Serge Gnabry: ‘Tony Pulis felt I wasn’t Premier League level’
#1
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/sport...-wj6vdt9q2

So, what did happen?
“Tony Pulis,” Serge Gnabry replies.
“Ask Tony Pulis.”
And he smiles. He can laugh now but there was no fun living through it — one of the odder episodes in any leading talent’s career. No other Bayern Munich player knows what it is like being grateful for 57 minutes against Port Vale, after all. Or how it feels when, repeatedly, you don’t even make the bench and the manager rates Callum McManaman higher than you.
Relaxed and engaging, Gnabry now speaks as one of Germany’s first-choice players, as a Bundesliga winner and star rated worth £80m by CIES Football Observatory. Then? This weekend four years ago he was an unused substitute at the Hawthorns, his next appearance coming at Rush Green stadium in front of 276 spectators against West Ham for West Brom Under-23s.

Gnabry’s 2015-16 loan to West Brom effectively ended his Arsenal career, one that promised so much when he became the club’s second youngest league footballer at 17 and appeared 18 times before his 19th birthday. A serious knee injury robbed him of a year’s development before, on turning 20, he was sent to play for Pulis, who gave him 12 minutes in the Premier League against Chelsea. Then two curtailed League Cup run-outs. Then never used him again.

“Different style, different opinions. I can’t say too much but I tried my best at West Brom,” Gnabry says. He arrived there having done well for Germany as they reached a European Under-21 Championship semi-final. “I was fit and hoping to play and was told I would be getting a lot of game time. I spoke to the manager before [going] and worked hard but it didn’t work out.”

Pulis said he was not “at the level” to play Premier League football, implying problems with his conditioning, and there were murmurs about his weight. Gnabry denies such issues. “I’m the same [weight and fitness] now,” he says. For him it was simply about opportunities. The following summer he top-scored at the Olympics, where Germany were beaten finalists. “I got the chance to play regularly,” he says, agreeing that the Rio Games were the turning point of his career. “I’m sure if [Pulis] had given me some [game] time I’d have showed what I’m capable of.”
Arsenal have a loan manager nowadays and rigorously plan and track their young players’ spells at borrower clubs. That wasn’t the case in 2015-16 and after being recalled in the January transfer window, Gnabry was stigmatised. Asked if Arsenal thought less of him he says: “For sure. The question came up. It didn’t look good when I didn’t play at West Brom. But looking back I can say, ‘I don’t know why’. I’m sure I have proved to everyone [that the doubts were wrong].”

Gnabry’s resurrection started at Werder Bremen. Some at Arsenal — notably then chief scout Steve Rowley — argued against letting him go but Arsène Wenger was happy to sell to Werder Bremen for £5m and Gnabry, having tasted regular football at those Olympics, just wanted to be somewhere he would play.
“[Arsenal] had so many wingers at the time — Ox, Rosicky, Theo, Cazorla, Alexis, Mesut Ozil . . . so I just had to go. Sadly,” he says. “I was still confident I could have got in the team but I didn’t want to wait. It was the hardest decision I had to make in football, leaving a club like Arsenal — the fans, the players — but to keep playing I had to take a step back and it was the right decision.”

He flourished at Bremen and scored a hat-trick on debut for Germany. Bayern signed him and with Arjen Robben, Franck Ribery, Kingsley Coman and Douglas Costa ahead in the pecking order he pushed this time for a well-judged loan move to Hoffenheim, where he was keen to play for their messianic young coach Julian Nagelsmann. “With Bremen we lost to them, at home, 5-3 and the way they played I said, ‘What. The. Hell. I need to learn from this guy.’”

Nagelsmann — now wowing at RB Leipzig — didn’t disappoint. Niko Kovac took until November to give Gnabry consecutive starts in his first “real” season for Bayern but he soon proved pivotal, excelling in a deep wide role when Kovac switched to 4-2-3-1 and scoring key goals — only Robert Lewandowski outscored him — as Bayern overhauled Borussia Dortmund.
The make-or-break quality required by any Bayern player is “personality”, Gnabry says. He observed it in Ribery and Robben and tried to learn from them — “the mentality [Robben] had was a different level”— but the strength of his psyche really stems from his English experiences. The leaving of family and friends behind in Germany at 16. The injury. All the big players at Arsenal. And those difficult West Brom months; cold-shouldered at training, playing for the under-23s and going back to an empty rented flat in Birmingham, forever grateful for the support of his father, Jean-Hermann, who drove from London every weekend to see him.
“I don’t regret [joining Arsenal so young] at all,” Gnabry says. “I wish I’d had more luck at West Brom but it is all what made me what I am today. Off the pitch I learnt a lot — how some people are not there for you when it is not going well. And also mentally for me, in that time at West Brom when I said, ‘OK, even though I have zero chance of playing all I can do is work hard’. That mentality has stayed with me today and helped me become a Bayern player.”


I'm glad he's recovered from his time with us. Hope other young players read this and vow never to play for a team managed by TTWTC
Reply
#2
Pulis in “wrong about actual footballer” shock
Reply
#3
Gnabry wasn’t ready though, anyone who actually watched him could tell that. Wenger didn’t think so either.

There are plenty of legitimate sticks to beat Pulis with, this isn’t one of them.
Reply
#4
(09-29-2019, 06:47 AM)Duffers Wrote: Gnabry wasn’t ready though, anyone who actually watched him could tell that. Wenger didn’t think so either.

There are plenty of legitimate sticks to beat Pulis with, this isn’t one of them.

Yep. Players Develop. This was 4 seasons ago for a loan player for a season when we finished 14th in the Prem. Time to move on
Reply
#5
It does make you wonder why Pulis did take him on loan. Our loan players around that time in general under Pulis were shit.
Much improved now.
I'd like to think a bit more thought is being put into it now with what we need.
Reply
#6
(09-29-2019, 07:12 AM)tiptontown Wrote: It does make you wonder why Pulis did take him on loan. Our loan players around that time in general under Pulis were shit.
Much improved now.
I'd like to think a bit more thought is being put into it now with what we need.

Spot on
Reply
#7
(09-29-2019, 07:12 AM)tiptontown Wrote: It does make you wonder why Pulis did take him on loan. Our loan players around that time in general under Pulis were shit.
Much improved now.
I'd like to think a bit more thought is being put into it now with what we need.

Did Pulis have a say in who we took on loan?

My impression was that he didn't want certain players and bombed them out because they didn't work aaaard enough
Reply
#8
Wenger chose to send him on loan. Cant have rated him either.
Reply
#9
(09-29-2019, 07:55 AM)Albionmad Wrote:
(09-29-2019, 07:12 AM)tiptontown Wrote: It does make you wonder why Pulis did take him on loan. Our loan players around that time in general under Pulis were shit.
Much improved now.
I'd like to think a bit more thought is being put into it now with what we need.

Did Pulis have a say in who we took on loan?

My impression was that he didn't want certain players and bombed them out because they didn't work aaaard enough

No idea, all I do know is our loan deals needed improving back then as most weren't working to the clubs advantage.
Reply
#10
I was at that Vale game and felt Gnabry showed skill, pace and promise which was something we lacked at the time. He twice turned his man near halfway line and created attacks, blazing one over and the other coming to nothing. Was disappointed he was hooked and put it down to fitness.

Wenger sent him on loan to us to get minutes as he was just coming back from overcoming a serious injury- to say Wenger didn’t rate him is incorrect.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: