Least Worst
#1
In its formative days our new government did several splendid things; binning IR35 changes, cancelling the counter-intuitive ban on bankers bonuses and the pledge to cap energy costs this October. As a "mini-budget" that would have been fine. We'd still have been paying more tax than at any other point in peacetime, but such policies would indicate a government that had an idea about the kinds of supply side policies that would aid incentives and growth, as well as supporting those in genuine need.

The less good aspects were the lack of targeting of the support for energy bills, the cancellation of tax increases given the lack of a clear plan on where funding will come from (borrowing), and an entirely tin-eared ideological cut of the 45p rate (the policy is ultimately right, but the timing, optics and additional borrowing are appalling).

I then read over the weekend that we are in for spending curbs to help fund the deficit. Again, the optics of this in the current climate are truly incredible. I have spent most of my adult life campaigning for incentives for enterprise, tax cuts and a smaller state - but not when the economy is in such uncertain times, we have a war in Europe and energy prices have brought millions to subsistence living.

All this without any consistency with the Bank of England (who've spent a decade making their own mistakes) and any oversight from the institutions actually created by the Tories to keep government honest (sic). 

Then I listen to Kwarteng u-turning this morning. He was skewered by Nick Robinson. There is a vacuous pound shop Thatcher ideology that's completely ignores the Thatcherite bedrocks of supply side reform, sound money and fiscal discipline. 

I hoped, really hoped for all of our sakes that I was going to be wrong about Liz Truss. She has surrounded herself with a like-minded cadre, there's no Cabinet challenge by wets as there was by Prior, Walker or Heseltine to act as a brake.  U turn or no u turn I only see things getting worse for the next 18 months. With the feeble initial support if just 50 MPs in the first round Truss was already carrying Dike's hamstring injury. The fallout from the greatest exercise in borrowing in 50 years has essentially shot off both her kneecaps.

I can't see anything other than a government devoid of either electoral mandate or support from its own Parliamentary Party, corroding from within hobbling along with reactionary and probably counter productive measures through a borrowing crisis, inflationary crisis and cost of living crisis. Oh and war on our doorstep.

It makes you wonder what's #LeastWorst after all, eh?
Reply
#2
Nicely written but it’s been twelve years of absolute oss shit from this government.
Reply
#3
(10-03-2022, 02:41 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Nicely written but it’s been twelve years of absolute oss shit from this government.

Yep, would be a lot easier to take if Proth and his cronies hadn't of put us in this position.
Reply
#4
(10-03-2022, 02:52 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Yep, would be a lot easier to take if Proth and his cronies hadn't of put us in this position.

The electorate put all of us in this position.
Reply
#5
Sad that you have wasted a lifetime campaigning for "incentives for enterprise, tax cuts and a smaller state" when typically those things don't work. Businesses invest based on expectations of future profits. Usually that is highly correlated with a stable economy, sound money, strong public investment in health and education, open trade (typically with your biggest trading partner), an export led industrial policy, credible macroeconomic policy and strong regulation that protects workers rights and stops banks from taking excessive risks. Do all of that and you get a good government. For the last 12 years, we have had virtually none of the above, principally because of austerity. And don't come back to me with the public sector is bigger than ever before blah, blah blah. That is the case because growth has been hammered. On a per-capita basis, the state is much smaller and there is now virtually nothing left to cut - unless you want to privatize health and education.
Reply
#6
Always happy to read your opinion. Couldn't agree with you more about a stable economy and sound money. Neither are created by a culture of debt-funded spending, ever increasing untargeted bailouts to individuals or debt-funded tax cuts. I don't agree that a post-industrial state needs an export led industrial policy, instead we should admit the primacy of the City and our Science & Technology hubs and concentrate on releasing their huge potential.

You're right that growth has been hammered. Faux-austerity played a part, as has the continued existence of thousands of zombie companies - creative destruction has been on holiday for a couple of decades I'm sure you'll agree. Instead we've had a cheap debt fueled asset price spiral.

Of course successive crises mean that this is all unravelling now and the policy response is lamentable as always.
Reply
#7
(10-03-2022, 04:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I don't agree that a post-industrial state needs an export led industrial policy, instead we should admit the primacy of the City and our Science & Technology hubs and concentrate on releasing their huge potential.

What do you think the role of the technology development in the Midlands is, exactly?

London was perfectly fine building it's service industry to compete with New York in 2005 while the Midlands was outputting world-leading development tech for regional industry, why exactly can't we do that again? The UK isn't a city state.
Reply
#8
(10-03-2022, 04:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What do you think the role of the technology development in the Midlands is, exactly?

Developing then Licencing technology largely. We cannot compete in manufacturing and haven't the labour even if we wanted to.

We are are largely a City-state too and it's high time we admitted it and embraced it. I'm at a loss why we treat the global success of financial and professional services as some sort of guilty secret.
Reply
#9
The region had a trade surplus with China before Covid, how do you square that with not being able to compete?

I also suggest you look at the destination of patents and licensed tech at Warwick and UoB, think you'll find that it's overwhelmingly benefiting manufacturing in the region.

We are not a city state, city states do not cover 243,610 square kilometres. To think otherwise is ludicrous. I know you have an aversion to things outside your worldview but get real.

All you will achieve is a massive brain drain away from the UK as very capable talent will not have job opportunities to progress which will fuck up the development of this country.
Reply
#10
(10-03-2022, 04:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The region had a trade surplus with China before Covid, how do you square that with not being able to compete?

I also suggest you look at the destination of patents and licensed tech at Warwick and UoB, think you'll find that it's overwhelmingly benefiting manufacturing in the region.

We are not a city state, city states do not cover 243,610 square kilometres. To think otherwise is ludicrous. I know you have an aversion to things outside your worldview but get real.

All you will achieve is a massive brain drain away from the UK as very capable talent will not have job opportunities to progress which will fuck up the development of this country.

They don't have populations heading for 70 million either.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: