Wigan
#21
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:44 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(06-04-2023, 10:47 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(06-04-2023, 07:03 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: And the 2 big scouse and Manc clubs both 20 miles away. Fair play to them though. FA Cup Winners and a few seasons In the Premier League. A few traditionally lower league clubs having their moment  in the sun (Hull, Bournemouth, Brighton, Reading...)

I don't think Brighton belong in that list?

Why not? Up until recently their only ever spell in the top flight was a couple of years in the mid 80s. Traditionally a lower league club.
I recall less than 20 years ago Brighton struggling to sell out the 7k capacity Withdean stadium.
Like Reading they are a one county club attracting Jonny come lately Liverpool, Arsenal etc fans to watch their local club. Reading were averaging 24k capacity in the Prem and were talking of increasing capacity at the Madjeski.

Correct.

Brighton have been a club continuously improving for 10-15 years now. They've built the AMEX, and gad several playoff and promotion charges throughout League One and Champ, and have then been steadily improving in the PL all whilst playing generally very good football (18 months ot Hughton's survival aside).

The minute their fortunes turn they'll go back to struggling to attract 10k fans every week.

People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).
Speaking for myself, of course I have a snobbery when it comes to a club like Brighton. I had a spell working near there when I was much younger and they couldn't buy a crowd. Anyone interested in football, and they were a meagre few, "supported" Man Utd or Spurs, while some fancied themselves as Pompey fans (but never went). Good luck to Luton, and anyone else managing to have a moment in the sun, but that is quite different to those south coast seaside clubs that really have no traditition or bedrock of supporters. Yes, I am jealous of their finances and do turn my nose up at their plastic johnny-come-lately fans, I don't know if that is a good or a bad thing or it is simply natural.
Reply
#22
(06-05-2023, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:44 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(06-04-2023, 10:47 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I don't think Brighton belong in that list?

Why not? Up until recently their only ever spell in the top flight was a couple of years in the mid 80s. Traditionally a lower league club.
I recall less than 20 years ago Brighton struggling to sell out the 7k capacity Withdean stadium.
Like Reading they are a one county club attracting Jonny come lately Liverpool, Arsenal etc fans to watch their local club. Reading were averaging 24k capacity in the Prem and were talking of increasing capacity at the Madjeski.

Correct.

Brighton have been a club continuously improving for 10-15 years now. They've built the AMEX, and gad several playoff and promotion charges throughout League One and Champ, and have then been steadily improving in the PL all whilst playing generally very good football (18 months ot Hughton's survival aside).

The minute their fortunes turn they'll go back to struggling to attract 10k fans every week.

People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).

I agree totally with this Duffers.

Simply big clubs can go through bad times and small clubs good times and that is the eco-system in football, which has always been the way.

It has worked splendidly and continues to until we get to the top 6 who seem encased in titanium.

Also what is a big club? Are Blackpool, Huddersfield and Preston seen as such anymore, when they once were? I doubt it.

Ipswich were a small club who did well at the start of the 60s and then won a European competition and the FA Cup and had countless forays into Europe. Are they now a small or a big club?

It all is very subjective.

This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.
Reply
#23
(06-05-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:44 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Why not? Up until recently their only ever spell in the top flight was a couple of years in the mid 80s. Traditionally a lower league club.
I recall less than 20 years ago Brighton struggling to sell out the 7k capacity Withdean stadium.
Like Reading they are a one county club attracting Jonny come lately Liverpool, Arsenal etc fans to watch their local club. Reading were averaging 24k capacity in the Prem and were talking of increasing capacity at the Madjeski.

Correct.

Brighton have been a club continuously improving for 10-15 years now. They've built the AMEX, and gad several playoff and promotion charges throughout League One and Champ, and have then been steadily improving in the PL all whilst playing generally very good football (18 months ot Hughton's survival aside).

The minute their fortunes turn they'll go back to struggling to attract 10k fans every week.

People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).

I agree totally with this Duffers.

Simply big clubs can go through bad times and small clubs good times and that is the eco-system in football, which has always been the way.

It has worked splendidly and continues to until we get to the top 6 who seem encased in titanium.

Also what is a big club? Are Blackpool, Huddersfield and Preston seen as such anymore, when they once were? I doubt it.

Ipswich were a small club who did well at the start of the 60s and then won a European competition and the FA Cup and had countless forays into Europe. Are they now a small or a big club?

It all is very subjective.

This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.

Saw a table the other day that had us about 11th in all time top flight appearances.
Reply
#24
(06-05-2023, 09:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Correct.

Brighton have been a club continuously improving for 10-15 years now. They've built the AMEX, and gad several playoff and promotion charges throughout League One and Champ, and have then been steadily improving in the PL all whilst playing generally very good football (18 months ot Hughton's survival aside).

The minute their fortunes turn they'll go back to struggling to attract 10k fans every week.

People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).

I agree totally with this Duffers.

Simply big clubs can go through bad times and small clubs good times and that is the eco-system in football, which has always been the way.

It has worked splendidly and continues to until we get to the top 6 who seem encased in titanium.

Also what is a big club? Are Blackpool, Huddersfield and Preston seen as such anymore, when they once were? I doubt it.

Ipswich were a small club who did well at the start of the 60s and then won a European competition and the FA Cup and had countless forays into Europe. Are they now a small or a big club?

It all is very subjective.

This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.

Saw a table the other day that had us about 11th in all time top flight appearances.

When you look at debates over big clubs etc we always seem to be in the top 20.

However, let's face it when it comes to now it's all about TV money etc and when you see our value v the likes of the big clubs then it puts into perspective what the modern game is about. It's a different set of parameters.

The way I see it is there's the giant clubs and then 5-6 others who have that 30,000 plus base like Villa, Leeds, Newcastle and after that 20 or so battling for the spots in the Prem. 

I remember having an argument at a student house party with a Sheff U fan in the 1990s about which of us is bigger. In the end it's almost pointless, because it's all about now. Currently a good player will choose Bournemouth or Luton over us- that says it all.
Reply
#25
(06-05-2023, 10:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote: People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).

I agree totally with this Duffers.

Simply big clubs can go through bad times and small clubs good times and that is the eco-system in football, which has always been the way.

It has worked splendidly and continues to until we get to the top 6 who seem encased in titanium.

Also what is a big club? Are Blackpool, Huddersfield and Preston seen as such anymore, when they once were? I doubt it.

Ipswich were a small club who did well at the start of the 60s and then won a European competition and the FA Cup and had countless forays into Europe. Are they now a small or a big club?

It all is very subjective.

This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.

Saw a table the other day that had us about 11th in all time top flight appearances.

When you look at debates over big clubs etc we always seem to be in the top 20.

However, let's face it when it comes to now it's all about TV money etc and when you see our value v the likes of the big clubs then it puts into perspective what the modern game is about. It's a different set of parameters.

The way I see it is there's the giant clubs and then 5-6 others who have that 30,000 plus base like Villa, Leeds, Newcastle and after that 20 or so battling for the spots in the Prem. 

I remember having an argument at a student house party with a Sheff U fan in the 1990s about which of us is bigger. In the end it's almost pointless, because it's all about now. Currently a good player will choose Bournemouth or Luton over us- that says it all.

I've said numerous times that "history" counts for very little these days. We haven't been a serious contender in this country for well over 40 years now, and even then we didn't actually win anything. It's a great thing for those who were around at the time to see it to reminisce about, but in the grand scheme of things it counts for very little these days.

There is a group of about 20 or so teams scattered between the Prem and Champ who are broadly interchangeable. Teams like us, Norwich, Watford, Sheff Utd, etc, we're all the same.
Reply
#26
(06-05-2023, 10:31 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:54 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I agree totally with this Duffers.

Simply big clubs can go through bad times and small clubs good times and that is the eco-system in football, which has always been the way.

It has worked splendidly and continues to until we get to the top 6 who seem encased in titanium.

Also what is a big club? Are Blackpool, Huddersfield and Preston seen as such anymore, when they once were? I doubt it.

Ipswich were a small club who did well at the start of the 60s and then won a European competition and the FA Cup and had countless forays into Europe. Are they now a small or a big club?

It all is very subjective.

This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.

Saw a table the other day that had us about 11th in all time top flight appearances.

When you look at debates over big clubs etc we always seem to be in the top 20.

However, let's face it when it comes to now it's all about TV money etc and when you see our value v the likes of the big clubs then it puts into perspective what the modern game is about. It's a different set of parameters.

The way I see it is there's the giant clubs and then 5-6 others who have that 30,000 plus base like Villa, Leeds, Newcastle and after that 20 or so battling for the spots in the Prem. 

I remember having an argument at a student house party with a Sheff U fan in the 1990s about which of us is bigger. In the end it's almost pointless, because it's all about now. Currently a good player will choose Bournemouth or Luton over us- that says it all.

I've said numerous times that "history" counts for very little these days. We haven't been a serious contender in this country for well over 40 years now, and even then we didn't actually win anything. It's a great thing for those who were around at the time to see it to reminisce about, but in the grand scheme of things it counts for very little these days.

There is a group of about 20 or so teams scattered between the Prem and Champ who are broadly interchangeable. Teams like us, Norwich, Watford, Sheff Utd, etc, we're all the same.

Exactly- we are all between 12-35th in the food chain.

Clubs punching below their weight occasionally happens like Sunderland, Sheff W, Portsmouth in league 1. I doubt many are saying now West Bromwich are too big to be in the Championship, whilst some will say that about Leeds.
Reply
#27
(06-05-2023, 12:06 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:31 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 10:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:52 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 09:41 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: This is a very good debate to have, and one without an answer really.

