Least Worst
#11
Yup.

It's an absolute nonsense to suggest we can't compete with those global population powerhouses like Slovakia, the Czech Republic, Denmark and the Netherlands in having high tech manufacturing.
Reply
#12
(10-03-2022, 11:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote: In its formative days our new government did several splendid things; binning IR35 changes, cancelling the counter-intuitive ban on bankers bonuses and the pledge to cap energy costs this October. As a "mini-budget" that would have been fine. We'd still have been paying more tax than at any other point in peacetime, but such policies would indicate a government that had an idea about the kinds of supply side policies that would aid incentives and growth, as well as supporting those in genuine need.

The less good aspects were the lack of targeting of the support for energy bills, the cancellation of tax increases given the lack of a clear plan on where funding will come from (borrowing), and an entirely tin-eared ideological cut of the 45p rate (the policy is ultimately right, but the timing, optics and additional borrowing are appalling).

I then read over the weekend that we are in for spending curbs to help fund the deficit. Again, the optics of this in the current climate are truly incredible. I have spent most of my adult life campaigning for incentives for enterprise, tax cuts and a smaller state - but not when the economy is in such uncertain times, we have a war in Europe and energy prices have brought millions to subsistence living.

All this without any consistency with the Bank of England (who've spent a decade making their own mistakes) and any oversight from the institutions actually created by the Tories to keep government honest (sic). 

Then I listen to Kwarteng u-turning this morning. He was skewered by Nick Robinson. There is a vacuous pound shop Thatcher ideology that's completely ignores the Thatcherite bedrocks of supply side reform, sound money and fiscal discipline. 

I hoped, really hoped for all of our sakes that I was going to be wrong about Liz Truss. She has surrounded herself with a like-minded cadre, there's no Cabinet challenge by wets as there was by Prior, Walker or Heseltine to act as a brake.  U turn or no u turn I only see things getting worse for the next 18 months. With the feeble initial support if just 50 MPs in the first round Truss was already carrying Dike's hamstring injury. The fallout from the greatest exercise in borrowing in 50 years has essentially shot off both her kneecaps.

I can't see anything other than a government devoid of either electoral mandate or support from its own Parliamentary Party, corroding from within hobbling along with reactionary and probably counter productive measures through a borrowing crisis, inflationary crisis and cost of living crisis. Oh and war on our doorstep.

It makes you wonder what's #LeastWorst after all, eh?

Genuinely interested - what would you consider the appropriate outcome to the uprating of welfare in line with inflation? Cost around 5.5bn, 10bn less than the cost of the cut to corporation tax or similarly the NI reversal. Strikes me as another big hot potato lurking in the offing.
Reply
#13
(10-03-2022, 05:49 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuinely interested - what would you consider the appropriate outcome to the uprating of welfare in line with inflation? Cost around 5.5bn, 10bn less than the cost of the cut to corporation tax or similarly the NI reversal. Strikes me as another big hot potato lurking in the offing.

Welfare should be uprated in line with inflation, however part time workers ought to be incentivised to take on more hours.

(10-03-2022, 04:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The region had a trade surplus with China before Covid, how do you square that with not being able to compete?

I also suggest you look at the destination of patents and licensed tech at Warwick and UoB, think you'll find that it's overwhelmingly benefiting manufacturing in the region.

We are not a city state, city states do not cover 243,610 square kilometres. To think otherwise is ludicrous. I know you have an aversion to things outside your worldview but get real.

All you will achieve is a massive brain drain away from the UK as very capable talent will not have job opportunities to progress which will fuck up the development of this country.

Then the conceit is that you need an "Export Led Industrial Strategy". If the region is successful then why on Earth does it need the state to come in and fuck it up?
Reply
#14
(10-03-2022, 05:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote:

Then the conceit is that you need an "Export Led Industrial Strategy". If the region is successful then why on Earth does it need the state to come in and fuck it up?

You need to continually invest in regional infrastructure, training for skills and technology. You can't stand still, that's how Slovakia and the Czech Republic have moved forward with their manufacturing. The Midlands has a dearth of investment, per head the East Mids is the worst funded region and the West Midlands is below average, it has coasted on internal development and external (mainly Chinese, which is now cut off for obvious reasons) investment recently but it can't rely on that. That's how London got out of it's cycle of decline and progressed over the last 40 years.

I'll give you an example, if the government had released funds for a proper MRT metro in the West Midlands county and it ended up costing double what it was forecast then it would still have been a quarter the projected cost of Crossrail at the time. Couldn't get it funded and now we have trams (which are only operating as MRT between Handsworth and Wolverhampton and won't ever be able to operate as MRT in central Birmingham because there's no space except underground which the government doesn't want to fund development of), how much economic benefit would you unlock being able to get from suburban Coventry into central Birmingham on an MRT system like the tube, Merseyrail or Tyne and Wear metro?

12 years ago I could have told you the West Midlands needed central government support for developing Li-Ion cells in the region and exploit both the large automotive manufacturing base, promote an incentive to continue research and invest in research in that area and the stimulate great regional development for a disruptive and emerging technology that anyone and their moms could figure out was going to progress but the Treasury never bothered, we didn't and now we're massively behind not just South Korea, Japan, China, the US and Germany but also Spain and France and look to be slipping behind Slovakia. And when the Treasury did bother it gave the money to a convicted fraudster and now that business looks dead in the water. There is zero joined up manufacturing strategy in Westminster which is unable to see beyond Zone 2 London. The regions successes are in spite of government not because of it. Focusing more on London doesn't address this, it exasperates the brain drain issue (I can get paid more for what I do by moving to most other countries in Western Europe, nevermind the US, Canada and Australia) and the regional infrastructure inequalities which are contributing to inequality. Can't even build HS2 properly to open up rail freight capacity from Grimsby and Immingham going towards Southampton (pertinent due to well known road freight issues).
Reply
#15
(10-03-2022, 05:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-03-2022, 05:49 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Genuinely interested - what would you consider the appropriate outcome to the uprating of welfare in line with inflation? Cost around 5.5bn, 10bn less than the cost of the cut to corporation tax or similarly the NI reversal. Strikes me as another big hot potato lurking in the offing.

Welfare should be uprated in line with inflation, however part time workers ought to be incentivised to take on more hours.





(10-03-2022, 04:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The region had a trade surplus with China before Covid, how do you square that with not being able to compete?

I also suggest you look at the destination of patents and licensed tech at Warwick and UoB, think you'll find that it's overwhelmingly benefiting manufacturing in the region.

We are not a city state, city states do not cover 243,610 square kilometres. To think otherwise is ludicrous. I know you have an aversion to things outside your worldview but get real.

All you will achieve is a massive brain drain away from the UK as very capable talent will not have job opportunities to progress which will fuck up the development of this country.

Then the conceit is that you need an "Export Led Industrial Strategy". If the region is successful then why on Earth does it need the state to come in and fuck it up?

Fair enough, although I believe that is already happening twice over from 9 to 12 to 15 in the coming 4 months
Reply
#16
(10-03-2022, 05:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Welfare should be uprated in line with inflation, however part time workers ought to be incentivised to take on more hours.


Tax credits, for all the imperfections of the system, do that. Cliff-edge benefits don't.

Tax credits cost more than they needed to, not because of any inherent deficiency in the concept but because of timidity over setting the level of minimum wage.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: