| Welcome, Guest |
You have to register before you can post on our site.
|
| Online Users |
There are currently 2847 online users. » 2 Member(s) | 2841 Guest(s) Applebot, Bing, Facebook, Google, Dial M for Mick, mixed_xkpt
|
|
|
| NTT20 article on our "Managerial Churn" |
|
Posted by: Squid - 02-25-2026, 03:38 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (32)
|
 |
Not behind a paywall, so I'll post in full. It's overly kind to Mason, but worth reading:
https://www.ntt20.com/p/how-eric-ramsay-...popup=true
“It’s undeniable that the squad is capable of more than where it is at the moment.”
Those were the words of Eric Ramsay in his first interview as West Bromwich Albion manager. Were they true then? Are they true now?
With West Brom looking for a new manager, one name is not doing the rounds: Ryan Mason. There are logical reasons for that, of course. Who rehires a manager they just sacked? (OK, Sheffield United, but who else?) It doesn’t happen. And maybe the sacking shouldn’t have happened in the first place. At the very least, the club might furnish Baggies fans with some indication as to why they deemed Mason more unsuited to the job than, say, Eric Ramsay.
You cannot claim unfair dismissal when your higher-ups sack you for a subjective judgement on your performance. But if you could, would Mason be in with a shout? Plenty of West Brom fans would say no. A fair few might say yes. Either way, Mason’s successor demonstrated a Nostradamic aptitude for predicting a double downfall.
Before he was ever linked to the top job at The Hawthorns, and more than a year before he took it, Eric Ramsay spoke of his contentment with life as manager of Minnesota United.
“The length of a tenure here [MLS] is significantly longer on average than it is in the Championship.”
“You’ve got really sensible people that are looking at the long-term vision of the club. I felt like this was as good a chance as I was going to have to make sure that when I come out the other side of this, I’m as well prepared for whatever comes next as I could be.”
In May 2025, after Tony Mowbray’s departure, Ramsay was installed as favourite for the West Brom job. The role was instead given to Ryan Mason, whose 26-match spell in the Championship ended on 6th January. He delivered 31 points, with a solid home record undermined by a poor away run, including 11 losses.
At the time, I wrote about how West Brom had dispensed with Mason’s services while they had the division’s third-best xG ratio over his final five games, and the fourth-best over his final ten. The sackable offence, presumably, was that his team had taken only 9 points from those 10 games. We can also only assume that performance data was either ignored or overlooked as a mitigating factor when the club weighed up whether or not to sack the 34-year-old.
As supporters, we are ignorant of the conversations that take place behind closed doors, although it is fair to assume they do take place. You would love to be a fly on the wall when Chris Wilder or Will Still got the boot on the back of strong underlying performance data – and, in the former’s case, a brilliant points return. Arguably it was similar for Ryan Mason, for Lee Grant at Huddersfield, and even for Darren Moore at Port Vale, bottom of League One. All three clubs, per Not The Top Table, are showing poorer underlying numbers under their new bosses. But that is to overanalyse the outcome.
We all know sackings are common. Many have a curative effect on a team’s form; many more fail to be any such tonic. The biggest reason for their prevalence is that, to a club’s owner(s), sacking a manager is the only lever available when they believe the team is underperforming expectations. The issue with that, as George Elek pointed out, is that in a 24-team division, one team has to finish 24th, 23rd, 22nd and so on. And yet nobody seems to expect, and certainly will not tolerate, the realistic possibility that their season will be something other than rosy.
What are and what were West Bromwich Albion’s expectations? Obviously, to the board, 18th place after 26 games was below the standard. But was it right that Mason was made to carry the can in January?
I’m sure there are West Brom fans who would argue the sacking was fair. But, with the January transfer window in its infancy, it isn’t difficult to argue that the best person to fix personnel issues within the squad was the man who had spent the first half of the season learning its flaws. In firing Mason, they lost his instinct for what needed to change. Whether those instincts were good or bad, they were uniquely formed by the singular experience of… you know… actually being West Brom’s manager.