What is a "big club"? What defines it? It's all relative. If we ended up in League One for example, we're a massive club for League One. But in the Prem? These days we're just another team, but historically, I think we're top 10/15 in terms of points in the top flight.

Saw a table the other day that had us about 11th in all time top flight appearances.

When you look at debates over big clubs etc we always seem to be in the top 20.

However, let's face it when it comes to now it's all about TV money etc and when you see our value v the likes of the big clubs then it puts into perspective what the modern game is about. It's a different set of parameters.

The way I see it is there's the giant clubs and then 5-6 others who have that 30,000 plus base like Villa, Leeds, Newcastle and after that 20 or so battling for the spots in the Prem. 

I remember having an argument at a student house party with a Sheff U fan in the 1990s about which of us is bigger. In the end it's almost pointless, because it's all about now. Currently a good player will choose Bournemouth or Luton over us- that says it all.

I've said numerous times that "history" counts for very little these days. We haven't been a serious contender in this country for well over 40 years now, and even then we didn't actually win anything. It's a great thing for those who were around at the time to see it to reminisce about, but in the grand scheme of things it counts for very little these days.

There is a group of about 20 or so teams scattered between the Prem and Champ who are broadly interchangeable. Teams like us, Norwich, Watford, Sheff Utd, etc, we're all the same.

Exactly- we are all between 12-35th in the food chain.

Clubs punching below their weight occasionally happens like Sunderland, Sheff W, Portsmouth in league 1. I doubt many are saying now West Bromwich are too big to be in the Championship, whilst some will say that about Leeds.

Even Leeds aren't that big anymore.

Most people under 30 probably know them best for having a big ground and imploding financially.
Reply
#28
(06-05-2023, 08:36 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 08:20 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:51 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2023, 07:44 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(06-04-2023, 10:47 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I don't think Brighton belong in that list?

Why not? Up until recently their only ever spell in the top flight was a couple of years in the mid 80s. Traditionally a lower league club.
I recall less than 20 years ago Brighton struggling to sell out the 7k capacity Withdean stadium.
Like Reading they are a one county club attracting Jonny come lately Liverpool, Arsenal etc fans to watch their local club. Reading were averaging 24k capacity in the Prem and were talking of increasing capacity at the Madjeski.

Correct.

Brighton have been a club continuously improving for 10-15 years now. They've built the AMEX, and gad several playoff and promotion charges throughout League One and Champ, and have then been steadily improving in the PL all whilst playing generally very good football (18 months ot Hughton's survival aside).

The minute their fortunes turn they'll go back to struggling to attract 10k fans every week.

People on here don't seem to like it when smaller clubs come up and do well. There's a prevailing snobbery that says only the old guard should be in the top flight and doing well (including us, despite us doing nothing of note since Star Wars first came out).

I think it's more we don't see the"fairytale" when an owner has single handedly bankrolled the club through the divisions.

They are effectively, Newcastle. But because they are trendy at the moment. People overlook the 600m or what ever they have spent. 

Luton, if they stay up and crack on will no doubt have universal praise.

Exactly this, I have absolutely no issue with smaller clubs coming from nowhere and upsetting the odds, indeed I think the Luton story is fantastic and I hope they continue their journey, however I have zero time for clubs that have bought their success. Most of my current disinterest with football surrounds the fact it’s a competition now for who has the richest owner and that’s it.
Reply
#29
Considering the length of time since we actually won a trophy of note, our support is excellent.
Reply
#30
American football has the draft system where the bottom club in the league gets first pick of the rookie players leaving college football.  The second bottom gets the next pick etc with the Superbowl winners getting the final pick.  There are several rounds of this which takes about three days to complete.

The plan is to improve the quality of the lower teams to give them a better chance of competing in the following year.  Around 13 different teams have won the Superbowl since 2003. 


Here we do the opposite.  We give the already rich clubs more money for finishing top and the money is scaled down by £2.2 million per position and all teams get about £84 million for TV rights.   Man City got £161.3 million last year and Norwich got £100.3 million for finishing last.  They will also have received parachute money since.

So the three teams coming down will get about £300 million for their failure, and be able to massively outspend the rest of the division, thus perpetuating the problem of less well off clubs getting promoted. Hats off to Luton ( and Coventry) for what they achieved.  

If the Premier League were interested in the sport and not the money, and wasn't such a bent organisation,  they'd look at ways of levelling out the chances of teams other than Liverpool, Man City, Man Utd, Arsenal and in time Newcastle, being able to compete. 

But they're not interested in the likes of us.  We are just cannon fodder for Sky laugh at.  In time they are going to kill the game.  

I'm sure we all have every confidence in the Financial Fair Play rules being administered in a transparent and even-handed fashion.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: