Honest discussions on alcoholism
#1
Maybe it's the pub chat on here got me thinking , but is it me or is the guidance around alcoholism a real pile of utter steaming puritanical shite these days?

My brother in law killed himself through drink a couple of years back. He'd split up from his Mrs, was living in a bedsit, and from being a normal heavy drinker he turned into one who drank continually from morning to night, consuming a couple of bottles of vodka a day for a good few years. In the end his liver gave out. He'd been warned a few years before going into the liver unit at the local hospital over in Wales.

It'd taken him several years and he was 58.

To me that is someone who is a proper A class alcoholic. 

Behind that is category B, the blokes who get shitfaced in the pub most days, don't eat right and in the end they get cancer or the heart gives out, but you can tell they like the sup too much.

After that there's the ones (Cat C) who have a few most days, but they can miss a day or two. their drinking is only a problem if they are spending money they should be spending elsewhere and the Mrs gives out.

After that  I think anyone else is pretty much OK. I say this as a weekend drinker who binged during my 20s-mid 30s regularly, only on pints, and still in my late 50s have a session of over 6 pints several times a year. Equally I have 3-4 days most weeks I don't touch a drop now. 

According to health guidelines anyone now having over 7 pints a week has a drink problem. What crap.

I know old working class lads who got to their 90s drinking regularly most days.

The holier than thou attitude to it all makes discussing drink these days a bit of a farce.

Happy to hear thoughts as we support a club that'd make most hit the bottle.
Reply
#2
The guidance on both alcohol and drugs is not much use. 7 pints a week is not realistic. In fact it is so unrealistic no one will take notice. I've drank for most of my days although much less now. Out every night when i was single, out with the Mrs or mates, or else in with a bottle of wine and a video for many years. I always said if I couldn't make work next day I would stop but I never missed a day. As I've got older I found I dont need to go out so much, or drink at home. I have probably 4 dry days a week, drink moderately when i am out but still have the odd binge. I learned to cut back, not on medical guidance, but purely when I realised you don't have to be out until the very end of the night and if whatever I was looking for hasn't happened by 11 then it won't happen by 1AM either. I've known drinkers in all of the categories Patels Platoon describes. I know a plasterer that starts early, doesn't stop for breaks for food and is in the pub by 1pm every day, not ideal. I know people that pop out for 3 pints every night and live (apparently) normal lives. I once knew a guy that got so messed up on drugs that although he got  clean he needed just one bottle of cider every evening. Never more than one but he shook and couldn't function without it. I also once had a mate that went all the way, hooked first on speed then later, drink, tranquillisers, heroin, methadone. He got clean and became a compulusive gambler, when he gave up gambling he took up gym membership.  I kid you not he got so hooked on the gym he'd do all day in there! He's no longer with us. 
What I'm banging on about, I suppose, is it takes all sorts and one 7 pints a week recommendation is not going to solve anything. Some sensible,  down to earth, realistic advice from an early age might actually go a long way to preventing social habits becoming dangerous.
Reply
#3
I think your categories are a bit simplistic. There are a lot of problem drinkers or people slowly killing themselves with alcohol hiding in plain sight. Particularly women.
Reply
#4
Many are doing it with food as well given the number of fatties out there.
Reply
#5
(03-18-2026, 07:36 PM)Squid Wrote: I think your categories are a bit simplistic. There are a lot of problem drinkers or people slowly killing themselves with alcohol hiding in plain sight. Particularly women.

I think you’re right regards women. The bored Prosecco o’clock housewives on Facebook all day are plentiful.
I think women choosing wine over beer mostly and being smaller adds to the overall issue they face. 
I think the post is a shade simplistic but don’t think it’s meant to be a deep dive report for Health England, but more a broad brush approach know b what most of us do that the 7 pints a week guideline is farcical, especially when other countries have higher guidelines.
Reply
#6
Like most people I like a good drink but I’ve got a rule nowadays: if I’m on a big one and hit the nightclub, it’s water only for me.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#7
Alcohol consumption seems to be quite a individualistic pursuit, I've never personally understood the desire to drink solo at home as an example. This is despite having parents that regularly cracked open cans of special brew whilst growing up.

These days I don't drink circa 50 weeks a year but I managed to squeeze a lot of units into the 2 that I do, usually around xmas.

I guess I am an irresponsible binge drinker. But at least I can average it down to a few units per week on the doctors forms.
Reply
#8
It was interesting reading the pubs, tax man and GenZ thread on this topic, and I think putting arbitrary amounts of the intake of anything is fine as a guide, but shouldn't be used as a hard and fast rule.

Living over here, alcohol is a way of life... most people I know here will drink majority of days, and most of the younger folk still drink. If you go to the beach any day of the week there will be people with a few cans, and it's not unusual to see a couple old dears sitting outside a cafe with a beer or a vermut at 11am having a chat... indeed, here, it is often advised to drink frequently as long as it is in a social setting... and with the UK going very much down the 14 units a week or more and you'll die route, it's interesting here the guidance still says under 35 is perfectly fine, and the Basque region, where many people will still have wine with lunch most days, suggest 42 is fine.

For me, alcoholism is not linked entirely to the sheer amount you consume, it is around the dependency or need to drink. It can be the need to drink a couple cans of an evening in order to relax, or the inability to socialise without alcohol, or finding it weird when other people choose not to. I think it also manifests when alcohol is no longer a social event, where you find yourself drinking or relying on it at home. It's easy to see it then creep into something much more difficult as the learned behaviour of treating any kind of anxiety with a drink kicks in.

I drink a little more than I probably should, but I can not drink if the mood takes me... I don't believe in doing dry months, or rules like only drinking at the weekend - if that works for you, great - but I would miss that casual beer on a Tuesday because it's sunny and I've bumped into someone, and over here, drinking is all about the sobremesa - the chat around the table. It's again not unusual for people to sit around a table for 2-3 hours and only have 2 bottles of beer all evening. Similarly, you'll only ever see a tourist drinking a pint, it's all 200-300ml glasses here, which I end up drinking at the same speed I'd drink a pint in the UK.

Spain are incidentally running a huge, long term study around whether drinking wine daily is actually bad for your health, and the early results suggest the opposite - a couple glasses and conversation with friends and family is far better for your health than not having that relaxing moment.

So in short, don't degrudge yourself a couple pints with your friends when you want... even if it's every day, it'll probably do you more good than bad... just don't start necking cans alone!
Reply
#9
I never ever crave a drink but when I’m out, I’m out and the large majority of my friends are like that too. It’s the main reason I never tried anything more chemical earlier in life as I recognise I don’t have an “off” button once I start.
Reply
#10
I think you are bang on.
Drinking has always been a common pursuit and the problem with ridiculously low limits is that it dilutes ( no pun intended) the issue. If you waste time telling people who drink socially in moderation that they are overdoing it, you lose sight of the people who genuinely need help.
Same with telling people who are a little overweight but graft every day and eat “normally” that they are obese, when they are clearly not, it corrupts the stats and no one believes it.
If you can go a week without drinking you are not an alky. If you work all week and have a takeaway on Friday, and you can still see your dick, you are not obese.
Thems my onions.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)