Instead, Mason’s career – like so many before and so many to come – was defined by a bad run of form. It was decided, above his station, that he had failed to such an extent that another individual was more likely to improve the situation.
This is a logical fallacy.
With so much money sloshing about in football, it amazes me that such muddled thinking persists. But the formula is simple: one part outcome bias, one part recency bias, and a few parts attribution error. How often do we see an individual, the manager, blamed for situational factors such as injuries, squad quality, an out-of-form striker or a couple of individual errors? Or, as with Mason’s final game, a 2-1 away defeat when Abdul Fatawu volleys home a sensational winner in the 94th minute after WBA have created three big chances, had eight shots on target and hit the post?
The Championship table after Ryan Mason was sacked
When Eric Ramsay joined the Baggies on 11 January, he was the beneficiary of an illogical churn that he had already articulated with clarity:
“As a young British coach, you can get lots of hype around [you] very quickly and end up moving through the steps very quickly, but then the career can be over before it has begun.”
During his first interview in post, Ramsay also spoke to the questionable logic behind sacking Mason in the first place. With hindsight, the comment feels even more pointed.
“Everyone who has watched a good chunk of this season will recognise there has been an element of misfortune.”
Fortune and misfortune are underrepresented in discussions of the hire-and-fire approach in football. These situational factors and considerations are rarely enough to save a manager during a poor run of form. Citing mistakes and poor decision-making is far easier for owners, board members, fans and, well, me.
Ramsay made one of his own in his very first game.
Wedded to a particular shape, he deployed Mikey Johnston, arguably West Brom’s best player, as a right-sided wing-back during his opening defeat to Middlesbrough. Watching that match, it felt utterly bizarre. The decision heightened Johnston’s weaknesses and masked his strengths. It was difficult to see how this could possibly be the bold answer to West Brom’s woes – and it wouldn’t have been the case had Mason been in charge.
Dig a little deeper and the situation looks even stranger. Across Ramsay’s eight Championship matches in charge, Johnston started at right wing-back, left midfield, right midfield, in a floating central attacking role and once on the left wing, along with three appearances from the bench. Notably, he didn’t provided a single goal nor assist under Ramsay, despite continuing to top the squad’s rankings for goal contributions (11).
This is just one tightly focused example of Ramsay struggling to correct a problem of his own making. That isn’t to say Mason had everything solved. Rather, it highlights how changing a manager can overcomplicate and distort issues that didn’t necessarily require such upheaval.
Still, it wasn’t Ramsay’s difficulty in finding Johnston’s best role, or his hesitancy between sticking and adapting, or even adopting a style of play that looked ill-suited to the squad, that ultimately defined his spell. All of that would likely have been forgiven if West Brom had simply won a few games. Winning is the handmaiden of patience, after all, and losing is the chaperone of its opposite.
They did not win a few games. They did not win any games.
Thanks to a record of P8 W0 D4 L4 under Ramsay, West Bromwich Albion now sit just a point above the relegation zone. They’d be in it were it not for Leicester’s points deduction.
The Championship table after Eric Ramsay was sacked
None of this is intended as a critique of Ramsay’s coaching ability, nor a defence of Mason’s. It is fascinating, though, that someone who so clearly understood the precarious nature of taking a job in England arrived in the Midlands and told supporters: “It’s undeniable that the squad is capable of more than where it is at the moment.”
All right, so it reads more like a truism now. But was it true when Ramsay took over? Was it true when Ryan Mason’s final seven games – two wins and five defeats – were all decided by a single goal? You may answer yes to all those questions and you may be right or wrong and it still won’t matter because, ultimately, they are the wrong questions. The right question is one of decision-making.
This is the thing I cannot fathom.
Strip away the individuals involved and focus on the logic of those behind the scenes. Why was there so little faith in one man and so much faith in the other? In this example, and so many more, there is no good answer. The buck stops short of those who really make decisions. Personally, I think that stinks.
It stinks that managers are the only accountable figureheads at football clubs. It stinks that too many owners can’t practise a scintilla of patience. And it stinks that what is missing on the managerial obituaries of Ramsay and Mason alike is an adequate account of why they were hired in the first place and fired in the second. Luckily, Eric Ramsay, a man who walked into the trap he predicted, wrote it already:
“Getting managers sacked is a bit of a national sport.”
https://www.ntt20.com/p/how-eric-ramsay-...popup=true
|
|
|
| The View from the Opposition - Charlton at the Hawthorns |
|
Posted by: Squid - 02-25-2026, 03:32 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (6)
|
 |
I missed doing them, so here it is:
***Pre Match***
I always remember West Bromwich as being a well established Prem side, but now have really fallen from grace of late and currently sit one place and one point outside the drop zone, winless in the last six matches…so, we really need to rub salt into the wound and come home with all three points…
At least Grant's injury precludes the ex-player curse striking again. We've been diabolical and decent in equal measure recently so a basically competent non thrilling professional win will do nicely please.
- They do have Bielik as well.
They’ve not won in the league in 2026, this feels like one where we need 3 points not “settle for a draw” imo
- More than not winning, they haven’t led a game since December. Banana skin written all over it
Not a must win, but this is a game we ought to be targeting for a win. Yes our next 2 games are at home, but against WAY better opposition than WBA.
Pompey are a better team than WBA as well, I never thought they would go down. Well coached, and they made decent additions in January. Plus the players and fans are totally behind Mousinho, whereas it won't take much to get the Baggies fans to turn tonight.
If you’re looking for an omen for tonight…
Left work, waited to cross road and opposite me waiting to cross is a bloke in a Charlton hat. Unusual for the city. As we approach each other crossing I excited go with fist clenched “big game tonight, COME ON YOU REDS”
Bloke completely ignores me. Proper pies me. Those crossing either side of me hastily split away like I’m some local nutter.
Cheers mate
I presume the rainbow mascot is bi-sexual? It is, apparently, a combi boiler, after all.
Isaac Price just wiped his nose and rubbed it on the grass, charming
Never understand why West Brom have a boiler as a mascot
- Sponsored by a boiler company right?
West Brom manager looking for his first win. Oh, bugger.
***First Half***
WBA down our left but offside
WBA get into our box, Bell clears out for a corner.
WBA on top so far.
- Brownie spoke about them being very possesion based, they had more of the ball than Coventry on Saturday
Ref is ready to give them anything and everything
Bite your hand off for a draw this evening.
No availability in midfield so we lump it forward and lose it quickly. A better team than WBA would be exploiting this already.
This is an absolute abomination of a game so far.
This lot look so low on confidence, maybe we should show some attacking intent?
Johnstone has Ramsay and Clarke on toast right now
If we can keep this 0-0 to HT we might get something. WBA 100% the better team so far and feels like the Pompey game before the Kaminski error.
Looks like Albion have realised we are shit and very little threat to their goal. Johnston is running Clarke ragged at the moment.
Second best here. Needs to improve fast.
Can't help but feel that we would benefit from someone quick up front to hassle their back line.
West Brom defenders are playing sideways balls around Leaburn and Dykes and it would be interesting to see them have to make quick decisions
Incredibly quiet at The Hawthorns
They’ve been the better team but West Brom seem a poor side low on confidence. We could do with testing their defence
Giving these far too much respect
Collins against that tricky left winger and a card happy ref….
Even this WBA side, who are poor, have way more quality than us.
WBA crowd starting to get impatient. Great sliding challenege from Chambers to put it out for a throw there.
- All credit to the WBA crowd staying awake enough to get impatient.
This is painful to watch.
Ref now ignoring wba fouls
Driving me potty this shit show - we are making them look good.
1 - 0
Terrible first half from both sides, less said about the Ref the better.
