Reading ratings
#1
Here's me onions...

Sam: didn't have much to do (the penno was their only shot on target). Distribution was fine but it's fair to say crosses are his achilles heel. Helped steady the nerves at the end by taking his time - 6

O'Shea: I thought his defending in the first half was superb, making several timely tackles and interceptions. I like him. If we're going to persist with him at RB, he's going to need to work on his forward play - but having FBs whose prime consideration is defending is fine by me - 7
Bartley - recovered well from his inexplicable handball that gave Reading a penalty and gave a commanding performance, topped off with a very well taken goal - 8.
Ajayi - made good use of his athleticism tonight, but he still gives the ball away too frequently. Sound overall - 7.5
Townsend - ever willing going forward, he put in another very competent defensive performance against a pacy winger. I really like him, don't think he's ever let us down and don't understand some of the sniping he gets on here. 7.5

Pereira - boy oh boy, so talented. Pulled the strings tonight, got a goal and could have had more (I thought his free kick had nestled into the top corner). But it's not just his  creative talent, is it? He really put in a shift tonight and covered a lot of ground. Don't fuck this Albion, make sure he's signed for next season. Very nearly my MOTM, but not quite - 9.
Livermore - is he currently in the form of his life? He seems to be flourishing in the role of team captain, leading by example. Drove us on tonight, tackles AOTS and also getting into the Reading penalty area. Outstanding and my MOTM - 9.5
Sawyers - I love watching Sawyers. Very intelligent. When he's on his game, so are we - but he struggled for some periods tonight. However, when he did come alive (15 minutes either side of HT), we were fantastic. 2 blokes just in front of where I was watching got into a heated debate over him, with one saying  he only ever passes sideways or backwards. If you think that, chap, you're not watching closely enough, frankly. Tonight though - 6
Krov - links up well with Pereira and in really good form since he got back in the team. Clearly loving life at the moment and geed up the travelling fans a few times - 7
Robinson - first viewing of him and looks like another good loan picking. Doesn't look the fastest IMO, but when he gets the ball, he plays with his head up and aware of his options, putting in several telling crosses. Seems comfortable going outside or coming inside, I'm certain he's going to weigh in with goals - 7

HRK - another trademark performance. Industry, aggression, tenacity. If he scored goals, he'd probably be elsewhere. Is he capable of putting in a 3rd shift in 6 days v Forest? A decision for Bilic - 7

Subs:
Phillips - great to be able to bring a player of his quality on. Helped us over the line - 7
Grosiki - didn't get enough of the ball - 6
Austin - not enough time - 6

Bilic - credit for regaining momentum - 9

FANS - don't normally pass comment on them but they were behind the lads from start to finish. Thanks for making me laugh with the 'Charlie Adam, we though you were dead' chant, even if he nearly had the last laugh with that delicious cross Smile
Reply
#2
Bartley shouldn’t get an 8 after what he did. Krov and Robinson higher, thought they were superb in linking up with Pereria, both hit the bar after brilliant build up play.
Reply
#3
Can't disagree with a lot of that Chase. I'd have Krov, Hal and Robinson a point higher and Pereira was my MOTM but can see why you picked Jake. Brilliant this season.

On Sawyers it's a strange one. He's so damn good but equally quite frustrating at times and a few around us were discussing his seeming inability to shoot. He seems to do anything in his power to not take on the shot and look for a pass. A few times last night it opened up for him 20 yards out but he chose an intricate pass instead.

We were guilty at times of over playing last night and trying to be too pretty. I'm not going to lie though. We were bloody lovely to watch.
Reply
#4
(02-13-2020, 02:07 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Here's me onions...

Sam: didn't have much to do (the penno was their only shot on target). Distribution was fine but it's fair to say crosses are his achilles heel. Helped steady the nerves at the end by taking his time - 6

O'Shea: I thought his defending in the first half was superb, making several timely tackles and interceptions. I like him. If we're going to persist with him at RB, he's going to need to work on his forward play - but having FBs whose prime consideration is defending is fine by me - 7
Bartley - recovered well from his inexplicable handball that gave Reading a penalty and gave a commanding performance, topped off with a very well taken goal - 8.
Ajayi - made good use of his athleticism tonight, but he still gives the ball away too frequently. Sound overall - 7.5
Townsend - ever willing going forward, he put in another very competent defensive performance against a pacy winger. I really like him, don't think he's ever let us down and don't understand some of the sniping he gets on here. 7.5

Pereira - boy oh boy, so talented. Pulled the strings tonight, got a goal and could have had more (I thought his free kick had nestled into the top corner). But it's not just his  creative talent, is it? He really put in a shift tonight and covered a lot of ground. Don't fuck this Albion, make sure he's signed for next season. Very nearly my MOTM, but not quite - 9.
Livermore - is he currently in the form of his life? He seems to be flourishing in the role of team captain, leading by example. Drove us on tonight, tackles AOTS and also getting into the Reading penalty area. Outstanding and my MOTM - 9.5
Sawyers - I love watching Sawyers. Very intelligent. When he's on his game, so are we - but he struggled for some periods tonight. However, when he did come alive (15 minutes either side of HT), we were fantastic. 2 blokes just in front of where I was watching got into a heated debate over him, with one saying  he only ever passes sideways or backwards. If you think that, chap, you're not watching closely enough, frankly. Tonight though - 6
Krov - links up well with Pereira and in really good form since he got back in the team. Clearly loving life at the moment and geed up the travelling fans a few times - 7
Robinson - first viewing of him and looks like another good loan picking. Doesn't look the fastest IMO, but when he gets the ball, he plays with his head up and aware of his options, putting in several telling crosses. Seems comfortable going outside or coming inside, I'm certain he's going to weigh in with goals - 7

