Ian Pearce
#51
(03-08-2022, 07:18 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 06:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 04:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-08-2022, 03:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think you are forgetting how we got to where we are now. Our lauded system fell to pieces as soon as Ashworth left. We tried to do it on the cheap with Garlick, then Burton, then expensively with the bloke from Blackburn whose name escapes me (Williams?)  Have all the scaleable plans and structures you want but ultimately it will come down to whether we have the right people in place. Over the last decade getting rid of those failing in those roles has cost us a lot of money and seen a lot of upheaval. Every bit as much as losing managers. 

Shall we list some of the dross bought by committee, Gamboa, Samaras, Davidson, Blanco, Poco etc Ot who can forget the ‘we want a coach not a manager’ situation where it led to Terry Burton bringing in Irvine who ticked every box under the system at the time.

I think you're more intent on arguing a strawman than engaging with the premise to be honest. The players you highlighted were signed well after our recruitment setup went to piss and hadn't been kept up to date since Dashworth left, in other words were 3 years out of date. How are they an example? It isn't about players being "bought by committee", or the remit of the head coach, having a technical structure is there to support the manager. We weren't buying by committee under Ashworth, we weren't operating out of a spreadsheet. We were using data-analysis and scouting to generate reports and then clearing them with the manager on top of establishing an academy structure to develop players that had started to be integrated by the time Ashworth left. It worked under Mowbray, Di Matteo, Hodgson and Clarke and wasn't disrupted when each manager left.

Do you know how we signed McAuley, for example? Wyscout and data driven analysis identified a potential player to sign, he was then scouted including when Ashworth and Hodgson went to watch him in person and Hodgson cleared the transfer. There was a complete disconnect from this after Ashworth left. Reports weren't being updated, scouts were being sidelined and manager input was being disregarded. They weren't operating in the same structure.

So ultimately the system didn’t work without having Ashworth in place to lead it. No problem with having a system incorporating scouting, data, young hungry head coaches but they fall to pieces like anything else when those in place aren’t good enough. It’ll always be the quality of people first.

Also the entire structure was set-up and financed thanks to TV money and we have a very finite amount left and it will require investment from the club over a sustained period of time. Let’s see how much they are willing to put in to see a return - promotion.

How come clubs throughout the football pyramid manage it fine Derek?

Of course you need the right people, as with all jobs, same if you hand all power to the manager...

I never get your view on this, never.

I have never argued that to have success you can only go down the manager in complete control route. However I never argued that the alternative was the only way either. My cynicism is based on experience  of seeing our system failing over a sustained period to the point it was rescued by Pulis. I’m not adverse to us going down the route of a DoF, a properly functioning scouting set-up, data analysis etc, why would I be? What I am questioning is our ability to get it right. We have not arguably got anything right on the pitch since the second Pulis season and before that Clarke’s first season.

There was no accountability when things started to go wrong after Ashworth. Head Coaches got the blame, the system remained the same. Unless each cog in the machine works well then it fails and the more complicated it gets the more difficult it is to address 

I hope that this will be the start of the clubs owners wanting to invest long term or long enough to get us promoted, but I’m not convinced any long term project which see’s us stay in this division is going to yield anything good abs as a club we only have Megson’s first season as proof we are capable of promotion without the TV money.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)