Wigan
#41
(06-06-2023, 08:42 AM)Fido Wrote:
(06-06-2023, 08:17 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 04:59 PM)Offside Wrote: American football has the draft system where the bottom club in the league gets first pick of the rookie players leaving college football.  The second bottom gets the next pick etc with the Superbowl winners getting the final pick.  There are several rounds of this which takes about three days to complete.

The plan is to improve the quality of the lower teams to give them a better chance of competing in the following year.  Around 13 different teams have won the Superbowl since 2003. 



Here we do the opposite.  We give the already rich clubs more money for finishing top and the money is scaled down by £2.2 million per position and all teams get about £84 million for TV rights.   Man City got £161.3 million last year and Norwich got £100.3 million for finishing last.  They will also have received parachute money since.

So the three teams coming down will get about £300 million for their failure, and be able to massively outspend the rest of the division, thus perpetuating the problem of less well off clubs getting promoted. Hats off to Luton ( and Coventry) for what they achieved.  

If the Premier League were interested in the sport and not the money, and wasn't such a bent organisation,  they'd look at ways of levelling out the chances of teams other than Liverpool, Man City, Man Utd, Arsenal and in time Newcastle, being able to compete. 

But they're not interested in the likes of us.  We are just cannon fodder for Sky laugh at.  In time they are going to kill the game.  

I'm sure we all have every confidence in the Financial Fair Play rules being administered in a transparent and even-handed fashion.

This only works for the American sports (basketball, baseball and hockey do the same) because of their incredibly robust and competitive college system. College football for example gets crowds up to 100k, pretty regularly for the bigger schools. March Madness (the college baskbetall playoffs) is the biggest sporting event in the country for the whole of March.

It also works because of the fixed number of teams in each league. 32 in the NFL, 30 in the NBA, so you're able to spread the talent evenly. How would you do this for football? Only Prem teams get picks? Or do you tier players and then each league gets a pick at all the players? It simply doesn't translate to this country.

Also in terms of revenue split, the Prem is one of the fairest leagues because everyone gets at least £100m TV money, or whatever the figure is now. The other leagues negotiate per team, and it skews the money even more. Also, I believe that if a relegated club gets promoted whilst still in the parachute payment period, then the remaining parachute money for them gets split across the rest of the teams in the football league. I may be wrong on that. But as unfair systems go, and it is unfair, it's not as bad as it could be.

If the Champions League went back to being a knockout competition that would kill a number of birds with one stone but there’s no hope of that, of course.

The champions league needs to go back to being a competition for champions, not anyone that doesn't actually get relegated.
Reply
#42
(06-06-2023, 09:27 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Unless football is made fairer at the top I would rather the top few clear off. No ne of us can compete with them and not because of the brilliance, but simply the money and how it is weighed in their favour.
But that won't Happen- instead it'll be the same old shit and pundits fawning over Haaland and De Bruyne as they demolish Luton next season, overlooking the fact that Haaland alone costs more than the value of Luton as a club.
It is akin to a Ferrari beating a Ford Focus and motor racing pundits overlooking the obvious whilst talking about the brilliance of the driver.

I agree with your point, not sure your analogy works though.

Takes a lot of skill to drive fast cars quickly and effectively, especially if you're talking about F1 cars. So of course the Ferrari would win the race because the Focus is comparatively shit, doesn't mean that the Ferrari driver isn't brilliant though.
Reply
#43
(06-06-2023, 09:36 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-06-2023, 09:27 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Unless football is made fairer at the top I would rather the top few clear off. No ne of us can compete with them and not because of the brilliance, but simply the money and how it is weighed in their favour.
But that won't Happen- instead it'll be the same old shit and pundits fawning over Haaland and De Bruyne as they demolish Luton next season, overlooking the fact that Haaland alone costs more than the value of Luton as a club.
It is akin to a Ferrari beating a Ford Focus and motor racing pundits overlooking the obvious whilst talking about the brilliance of the driver.

I agree with your point, not sure your analogy works though.

Takes a lot of skill to drive fast cars quickly and effectively, especially if you're talking about F1 cars. So of course the Ferrari would win the race because the Focus is comparatively shit, doesn't mean that the Ferrari driver isn't brilliant though.

Who do you think you are? Stirling Moss  Smile
Reply
#44
(06-06-2023, 10:07 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-06-2023, 09:36 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-06-2023, 09:27 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Unless football is made fairer at the top I would rather the top few clear off. No ne of us can compete with them and not because of the brilliance, but simply the money and how it is weighed in their favour.
But that won't Happen- instead it'll be the same old shit and pundits fawning over Haaland and De Bruyne as they demolish Luton next season, overlooking the fact that Haaland alone costs more than the value of Luton as a club.
It is akin to a Ferrari beating a Ford Focus and motor racing pundits overlooking the obvious whilst talking about the brilliance of the driver.

I agree with your point, not sure your analogy works though.

Takes a lot of skill to drive fast cars quickly and effectively, especially if you're talking about F1 cars. So of course the Ferrari would win the race because the Focus is comparatively shit, doesn't mean that the Ferrari driver isn't brilliant though.

Who do you think you are? Stirling Moss  Smile

James Hunt, actually
Reply
#45
(06-06-2023, 09:27 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Unless football is made fairer at the top I would rather the top few clear off. No ne of us can compete with them and not because of the brilliance, but simply the money and how it is weighed in their favour.
But that won't Happen- instead it'll be the same old shit and pundits fawning over Haaland and De Bruyne as they demolish Luton next season, overlooking the fact that Haaland alone costs more than the value of Luton as a club.
It is akin to a Ferrari beating a Ford Focus and motor racing pundits overlooking the obvious whilst talking about the brilliance of the driver.

Ford vs Ferrari is a great film. Even more-so given that the driver in the Ford car was a Brummie and Christian Bale puts on a decent Brummie accent.
Reply
#46
I'd have said Brighton are a decent sized club. Bigger than the likes of Wigan etc,. Obviously I'm wrong judging by the responses to my post!
Reply
#47
(06-06-2023, 10:16 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(06-06-2023, 09:27 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Unless football is made fairer at the top I would rather the top few clear off. No ne of us can compete with them and not because of the brilliance, but simply the money and how it is weighed in their favour.
But that won't Happen- instead it'll be the same old shit and pundits fawning over Haaland and De Bruyne as they demolish Luton next season, overlooking the fact that Haaland alone costs more than the value of Luton as a club.
It is akin to a Ferrari beating a Ford Focus and motor racing pundits overlooking the obvious whilst talking about the brilliance of the driver.

Ford vs Ferrari is a great film. Even more-so given that the driver in the Ford car was a Brummie and Christian Bale puts on a decent Brummie accent.

Le Mans 66 is a great fim. Ken Miles was from Sutton and quite a character.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)