Good Luck Burnham
#1
IF (big IF) Andy Burnham commits to the end of the Triple Lock within this Parliament then I wish him the best of luck.

It would be totemic.
Reply
#2
It's an ideal time to tie the PA to the pension amount to give something in exchange. Giving pensioners the best of any scenario is honourable but unaffordable. Taking away the threat of losing their homes by creating the social fund mentioned would be a good incentive.

However last time anyone threatened pensioners, by taking the WFA from the rich ones, had a Reform supporting mate of mine literally shouting in the middle of a restaurant that people would die so god knows how they will react to this one.
Reply
#3
Surely the triple lock has served its purpose to bring up to a decent level for many people and should now be inflation linked.
Reply
#4
He could take away the 2.5% minimum without having any impact on anyone for years probably. The problem is that in todays climate you can't take anything away without it being labelled as political suicide.
Reply
#5
(09-29-2026, 12:14 PM)baggy1 Wrote: He could take away the 2.5% minimum without having any impact on anyone for years probably. The problem is that in todays climate you can't take anything away without it being labelled as political suicide.

Both are true.

Inflation won't hit target until after the end of this Parliament at least.
Reply
#6
Removing the link with wages and the 2.5% being moot for the foreseeable future is a good move and framed well in that speech. A lot of other good parts to that speech as well - no skating around subjects with political language and honesty for a change. I would vote for that, obviously some might say.

Who wouldn't vote for that and what would be the reasons?
Reply
#7
(09-29-2026, 12:01 PM)HugeHons Wrote: Surely the triple lock has served its purpose to bring up to a decent level for many people and should now be inflation linked.

Yes, it has. When it came in pensioner poverty was high, now it's dropped in absolute and relative terms and is lower than adult and child poverty.
Reply
#8
(09-29-2026, 03:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Removing the link with wages and the 2.5% being moot for the foreseeable future is a good move and framed well in that speech. A lot of other good parts to that speech as well - no skating around subjects with political language and honesty for a change. I would vote for that, obviously some might say.

Who wouldn't vote for that and what would be the reasons?

Welcome in principle. However it's kicked down the road. 

Here's the fudge as well - Burnham said the state pension will also “hold its value relative to earnings over time, so that pensioners will always share in the rising prosperity of the nation”.

What on Earth does that mean?

Is it just 2.5% or CPI, or is it something else?
Reply
#9
It's so depressingly predictable that Labour governments get bogged down by any discussion of reducing any kind of benefit. The same people who shout about this will vote Conservative or Reform and watch their government of choice doing exactly the same thing - perfectly happy to accept that it's necessary.

As one of the 27% of pensioner households with a notional worth of £1m plus (counting value of pension pots and property) I don't need a Winter Fuel Allowance, I don't need an above average increase in my State Pension and I'm happy to pay a bit of higher rate tax in the years when I get my sums wrong. We need to get away from this notion/expectation that a Labour government can't ever take anything off anyone.

I heard the annoying Sharon Graham of Unite rattling on about "Labour must reduce the tax burden on working people". That's missing the point. Labour needs to reduce the tax burden on people in poverty - I mean can't afford food or fuel poverty, not can't replace the car every two years or go abroad twice a year poverty. Most of us could and should pay a little more tax to provide the things we expect (healthcare, roads, schools, defence). Yes, get stuck into businesses that avoid tax and sting the super-wealthy within reason, but that isn't going to bring in all the money we need.

The Chesh solution? Sharp increase in thresholds, rigorously index-linked year-on-year. One percent on base rate of tax, 2 percent on higher and additional rates. Back off a little on the stealth taxes, especially NI. Won't win me any elections, but it might balance the books.
Reply
#10
(09-29-2026, 03:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-29-2026, 03:08 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Removing the link with wages and the 2.5% being moot for the foreseeable future is a good move and framed well in that speech. A lot of other good parts to that speech as well - no skating around subjects with political language and honesty for a change. I would vote for that, obviously some might say.

Who wouldn't vote for that and what would be the reasons?

Welcome in principle. However it's kicked down the road. 

Here's the fudge as well - Burnham said the state pension will also “hold its value relative to earnings over time, so that pensioners will always share in the rising prosperity of the nation”.

What on Earth does that mean?

Is it just 2.5% or CPI, or is it something else?

The IFS have covered that, it's essentially saying that the double lock is 2.5% or inflation but pensions aren't expected to deviate much from average earnings over the lifetime of the policy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)