Ray Tings
#1
What a great effort from the boys.... 

Ingram - 7 - No chance with any of the goals. Solid in everything else. No flapping. On the face of it he looks decent back up.

Williams - 8 - On this showing against a £350m assembled Premier league side I thought he had an excellent game for a young player. Defended well and supported Whitwell well.

Mepham - 6 - Solid enough. Shame aboylt the OG. Maybe could have moved his feet better.

Campbell - 6.5 - Carried the ball really well at times and showed some lovely passing. Possibly could have done better with their 2nd goal but unlucky also.

Townsend - 6 - Good pro and decent cover. I felt they were targeting him 2nd half and I think he could have done better for the winner but I'd need to see a replay.

Rabby - 7 - Considering his inexperience and the level of opposition I think we might have found a little gem. Cracking wotkrate and some clever passing. Tired 2nd half and was rightly subbed on a booking.

Diakite - 7.5 - Love Oussie. Looked class at times against very good opposition.

Whitwell - 7 - Showed real promise again and the longer the game went on the more he wanted the ball. He roamed everywhere to get it and his confidence is growing. Need to get that contract sorted.

Price - 8.5 - All action, all energy. He does love the month of August as once again he is looking like a £30m international player imo. Goals apart he just looks class.

Morgan - 6.5 - Ran, probed, buzzed around and tried to make things happen. Gets frustrated quite easily and needs to keep concentrating but no doubt he is a very good buy for the money.

Stewart - 7 - I really liked his performance. He fed off scraps all night but by God did the Toon defenders know they were in a game. Elbows, knees, head went in on every challenge and he ran the line left to right all night and I'm not sure he was caught offside once all night. Contrast that to Morgan against Burnley. Stewart is a real number 9 and he reminded me in style a bit like Gary Thomson with his socks around his ankles. For £1m it'll be interesting to see if we can polish him up.

Subs - All OK. Even Bany won a few decent free kicks. Can't be arsed to score them.

Top effort from Jimmy and the lads. Play like that against Boro and we might just well be sat on 9 points come Saturday night.
Reply
#2
Whitwell worth at least an 8 IMO. Absolutely destroyed Lewis Hall that first half. If Hall is a 70 million pound player then Williams is worth 9 figures on that showing
Reply
#3
Ingram 7

Williams 8
Campbell 8
Mepham 6
Townsend 5

Nzingoula 7.5
Diakite 8

Whitwell 8
Price 9
Morgan 7

Stewart 6

Molumby 6
Styles 7
Horn Myhre 7
Bany 6
Bostock 6
Reply
#4
Can't look past your .5 marks. Scrambles my brain  Big Grin

Ingram - 6 - nothing really to do, good passing and 2 routine saves.

Williams - 7 - Solid as a rock, struggled in possession at times first half and played some really sloppy sideways passes. Fine to compete with Galvez.
Mepham - 7 - Solid and composed. Unlucky for their first.
Campbell - 7 - see above. But unlucky for their second.
Townsend - 6 - 2 really good crosses and some good passes into the final third. Poor for their 3rd which costs him a mark.

Whitwell - 7 - Solid showing, seems to be settling into the cut and thrust of men's football and has a bit of the Nico Kranjcars about him in possession.
Rabby - 7 - 8 for 30 mins of the first half. 6 for the rest. Lots of potential to work with.
Diakite - 7 - See above. But he has already started to realise his potential.
Price - 8 - MOTM. Usual graft. 2 goals. Some player he is.

Barney - 7 - Good work rate, solid pressing, some good hold up play. But way of the standard to be a Championship regular. Plenty to work with though and will be a good option in games where we are battering the opposition.
JJ - 7 - His first touch is buttery smooth, he can pass really well too. Enjoying that bit of edge he seems to have to his game, but need to reign in the moaning at officials.

Subs, - Settled us down and helped us compete again. Styles and Molumby picked up where Aussie and Rabby left off. Bany and Horny showed good touches. Bostock I still think is shite and would tin off.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#5
(08-26-2026, 09:37 PM)Sliced Wrote: Whitwell worth at least an 8 IMO. Absolutely destroyed Lewis Hall that first half. If Hall is a 70 million pound player then Williams is worth 9 figures on that showing

Yeah.... No arguements from me. Especially given the level of opposition.
Reply
#6
As a slight defence of Townsend, he was left isolated and exposed on a number of times tonight with not much help coming from those further forward. I noticed the same on Sunday and I think it's the price we pay for having more attack minded wide midfielders and, given the way we get those players forward quickly, it's something we may have to get used yto.
Reply
#7
I struggled to tell who was who from so high up, vertigo isn't nice! Id go for 8 all round though.
Reply
#8
Great to see Price having another strong game, can't help but be a little concerned there may be a PL side sniffing now too.

It seems odd we'd be speaking to him about a new deal when he has 3 years remaining.
Reply
#9
Ingram 7

Williams 7
Campbell 6.5
Mepham 7
Townsend 6.5

Nzingoula 7
Diakite 8

Whitwell 7.5
Price 8
Morgan 7

Stewart 6.5

Molumby 7
Styles 7
Horn Myhre 7
Bany 7.5
Bostock 6
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)