Well they deserve it we are shite
***Half Time***
What’s worse? That we’re 1-0 down to the worst team in the division? Or that they fully deserve the lead.
- We aren't playing Sheffield Wednesday
- I’ve watched WBA a few times recently. And Wednesday (a squad that’s been ripped apart and under an embargo) - WBA are worse, certainly in recent weeks.
I can't be mad. They deserve that.
No surprise. WBA have outplayed us. A spineless display.
Well Done WBA. Ref is MOM
Urgh. What timing. They probably deserve that though.
That’s maybe the worst goal we’ve conceded this season. How is Campbell free at the back post? Utterly disgraceful.
We don't create anything and have very little movement too - no meaningful crosses, no penetrative passes, wing backs not getting forward, nobody getting beyond the front two from deep etc etc. I get it playing like that against the likes of Coventry, Middlesbrough or Ipswich but WBA haven't won a game of any description for 12 games. We've literally played into their hands.
WBA fans celebrating the HT whistle like its FT
This team have not scored in 4 and won in years and yet we are more insipid then we were against Chelsea.
Why can’t we ever take a game by the scruff of the neck and say to the other team ‘come on, then.’ We’re playing pretty much the worst team in the league who are bereft of confidence, fans booing them off last game and a manager who seems totally out of his depth. And yet again we subside, give them space and let them take a hold on the game.
Poor first half, but West Brom looked toothless before the goal.
WBA are actually playing football - we are not.
Their left winger is turning Clarke inside out!
***Second Half***
If we score the next goal, we'll go on to win this, they're flaky as hell
lol wba midfield all over us.
More atmosjpher in a black hole than at The Hawthorns
Nasty tackle from Molumby, studs up and above the ankle. Booked
Should be 2-0. West Brom moving the ball well in the final third
Very lucky not to be 0-2
Should be 2-0, got away with it after yet more ridiculously sloppy play from Doc on the ball
Josh Maja misses from 8 yards
- Maja error
We are making a horrible side look like playoff chasers.
That’s a shocking WBA miss. They are not great up front. We have a chance.
You would think WBA were top half the way we are letting them play
Phillips gets free head, 5 Charlton stand there staring at eachother
Maybe this is all part of the plan...
Let West Brom win so they don't sack Ramsay, and every other club can then beat them, and send them down
WBA have not won for 12 games. They've has ten shots. We've had one.
One attack and WBA looked shellshocked.
Despite everything we are still only. 1-0 down to a goal that should never have happened if the ref done his job correctly down the other end
13 games since that WBA sub scored, we all know what's coming!
Heggebo on a 13 game drought....
You know what that means
Another let off.
WBA look terrible and they’re better than us by a mile
1 -1
Haha completely underserved but GET IN
Dykes! Great ball from Ramsay, poor defending from wba. Can we do this?
Am I the only one who just assumed he was about 7 yards offside and didn’t celebrate
Harsh on West Brom given how they've played, but they clearly can't finish their dinner which is why they're in the mess they find themselves in
The win is probably also there if we want it - I can see WBA crumbling
Jed Wallace really opted for the wrong move, when he decided to swap Millwall for West Brom
Johnston is a tidy footballer.
- His name irritates the shit out of me... Its missing an "e" at the end
West Brom do get caught offside a lot. I can't remember this many in a game all season.
Football is a funny game. I can see WBA losing the plot, throwing everything at it & losing the game from a quick break
Reported CAFC fan Imray on, hopefully he helps us out
Phew. WBA chance half blocked by Ramsay and Cov does well to block the follow up. Surprisingly we get the goal kick.
How did that stay out AND get given as a goal kick?
Gave us a goal kick there instead of a corner to WBA.
Only one team looks like winning this
- Do they? Neither look like winning it to me
WBA down our left, we struggle to deal with it, cross comes in, we're a bit all over the place but manage to clear.
This is all part of a plan to stop WBA sacking the coach so they lose to Oxford on Saturday
Fucking hell that was close.
