga is finding that out too.

The squad is slowly being updated but we have far too many players that have not been good enough for 3 years, a weak spine and very little up front. Yes, there's talent but it's a very unbalanced overall squad that's very much in transition under the new owners.

Not sure the blanket analogy applies to us right now. I think when Bartley is fit again we'll be tighter at the back. I'm more perplexed by the other end of the pitch. We dominate possession in most games but it doesn't reflect in chances created. I think if teams snuff out the threat we have on the flanks then it makes it very hard for us. On Saturday, Mikey was almost always sent down the outside by Plymouth's RB and they doubled up on Fellows most of the time. We need more from Diangana, Swift and Mowett. That said a fit no. 9 would be very welcome

I think it very much agrees to us defensively. Carlos protected us defensively by not releasing too many players at once (which was a criticism by many) Playing Swift and Mowatt as your central midfield exposed us Saturday and defensively we were pretty poor. Plymouth won 80% of the tackles and not one Albion player won more than one tackle.

TM needs to find a better balance between the defensive approach of CC and his romantic ideal of attacking football otherwise this season could quite easily slip away from us.

I thought he was more pragmatic now? Too early to say but unless he plays Molumby and Mowatt in central midfield I will come to the conclusion he hasn’t really changed. Powder puff football without the massive gulf in class that we had when he was previously here will get us nowhere.
Reply
#32
(02-03-2025, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 08:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 07:22 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-02-2025, 03:41 PM)richbaggie Wrote: “The ‘short blanket’… if you cover your head, you have your feet cold, but if you cover your feet, you have your head cold.”

Rafa Benitez pointing out that the more risks you take in committing players forward, the more open it will leave you at the back. Whilst if you are too defensive, it leaves you more open to failing to score enough goals.


It always felt like Carlos had the same conundrum and Mogga is finding that out too.

The squad is slowly being updated but we have far too many players that have not been good enough for 3 years, a weak spine and very little up front. Yes, there's talent but it's a very unbalanced overall squad that's very much in transition under the new owners.

Not sure the blanket analogy applies to us right now. I think when Bartley is fit again we'll be tighter at the back. I'm more perplexed by the other end of the pitch. We dominate possession in most games but it doesn't reflect in chances created. I think if teams snuff out the threat we have on the flanks then it makes it very hard for us. On Saturday, Mikey was almost always sent down the outside by Plymouth's RB and they doubled up on Fellows most of the time. We need more from Diangana, Swift and Mowett. That said a fit no. 9 would be very welcome

I think it very much agrees to us defensively. Carlos protected us defensively by not releasing too many players at once (which was a criticism by many) Playing Swift and Mowatt as your central midfield exposed us Saturday and defensively we were pretty poor. Plymouth won 80% of the tackles and not one Albion player won more than one tackle.

TM needs to find a better balance between the defensive approach of CC and his romantic ideal of attacking football otherwise this season could quite easily slip away from us.

I thought he was more pragmatic now? Too early to say but unless he plays Molumby and Mowatt in central midfield I will come to the conclusion he hasn’t really changed. Powder puff football without the massive gulf in class that we had when he was previously here will get us nowhere.

Not sure we have been "powder puff" we never defend by making lots of tackles, pressing hard up the pitch, and physically dominating teams. And to be fair against Plymouth we didn't get caught out because of a lack of physicality or defensive players on the pitch. In fact it was the opposite. We didn't control the game well enough second half, which allowed them to hurt us on their transitions and they got 2 goals which were piss poor from our back 4. 
The only change midfield I can see working if what you say is right is Diakite, as he seems the most dominant defensively. Not sure, and never have been to be fair, that Molumby and Mowatt are actually compatible, they are too similar.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
First time around TM had a squad that should have won promotion but didn't. After cleaning much of it out and assembling his own team we won the league. I have no idea if he can emulate that but from previous, he'll want a year to wheel and deal. I fully expect us to go backwards for a while before any consistent improvements become apparent. I have no idea how it will end but I believe TM is the type of character to insist it'll be done his way. Like it or not, patience will be required.
Reply
#34
(02-03-2025, 10:28 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: First time around TM had a squad that should have won promotion but didn't. After cleaning much of it out and assembling his own team we won the league. I have no idea if he can emulate that but from previous,  he'll want a year to wheel and deal. I fully expect us to go backwards for a while before any consistent improvements become apparent. I have no idea how it will end but I believe TM is the type of character to insist it'll be done his way. Like it or not, patience will be required.

They way this team has been left there is no need for it to go backwards before going forwards and would represent a huge waste of time. The foundation of a solid, if unspectacular side are there. There is absolutely no need to rip up the one part of our team that was functioning as intended.
Reply
#35
(02-03-2025, 10:52 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:28 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: First time around TM had a squad that should have won promotion but didn't. After cleaning much of it out and assembling his own team we won the league. I have no idea if he can emulate that but from previous,  he'll want a year to wheel and deal. I fully expect us to go backwards for a while before any consistent improvements become apparent. I have no idea how it will end but I believe TM is the type of character to insist it'll be done his way. Like it or not, patience will be required.

They way this team has been left there is no need for it to go backwards before going forwards and would represent a huge waste of time. The foundation of a solid, if unspectacular side are there. There is absolutely no need to rip up the one part of our team that was functioning as intended.

I agree. I just think it will happen.
Reply
#36
(02-03-2025, 10:54 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:52 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:28 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: First time around TM had a squad that should have won promotion but didn't. After cleaning much of it out and assembling his own team we won the league. I have no idea if he can emulate that but from previous,  he'll want a year to wheel and deal. I fully expect us to go backwards for a while before any consistent improvements become apparent. I have no idea how it will end but I believe TM is the type of character to insist it'll be done his way. Like it or not, patience will be required.

They way this team has been left there is no need for it to go backwards before going forwards and would represent a huge waste of time. The foundation of a solid, if unspectacular side are there. There is absolutely no need to rip up the one part of our team that was functioning as intended.

I agree. I just think it will happen.

In that case why is it "knee jerk" or "meltdown" to question a manager that does it? Surely midway through a season when we're in the PO race you play the cards you're dealt.

When you add this on top of quotes about making players fall in love with the game again, the way he played previously and his comments after the game on Saturday I don't think it is too ridiculous to be a little worried by it all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)