WBAUnofficial
Burnham - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Burnham (/showthread.php?tid=38826)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Burnham - baggy1 - 09-26-2025

(09-26-2025, 11:55 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I've said before we have a simple choice as a country. High spend and high tax like Scandinavia, or low spend and low tax and get low-level of public services/benefits.

People seem to want all the public services and benefits without paying for them. Labour should have put this simple choice before the voters in their manifesto. Instead they have put themselves in an escape room of their own making.

And I don't believe the grown ups who say Labour wouldnt have been an elected without declaring a 5 year lock in on tax increases. That's for the birds.

Agree on that MICS. We’ll never know about the voting if they’d have said they’re raising taxes because the tsunami of press propaganda, IMO, would have been relentless and swayed a lot.

This budget is the time to raise IT and even possibly reverse some of the Employers NI increases. Labour have still got time to turn things around despite Dekka’s daily polls of how far they are behind, but they need to do the nasty bits now and raise the taxes and take the hit.


RE: Burnham - man in the corner shop - 09-26-2025

I always want a Labour govt B1 as opposed to the hideous Tory and now reform alternatives. But not for the sake of it. 15 months in now and we need to go full throttle in changing people's lives for the better. For me, it's mainly a huge national house building programme that will do that but it isn't going well.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cgmzwk4yd1eo

I do not disagree with what you say on NI and IT.

And this below has to turned around

The ONS data showed that for the year ending in March 2024, 35.8 million people lived in households receiving more in benefits than they paid in tax – a record outside the pandemic when the figure rose to 36.5 million.

It represents 53.3 per cent of the population, up sharply from 52.6 per cent the year before.

https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/markets/article-15132747/Record-number-live-households-benefits-pay-tax.html


RE: Burnham - baggy1 - 09-26-2025

I always felt is was naive putting a house building target that included year 1 figures as the changes required would take time to bed in, but that is done and there has to be some movement soon otherwise that is a real failed headline policy.

And the benefits issue is massive - fuck knows what can be done about that as has been shown with the attempts so far. Part of that is down to an ageing population and it's a shame they didn't break that down to pensioners and non-pensioners to give a bit more insight. But to have a country where you can earn £40k and get more in benefit than you pay in tax is just wrong (although I will caveat with it would be interesting to get some detail behind that)


RE: Burnham - Protheroe - 09-26-2025

(09-26-2025, 12:25 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The ONS data showed that for the year ending in March 2024, 35.8 million people lived in households receiving more in benefits than they paid in tax – a record outside the pandemic when the figure rose to 36.5 million.

It represents 53.3 per cent of the population, up sharply from 52.6 per cent the year before.

Benefits are uprated every year and every year the dependency ratio gets worse as more people retire or go on long term sick.

The tax base is far too narrow to generate the benefits to which people believe they're entitled. At current rates the state pension would require savings of nearly £250,000 - how many people have contributed anything like that in NI even allowing for compounding over a working lifetime? The average DC pension pot at 65 is in comparison just £145,000. The most egregious drain will be from the those public sector pensions which are entirely unfunded (£1.42 trillion in liabilities).

As the IFS reports today Labour has also committed to increasing defence spending by £36.5bn on top of the £20-40bn black hole it already has in its finances. 

So when Dekka posts "No one is arguing for more and more spending unchecked" yet rejects any notion of cuts or fundamental reform of the public sector (including pensions), then unchecked spending is EXACTLY what he's asking for.

The ONLY way to get the country back on its feet is via growth and massive increases in productivity (particularly public sector productivity). Yet in every way the Labour government has adopted anti-growth measures - fiscal policy, energy prices, workers rights, public sector pay unlinked to productivity increases etc.

And all the mood music now is about taxes on wealth and unearned income which will achieve nothing but to set growth back even further.

In the absence of any sentient response the bond market crisis will eventually hit us, and decisions will be forced on the government and the public whether they voted for them or not. I can guarantee you (Dekka) that at that point the greatest losers will be the poorest. 

You really need to read Burnham's idiotic comment about the bond market in this context. The guy is fucking idiot.

(09-26-2025, 10:28 AM)baggy1 Wrote: This argument perfectly sums up why we're fucked - one side doesn't recognise the damage done by the past policies and feels we should push on further with them, and the other side doesn't recognise that we're fucked and can't pursue the policies that should have been implemented 15 years ago but still advocates for doing them. You're both having a bald man and comb argument that was started 15 years ago and you can't let go.

To be fair B1, the past is a foreign country. What's done is done, and matters less.

I'm not suggesting "pushing on" further with anything, because nothing necessary has even been attempted in the last 35 years.


RE: Burnham - baggy1 - 09-26-2025

Austerity was attempted, Brexit was attempted, Truss attempted, Patel is a temptress (according to a small minority)


RE: Burnham - Protheroe - 09-26-2025

(09-26-2025, 01:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Austerity was attempted, Brexit was attempted, Truss attempted, Patel is a temptress (according to a small minority)

We have never attempted to restructure the public sector so that it serves the public rather than itself, we have never attempted to simplify and broaden the tax base, we have never had serious conversations about the sustainability of state pension, public sector pensions and social care policy, we have never had a serious discussion about the morality and affordability of condemning millions to long term subsistence on benefits, we haven't built enough houses for 50 years, we haven't had a serious conversation about the benefits of managed mass migration or dealt with the scourge of illegal immigration.

I also know why we haven't done this. It's because we haven't had politicians capable of speaking hard truths for decades.

As I say, eventually we will be forced into necessary change whether we like it or not.


RE: Burnham - Derek Hardballs - 09-26-2025

(09-26-2025, 12:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I always felt is was naive putting a house building target that included year 1 figures as the changes required would take time to bed in, but that is done and there has to be some movement soon otherwise that is a real failed headline policy.

And the benefits issue is massive - fuck knows what can be done about that as has been shown with the attempts so far. Part of that is down to an ageing population and it's a shame they didn't break that down to pensioners and non-pensioners to give a bit more insight. But to have a country where you can earn £40k and get more in benefit than you pay in tax is just wrong (although I will caveat with it would be interesting to get some detail behind that)

You can earn £40k and earn more in benefit? Really? Where is the evidence for this?

Oh and I haven’t said anything about where Labour are in the polls for weeks… you’re getting confused again Wink


RE: Burnham - tHEgLASSdOORS - 09-26-2025

If someone earns 40k and receives pip and child benefit their benefits will outstrip the income tax they pay, as an example. There are others.


RE: Burnham - Protheroe - 09-26-2025

(09-26-2025, 03:56 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You can earn £40k and earn more in benefit? Really? Where is the evidence for this?

You do appreciate that this type of dependency was by design don't you? Gordon Brown has a great deal to answer for.

(09-26-2025, 10:34 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Increasingly I think you have a point here, or at least an opinion  that needs to be explored.

Certainly Govts have been increasingly addicted to more and more spending, achieving less and less. Even Govts who publicly stated that they were in favour of less Govt spending, have increased it.

I doubt I would agree with Proth on why this has happened, who benefits and what needs to be done next.

But he is right to raise this as an issue.

Thanks Shabbs. Those who've benefitted the most were those who already had the most, I doubt you'd disagree.


RE: Burnham - man in the corner shop - 09-26-2025

No one can deny that the rich get richer
As sure as the sun sets and the moon rises