So nearly payback time for the last minute winner at our place
That was so close. No idea how we're still in this game
***Post Match***
Full time, boos from the home fans
Nathan Jones making Eric Ramsay look just competent enough so he doesn’t get the sack and sends WBA down?
Massive let off there but it's a valuable point
Lucky, lucky, lucky
Wouldn’t mind us going in for Mikey Johnston if they go down next year
I just want to say that was a splendid effort from West Brom and Erik Ramsay, I hope they extend his Contract tomorrow
The good news is West Brom dropped 3 points tonight that they really should’ve had. They won’t play a worse side all season.
West Brom by far the better team.
Take a point all day long there. I thought West Brom looked decent tonight - well up for it, and a decent amount of quality on the ball. A player like Mowatt would be so handy for us.
My neighbours a West brom fan and he said he would be happy with a point when I bumped into him at 17.00, as I did. Sounds like we scrapped one.
Still trying to work out how we got a point from that match. Well having said that, when you are in WBAs position that is what happens but it felt like we did what we could to give them confidence to win it. Fortunately they didn't have it in the end.
Outplayed in the early part of the second half. We could easily have been 3-0 down when Dykes equalised completely and utterly out of the blue.
We made them look like like 70s Brazil at times. Very horrible game to watch but Dykes’s goal was exceptionally well taken and it’s a result we got although barely deserved. If we stay up and they go down then I wouldn’t mind us having a go for Mikey Johnston.
10 games without a win for West Brom - looks a good point for us and poor point for them.
The good thing about that point is their manager will stay on for possibly a few more games and we have a point. If we had won, they may have got a decent new manager bounce and leapfrogged us.
West Brom are bloody awful, Charlton and the ref made the conscious to join them in their dross, I think if West Brom don't change their Manager, I will confidently predict that they will finish below us.
Before the game I really wanted 3 points. After that performance, I'm grateful for the 1 point which keeps WBA down there. WBA play pleasant football, but aren't clinical, and that's why they're down there.
Excruciatingly painful watch, but a point is a point and denying West Brom all 3 was huge.
West Brom's remaining fixtures are horrible. Can't see where a win is coming from for them.
That 94th min reclycled ball that was caught bang centre edge of the box, on the volley, was sooooo close to being the winner. West Brom will be gutted tonight.
We robbed them of that point.
Waiting for the train back to Birmingham and I'm amazed we've got a point out of that.
They won't play a worse team all season. If they had any quality in the final third and they would have battered us.
Well that was needlessly stressful. West Brom are terrible but looked better than us for a lot of it. They absolutely should have scored a second but they didn't have the confidence to finish any of their chances when they came.
If they can't beat us when we play like that, who are they going to beat?
Looking at some of the comments on X, the WBA fans aren't happy. I'd forgotten that they had Daryl Dike on the bench, who didn't come on. I remember him being lethal when he played for them first time around.
Eric Ramsay did the post match press conference, so is still in the job at the moment.
I can see how WBA are 4th from bottom. They have had some brilliant strikers over the years, Cyrille Regis, Laurie Cunningham (winger) and Kevin Phillips, Baggies supporters must be in disbelief at their current front line. There is a serious risk of them going down.
Really poor first half and WBA are not scoring their goal if Jones is still on the pitch. I really hope the injury is ok. Ref gave hardly feck all decisions Charlton's way first half and a soft booking for Jones before he went off.
2nd half - WBA somehow missed a sitter to go 2 up. At 1-0, I thought that apart from us looking terrible, and all over the place, we had a goal in the team. Often, if a team does not take their chances, it comes back to bite.
Eric Ramsey sacked
Another manager we get sacked
The only slight concern now is they appoint an impressive manager like Blackburn and Leicester have
WBA are probably the worst team in the League atm bar Sheff Wed. That was the first time since New Year that they've taken the lead in a game & I think they've forgotten how to win. We were second best for most of the game. We had 2 efforts on goal all night.