HRK - another trademark performance. Industry, aggression, tenacity. If he scored goals, he'd probably be elsewhere. Is he capable of putting in a 3rd shift in 6 days v Forest? A decision for Bilic - 7

Subs:
Phillips - great to be able to bring a player of his quality on. Helped us over the line - 7
Grosiki - didn't get enough of the ball - 6
Austin - not enough time - 6

Bilic - credit for regaining momentum - 9

FANS - don't normally pass comment on them but they were behind the lads from start to finish. Thanks for making me laugh with the 'Charlie Adam, we though you were dead' chant, even if he nearly had the last laugh with that delicious cross Smile

+1
Reply
#5
(02-13-2020, 06:50 AM)aj21 Wrote: Bartley shouldn’t get an 8 after what he did. Krov and Robinson higher, thought they were superb in linking up with Pereria, both hit the bar after brilliant build up play.

I hear what you're saying about Bartley and no doubt it was an utterly astonishing mistake he made, BUT I thought that was the only blemish the whole evening. Got his head to numerous crosses, especially second half to prevent Reading from getting any clear cut chances. 1 shot on target.
Reply
#6
(02-13-2020, 08:22 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2020, 06:50 AM)aj21 Wrote: Bartley shouldn’t get an 8 after what he did. Krov and Robinson higher, thought they were superb in linking up with Pereria, both hit the bar after brilliant build up play.

I hear what you're saying about Bartley and no doubt it was an utterly astonishing mistake he made, BUT I thought that was the only blemish the whole evening. Got his head to numerous crosses, especially second half to prevent Reading from getting any clear cut chances. 1 shot on target.

The midfield have been so at it over the last 2 games, often said that is where games are won - they were all over everything last night, the workrate was amazing, even Krov and Periera who you might thing don't do that naturally were snapping at their heels - the number of times we regained possession through this was impressive.
Reply
#7
HRK is close on my Player of the Season - after the glamour players like Pereira and Grady.

Never thought I would say that.
Reply
#8
Livermore in the form of his life you say? You’re not allowed to say that on here with the mods!

Thought we were superb again last night, first time I’ve been to the Madjeski and got anything in about 8 visits but thoroughly deserved, nit quite as good as Millwall but not far off, lovely transition with the ball, pulling Reading defense and midfield all over the shop, only criticism and that’s too strong a word is we should be scoring more but our approach play is second to none and the swagger is certainly back

My marks

SJ 6 Really worrying, glued to his line again last night, the Pereira slice up in the air was keepers ball to punch away all night, he didn’t and from the corner they score, every corner is put in to our six yard box, he’s glued to his line and the one time he does come off his line for a cross, he’s beaten to the ball and Reading score...thankfully off side. Can’t think for one minute the coaches aren’t working on this aspect of his game so where’s the improvement?

O Shea 7;Some solid defending as you would expect from a CH playing at RB, tidy enough with the ball but has to play sideways and backwards a lot as he’s not got the game to get past his man and overlap
Only concern is the opposition know this and can press him quickly, still solid display for one so young

Townsend 8 Another good game for Connor, carrying the ball well forward, only exposed by Reading pacy winger once, very tidy in possession

Bartley 7 Sublime and ridiculous, the penalty is an absolute brain fade...and he’s got previous, after that defended well and got the goal

Semi 8 Thought he picked up where he left off Sunday, good defending, good on the ball, very solid in the air

Livermore 9 My player of the season just keeps getting better, work rate amazing, leads by example, sets the tone, top class midfield performance, pops up everywhere and could have had a couple himself such was our dominance

Sawyers 7 Real mixed bag, kept possession well but not influencing games as he was earlier in the season, shame he’s not got somebody challenging for his place as needs that pressure IMO, another soft yellow after his own sloppy play, suspension imminent, one booking away I think?

Robinson 7 A handful as he’s shown so far, just lacking end product and goals currently but intelligent player who’s fitting in well, can see he’s loving being part of the group

Pereira 9 Wow, different class again, just unplayable when he’s in this form

Krovinovic 8 Found space all night, especially in the first half, another top performance with workrate to match

HRK 8 Thought he was excellent last night, great workrate, hold up play excellent and unlucky not to score, fits our system so well and deservedly getting the nod

Subs

Phillips 7 Full of running when introduced

Krosicki 7;Always a threat when on the ball, couple of chances blocked but didn’t see as much of the ball as he could of

Austin 6 Little time but little impact

Great away night, great 3 points, roll on Forest

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#9
(02-13-2020, 08:46 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: HRK is close on my Player of the Season - after the glamour players like Pereira and Grady.

Never thought I would say that.

Not sure how HRK or Diangana could be anywhere near anyone's POTS when looking at the contribution we've had from Pereira, and particularly Livermore this season.

They're the only two genuine contenders in my view.
Reply
#10
(02-13-2020, 09:02 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(02-13-2020, 08:46 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: HRK is close on my Player of the Season - after the glamour players like Pereira and Grady.

Never thought I would say that.

Not sure how HRK or Diangana could be anywhere near anyone's POTS when looking at the contribution we've had from Pereira, and particularly Livermore this season.

They're the only two genuine contenders in my view.

HRK may not grab the headlines, but he is a willing worker, and an outlet.

We look a lot poorer without him, because the ball comes straight back. Another shrewd choice in team selection by Slav.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)