Neil staying at Preston
#41
(04-14-2019, 12:57 PM)Albionmad Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 12:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 12:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: That's made my weekend.
Never wanted him from the start.

More importantly what happens now?

Shan's done pretty well apart from Millwall and the disastrous first half v Bristol. 

Do we stick with him or get a more experienced man in?

I’m not sure anyone could have done much more than Shan has so far really.

4 wins from 6 on the back of some dodgy form, and missing a lot of key players.

Millwall was horrendous, but had JRod scored that pen we’d have got something, and the Bristol game we were down to the bare bones, and despite gifting them 3 goals he made changes that should have seen us get a point.

For me a manager needs to get the best out of a group of players, and proactively impact matches when Plan A isn’t working and he’s shown himself capable of doing this.

I’d like to see us bring someone with a bit of experience to act as a sounding board, but the decision ultimately needs to be Shan’s.
Agree with all you've posted.

However the prospect of us going into a double header vs The Vile with a rookie manager is the stuff of nightmares

The above could easily be countered.

We were awful against Swansea, routine against Brentford, lucky against Blues, awful against Millwall and clueless against Bristol to be 3 down in 20 mins with players defying instruction to not pass it around the back. I could also argue nothing was happening in the game yesterday until a wonder pass changed the course of it. Peston were the worst side we've faced this season.

Going into the play offs with the players basically running the show is nothing short of unfair on Shan. He can't be expected to go from a youth setup to suddenly play bad cop when we need those extra effort levels from experienced players.

The best business decision is to employ a new manager who can install belief and a game plan for the 3 vital playoff games. Reward Shan for his efforts with an assistant coach position alongside someone who isn't friends with the players. The guy is clearly no mug, he's just in an awkward position and has done brilliantly to steady the ship.

(04-14-2019, 09:36 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 06:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Just maybe....all the talk came from Neil's side just based on a few rumours and a passing interest.  He ends up looking good, ££££'s better off, he'll have other offers next season and doesn't have to face the play offs or The Prem. He wins hands down.  TBF, I think Neil was as good a shout as any in this league, but... we're 3 games from a much bigger League and we will certainly be a bigger draw for any potential managers.
At this stage in the clusterfuck, maybe the club should just offer Shan all the assistance he needs to finish the season.

+1

I'm honestly not sure a long term choice should be made now. Shan has their respect and we are organised. The players know what they need to do so we have to hope this crazy season ends well.

Only when we know what division we are in should we make the choice. Decision wise we will be in a much better market in the summer irrespective of what division we are in.

But without fail we need to move quick as lightening once our fate is sealed (pardon the pun) to appoint the new guy so I fully expect the candidate to be primed ready.

There's a difference between liking and respecting someone. I'd imagine it will be more a discussion amongst senior players in the dressing room, not Shan giving direct orders.

The Millwall and Bristol showings proved this. When the going gets tough, they threw in the towel. It's unfair on Shan to be asked to play bad cop. The dynamic doesn't work long term.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)