WBA are undoubtedly one of the worst teams in the division, there's no argument there and it is frustrating we couldn't beat them or play more aggressively but some context about their squad is needed. Trasnfermarkt values their squad at €68.53m and ours at €29.05m. That, of course, means they have some players capable of playing better than the team performances suggest. I think their two best performers last night were Campbell and Johnston. Campbell was a genuine bargain, he cost about €1.3m last summer. That is still more than we spent on a defender in that window, Sichenje has cost more. If you include loan fees, Johnston has got WBA a total of €4.7m which is more than we have spent on any single player this season and probably for a decade. He's also played a decent number of games for Celtic, European football and nearly 100 Championship games and is 26. We don't really have players of that age, with that pedigree.
Bizarrely Mikey Johnston hadn't started the previous 3 games for WBA. I'd read various comments from WBA fans baffled by that, and after last night I'm also confused, as he easily looked their best player.
bugger me that was terrible
West Brom are the poorest side I've seen all season apart from us first half at home against Saints.
If half the team from Saints away on Saturday had turned up we'd have spanked the Baggies big time
Just been reading the comments on the BBC website report of the game. A West Brom fan messaged "If I was sentenced to death, I'd want our players to be the firing squad"
Before that corner kick was taken, Campbell took two handfuls of Ramsay's shirt and threw him two yards away. Surprised NJ didn't complain in the post-match.
Last night we were out played and should have lost to a team that couldn't buy a point and sacked their manager minutes later.
|
|
|
| Fuggin Lib Dems |
|
Posted by: Fido - 02-25-2026, 03:09 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (2)
|
 |
Just received their little newsletter through the post and one of their tasks is to clamp down on illegal parking or rather people that park halfway onto the pavement. A few years ago we were having our drive done and I stuck my motor in the close opposite (probably about the only time ever) where everyone parks half on the pavement because otherwise the bin lorry can't drive up the road. (There is another pathway on the other side of the close as well). Lo and behold it's my fuggin motor they've snapped a photo of for all and sundry to see!
I'm going to give that beetroot-faced bastard Clive Jones a right mouthful if he's milling around the polling station come the next locals and tell them they're a bunch of shit-outs that don't even want to compete for governmental power in this country.
Fumin'...
|
|
|
| Dirty Business (CH4 9pm) |
|
Posted by: Pipkins - 02-25-2026, 02:25 PM - Forum: Politics
- Replies (2)
|
 |
Anyone been watching this docu/drama on CH4?
3 parter started on Monday over 3 nights (available on CH4 catch up)
Tells story of the Water Companies polluting seas & rivers resulting in death of young girl
Its been a great watch so far
But makes my piss boil how they keep getting away with what they do
Employing people as communications officer to say all the right things the publicc want to hear
The Environment Agency corrupt & totally fecking useless
Just confirms what 99% already thought
Utter utter disgrace
Should have been nationalised under Blair as private sector cant be trusted to manage it
|
|
|
| Shove the rumour mill up your arse |
|
Posted by: BertieTheBaggie - 02-25-2026, 01:18 PM - Forum: WBAUnofficial
- Replies (23)
|
 |
That’s my message to those putting names forward who won’t be in the running.
I’ve already had mates texting me about Dyche and Still and I just want to tell them to fuck off as I’m not part of the decision process, being a 57 year old who had not played football since you were still able to back pass to the keeper and he pick the ball up.
Having admitted my own lack of qualifications I still think I could have done better than Patel in the past year.
|
|
|
| Politics Live |
|
Posted by: Protheroe - 02-25-2026, 12:51 PM - Forum: Politics
- Replies (6)
|
 |
Well worth watching between 11:30 - 11:44 today, if only to witness the lunacy from Bell Ribeiro-Addy. We are being gaslighted on Energy by some of thickest people ever to enter the HoC.
Well worth watching at 11:50 where Bell admits she doesn't understand supply and demand. Jesus
|
|
|
|