The admit who you got wrong with managers thread
#31
I got it badly wrong about Bruce, I thought it was likely to be a poor appointment, as it happened it turned out to be an absolute fucking disaster.
Reply
#32
(10-22-2022, 09:15 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:29 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-21-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).

I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)

You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).

My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.

A lot of it also comes down to whether you view a manager as being successful or not.

I think both Mowbray, Bilic and Val were successes and I guess you don’t.

Val wasn’t a success, he achieved diddly squat. 
Bilic a kind of success but his teams are far too easy to play against for any prolonged success and left any manager replacing him with an impossible task of staying up. 
Mowbray, best resources in league, promoted as expected and relegated as expected and did the almost impossible and made football pretentious

He kept a weaker squad than we currently have now in the top 6…  
Like I said, you have a very different view on success as and when it suits.

He didn’t achieve anything with us. You can’t cling to the argument we were fifth, he was sacked due to poor form and results so who knows where we would have finished.
Reply
#33
Val was a success? On what planet and by which metrics?? Seen it all now.
If he was a success then Big Dave was a managerial legend, by virtue of getting sacked due to bad form, but was higher than Val.
Reply
#34
(10-22-2022, 10:22 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: I got it badly wrong about Bruce, I thought it was likely to be a poor appointment, as it happened it turned out to be an absolute fucking disaster.

Yes. Same with Pardew too.

With Bilic, I knew it would fizzle out, but I didn't predict the good times along the way.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: